Work Category: Perspectives

An Incomplete List of P-Words for Project-Based Pursuits, 2026–Present.

An Incomplete List of P-Words for Project-Based Pursuits

contents

I. An Introduction to An Incomplete List of P-Words for Project-Based Pursuits

P-word sections

  1. Purpose
  2. Process
  3. Prototyping
  4. Play
  5. Perceptuality
  6. Prompts
  7. Parameters
  8. Personality
  9. Pattern
  10. Philosophy
  11. People
  12. Proximity
  13. Portfolios

See Also: An Illustrative Introduction to a Curious Compendium of Incomplete Lists for Productive Practice

—

An Introduction to An Incomplete List of P-Words for Project-Based Pursuits

The word project has fascinating meanings and origins. As a noun, a project may refer to anything ranging from a simple task to a multi-year, 1,000-person effort. This alone makes project a big-tent term. A brief etymological exploration of the the word project reveals that the term was once commonly used to denote the physical act of throwing. This lineage remains evident in present day terms such as projector, projecting, and projectile. “Project” was derived from the Latin verb proicere (or projicere), which the product of two linguistic parts: 1) pro: meaning “forward” or “forth,” and 2) jacere: meaning “to throw.”1 Thus, we might contend that the term project’s ancient ancestor meant “to throw forward.” ¶ Alas, starting in the late 1800s, alongside the rise of the second industrial revolution,2 notions of a project, or that which is “project-based,” began to take on a curious trajectory at the intersections of education, industry, craft, creativity, and more. One of the earliest, most arduous, and most fascinating figures in relation to that which is project-based was John Dewey3 (1859–1952). Dewey was a highly influential American philosopher, psychologist, and educational reformer and is widely considered one of the most prominent public intellectuals of the first half of the 20th century. ¶ Before we briefly explore Dewey’s contribution to our understanding of projects, let’s further frame the vast scope of what a project may encompass today. Later, we will further define the term and its bounds as explored here. As readers are aware, a “project” may encompass everything from painting a wall in your home to group community-based improvement efforts to “hands-on” learning opportunities. But the scale of a project can go much further—from an aeronautics engineering team launch plan to a stadium that accommodates 100,000 fans. As we will see, one-off tasks and multiple-step projects exist on a spectrum, but the two are hierarchically interconnected. ¶ As was noted earlier, Dewey was an early proponent of project-based learning, or, as is often described another way, “learning by doing.” In the context of project-based learning, one of the most common references to Dewey is his 1897 essay titled “My Pedagogic Creed.”4 Dewey’s creed followed a five-part structure that explored the nature of education, the role of the school, subject matter, teaching methods, and the school’s potential connection to matters of social reform. Dewey argued against rote learning, advocating instead for an experience-based curriculum that prepares students with the skills, tools, and sensibilities for their lives, communities, and careers. Over the years, Dewey’s project-based views have expanded into a multitude of varieties, forms, and flavors. These include problem-based learning, active learning, challenge-based learning, inquiry-based learning, and more. ¶ While project-based learning may seem like a no-brainer to some, there are additional perspectives to consider. The most pressing of these, in this list-maker’s view, centers on notions of reflection and contemplation. Said more plainly, if we are focused on project-based doing, what time or space is being made to reflect on those activities, their merit, or intent? Alas, philosophers, scholars, and theorists have long explored these tensions. One of the more recent and prominent of these explorations was led by Donald Schön5 (1930–1997). Schön is best known for developing the concept of “reflective practice.”6 ¶ As we build upon some of the doing-oriented themes explored in An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains, the use of “project-based pursuits” in the title of this section intentionally casts a wide net around all things project-based. Here, this list maker will clumsily define and constrain a project as it is explored here. To do so, I will encapsulate it within three basic parameters by suggesting that a project is: 1) an effort, idea, activity, or goal that 2) requires two or more steps, participants, or both, that 3) may be constrained by a “temporal division of work.”7 With this description in mind, let’s now revisit the aforementioned task-project spectrum. This two-part definition may be fruitful in discerning the subtle differences between these terms. A task may be a one-off isolated chore, whereas a project is plural and systematic in nature. ¶ As we will see, projects and tasks are very much connected to, but also distinct from, designing and “design.” In our design section, we referred to Jones’ change-oriented definition as a reference point. Before we progress further, let’s briefly explore some subtle differences between projects and design. Designing is certainly an activity and usually requires more than one step, but if we adhere to Jones’ framing, design is generally change-oriented. This suggests that design is more limited in scope than projects. Said another way, a project may or may not have a change-oriented goal. For instance, a maintenance, repair, or feasibility project may or may not result in substantial change. ¶ While it may be obvious, it is worth noting that some are better at and more inclined to lead and direct, manage, or produce projects. Not surprisingly, in business, those whose role it is to manage a project often hold the title “project manager.” According to the Project Management Institute, project managers are “organized, goal-oriented professionals who use innovation, creativity, and collaboration to lead projects that make an impact.”8 While some might loathe a project manager for their nagging, when it comes to complex projects, what they offer is invaluable. As with project managers in business, other disciplines use different terms to convey similar project and people-organizing goals and objectives. In the world of film, entertainment, and media, these highly organized individuals who help plan and coordinate projects are typically titled producer(s).9 ¶ Projects exist on a vast range of scales—from the personal to the professional and beyond. As many small business owners will attest, out of necessity, the aforementioned “nagging project manager” may, in that case, be yourself. As such, like design, projects, and our understanding of them are vital. As we posit projects outside of business, we might conclude that writing an essay is a project, running for office is a project, and cleaning your room (likely the least exciting of projects) is a project. In An Illustrative Introduction to a Curious Compendium of Incomplete Lists for Productive Practice, this list-maker cites designer Bruce Mau’s use of the term “context projects.” This wonderful hybrid frame suggests that projects can, and often are, informed by and framed within notions of context. Without getting academic, we might just posit context as the things that surround or inform the thing, the thing in this case being the project or the outcome of the project. We will touch on projects and things later in this introduction. For now, let’s just note that understanding context in the context of projects is essential because projects (or problems) rarely exist in a vacuum. Alas, claims of things that inform things may sound like a bunch of “fluff.” Thus, let’s briefly break apart the value and intent of such discourse.

The Oddity of Objects, subjects and Things

Without delving too deeply into philosophy, when using a term as big and vast as project, we might assume that any description of a possible outcome of a project would likewise be varied or vast: things, if you will. “Things” in this case might serve as a catch-all for both physical and abstract entities. As we parse things, to thicken the soup, let’s now ponder the term “object” into the mix. It might be said that all objects are things, but not all things are objects. This bit of linguistic trickiness stems from a longstanding philosophical relationship or “polarity” between objects and subjects.10 Traditionally, in philosophy, the subject was understood to represent “the observer” and the object as “the observed.” While this seems straightforward enough, as we will see, things get strangely complex. ¶ As noted above, in philosophy, the subject is the observer and the object is the thing observed—but let’s now imagine a student walking into a psychology lab to take a memory test; in this case, they are considered the subject, not the object. This somewhat strange occurrence or “historical flip” is the product of what scholars call a linguistic inversion11—where a single word evolves to mean its own exact opposite: in his case, the meaning of the term subject, depends on whether you are standing in a philosophy hall or a psychology lab. In each space, the word means the complete opposite. Of course, this creates a paradox around the term “object,” which in philosophy meant a physical object, and then in science came to mean the conscious observing human mind. ¶ As we explore varios notions and projects, this brief diversion into epistemology and linguistics is worth noting in that the intended outcome of a project, especially for design-oriented projects, may be a physical object. This list maker is most certainly not the first to stumble upon this strange jumble of meanings that seem to shift across disciplines and contexts. A recent example might be an anthology titled Encountering Things: Design and Theories of Things. In the Introduction to Encountering Things, the editors, Leslie Atzmon and Prasad Boradkar, indirectly touch on the aforementioned issues. As the editors note: “Since the Enlightenment, in the West we have tended to divide the world ideologically along material and non-material lines. Western culture has positioned objects: things and bodies—or material entities—as both inferior to and in service to subjects: words, ideas, and the mind—or non-material entities in a object-subject polarity.”12 The editors note that with “the material turn”13 theorists no longer viewed objects as secondary to subjects.14 ¶ Complicating this discourse further is the fact that many designers are now designing “things” that are not objects in the traditional physical sense. Some examples include interaction design, experience design, and more. Designing an experience, for instance, may or may not require a real physical component. ¶ With all this in mind, let’s build upon our working definition of a project by adding a third clarifier: 1) an effort, idea, activity, or goal that 2) requires two or more steps, participants, or both, 3) with the goal of developing or exploring an entity, subject, object, or thing.

Be a Purveyor of Projects

As we engage in projects of various types and scales, this exploratory literature review aims to bring special attention to the concept of projects at their nebulously interconnected intersections. Across the p-words that follow, we will parse these project-based intersections, how they are enacted, communicated, and shared. Another goal will be to address some project-oriented pitfalls, paradoxes, and myths. ¶ As we posit projects, at this juncture, this list-maker should briefly bring to light a series of “gaps” that commonly surface across and within projects and practice. Firstly, and somewhat connected to the aforementioned notions of reflective practice, in academia and industry alike, there exists what some theorists call the praxis gap, which might be described as the disconnect between theory and practice. While this may seem unnecessarily academic at first, an understanding of this issue at this juncture is prudent. To better understand it, we need to take stock of the drivers that inform this gap. First, let’s briefly consider the traditional reward systems that surround practitioners and professionals. ¶ In the professional world, projects are often measured and judged by their outputs and outcomes. Depending on the market, those outputs might be measured by financial value, brand value, or other indicators of success, satisfaction, or improvement. Traditionally, the academy was the opposite: outputs were measured and valued in more scholarly and intellectual terms: citations, publications, lectures and other forms of recognition. The arts add even more complexity to this discourse as artistic “projects” may be neither market-oriented nor scholarly in the textual sense. ¶ In light of this fragmentation, in academia, several activity-oriented terms have emerged at these intersections of thinking and doing. For instance, those whose work tends to be project-based, issue-based, or community-based is sometimes described as “engaged.”15 Along these lines, in the social sciences, research that is project-based and also engaged is sometimes referred to as “action research.”16 In the sciences, those pursuing scholarship, projects, or research that is generally viewed as more directly “practical” or “beneficial” are sometimes described as pursuing translational17 research. While these terms may seem academic or esoteric, as we parse notions of projects, such terms firstly provide us with some artiture, and secondly are worth pondering—from the professor, to the plumber, to the pulmonologist—understanding the vast nature of projects, and thus exploring the timeless tensions and relationships between knowing and doing, is worthy of our time, study, and consideration. ¶ Similar to the praxis gap, as readers will likely recall from An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains, is the somewhat related notion described as the “Knowing Doing Gap.” Unlike the praxis gap, this second gap often describes the disconnect between possessing knowledge and actually executing it. These project-oriented “gaps” serve to remind us of the potential pitfalls that surface across projects of varying scales and disciplines.¶ One productive way to parse some of these introductory themes is to briefly consider the work of the American educator Ernest L. Boyer18 (1928–1995). Boyer’s contributions are worth noting in the context of projects, as his teaching, leadership, and advocacy might help students assert, navigate, and understand these action-theory-oriented relationships in a more nuanced fashion. In 1990, Boyer published his landmark book, Scholarship Reconsidered: Priorities of the Professoriate. In the book, Boyer’s introduced four flavors, or “dimensions” of scholarship: the scholarship of discovery, the scholarship of integration, the scholarship of application (or engagement), and the scholarship of teaching and learning.19 As we traversed our c-words and d-words, we previously encountered several of Boyer’s dimensions. Discovery, for instance, was one of our d-words. ¶ Within and outside of academia, Boyer’s dimensions of scholarship are noted here, such that students might thoughtfully posit the big-tent variety and various flavors of projects: from art projects to research projects, classroom projects to community-engaged projects, corporate projects to craft projects, and more. With hope that such discourse might potentially elevate your particular practice, this list maker will once again contend that understanding project-based perspectives is worthy of study, time, and attention.


P-Words


  1. Purpose: For reasons unknown, some view projects, especially creative projects and pursuits, with a misaligned sense that these peculiar practitioners are simply following their internal “passion.” In this list-maker’s observation, this is rarely the case. As I’ve gotten to know and work with artists, scientists, scholars, engineers, business leaders, and others interested in project-based practices, they more often cite “purpose” as a broader driver than passion. Purpose may inform an intrinsic or extrinsic desire to do something because it matters. It’s extrinsic because it involves other people and intrinsic because the drive is informed by your internal passion. What drives this purpose may vary widely from the pragmatic to the personal. Those who are purpose-driven may not be passionate about what they do, and those who are passionate may or may not have a purpose. ¶ Along these lines, projects may be commenced for a variety of reasons. They can be for oneself, for others, or both. In a section of the 1969 book Meaning in Architecture titled “Semiology and Architecture,” Charles Jencks20 (1939–2019) notes that “man has certain inborn dispositions to expect recurrent patterns, or to be more exact, he is always asking the environment questions. It is this curious purposeful [emphasis added] side, which completely permeates his nature…..”21 While much can be subjectively gleaned or interpreted from this quote, the reason for its inclusion here rests with Jencks’ pairing of the curious to the purposeful—which seems apt as we posit big-tent notions projects. As Jencks suggests, humans always seem to be asking questions, and one can only assume that Jencks (a cultural theorist, landscape designer, and architectural historian) understood that projects are one way that humans answer questions. ¶ On the more pragmatic and systematic side of a project and purpose, we encounter a vast range of roles, methods, products, and approaches that attempt to “manage” projects, or said another way, to ideally maintain a focus on the goals, budgets, timing, and purpose of projects. In the world of media, film, design, and entertainment, those who manage projects often take on the title producer, while in the worlds of business, architecture, and other fields, those who help steer and manage projects (no surprises here) often have the title project manager. ¶ In the world of business, Antonio Nieto-Rodriguez seems to have zeroed in on the importance of projects. Nieto-Rodriguez has written numerous books22 and articles that explore projects and project management in depth. In the context of purpose, in 2021, Nieto-Rodriguez published an article in Harvard Business Review titled “Does Your Project Have a Purpose?”23 In the article, Nieto-Rodriguez recounts a well-known story from the world of architecture, which is likewise summarized here. ¶ In 1957, the Danish architect Jørn Utzon submitted a proposal for a large-scale performance space in Australia. Out of 230 submissions from over 30 countries, Utzon’s proposal was selected for having the “most original and creative solution.”24 As Nieto-Rodriguez notes in his article, “In the end, the project was delayed a decade—it took 14 years to complete—and it exceeded its budget by 1,300%. The state lottery paid for much of the $95 million cost overrun, diverting money from other public expenditures.”25 Provocatively, Nieto-Rodriguez then asks readers if such a project might be considered a “complete disaster.” If you have not already guessed, the project described is the now internationally known and culturally iconic Sydney Opera House. By recounting the story, Nieto-Rodriguez attempts to put his readers in a position to question purpose, value, success, risk, failure, and more—all in the context of a single architectural project. Nieto-Rodriguez then cites data suggesting that purpose-driven companies outperform others in categories such as innovation and transformation.26 This list maker will only add that one can have a vision with no real purpose, but a purpose can most certainly fuel a vision. ¶ In summary, as we posit projects, paying particular attention to purpose can be paramount. From the scientific to the humanistic and everything in between, a purpose can vary widely. Beyond this, those who can understand and articulate this purpose, its meaning, value, and substance are typically well-equipped to lead. Those who can manage projects likewise possess valuable team-oriented, humanistic skills. And while a completed project always seems like the most fruitful outcome, as many will attest, the process is sometimes just as valuable as the final product.

  2. Process: Not to unnecessarily digress into art school nostalgia, this list maker recalls a pervasive, nearly unspoken rule from his time in art school. It seemed that every studio professor I encountered insisted on it and wanted to see concrete evidence of it alongside nearly any project. This rule was to document your process. ¶ For this list maker, this insistence on documenting process at first seemed quite odd. At the time, I remember thinking, “Gosh. I did all this work to make this thing—and all my professor wants to see and talk about is this file folder full of photos, sketches, and photocopies.” ¶ Looking back on it, this emphasis, if not insistence, on process very much made sense—especially in the world of projects and ideas. ¶ In what may have been a dream, I recall a classmate raising their hand and asking an instructor, “What is the process for developing a process?” In response, the art school instructor responds, “You need to find your process.” Then, the student, half-embarrassedly asks, “But where does one start?” ¶ As we seek answers to this timeless process-oriented question, we will first turn to the American novelist and nonfiction writer Anne Lamott.27 Lamott’s father, Kenneth Lamott28 was also a writer, and it was in fact her account of her father’s wisdom on the subject at hand that she is perhaps best known. This bit of process-oriented wisdom can be found in Lamott’s 1994 book Bird by Bird: Some Instructions on Writing and Life. In Lamott’s best-selling book, she recalls her then ten-year-old brother attempting to write a report on birds. Overwhelmed and behind schedule, her father saddled up next to him and offered this advice: “Bird by bird, buddy. Just take it bird by bird.”29 ¶ As a seasoned writer, Lamott’s father states what may seem obvious: once you get something written, it can be edited, added to, expanded upon, refined, altered, and more. In other words, just get started. In the world of writing, we often call this a draft, but in nearly every discipline and domain, there’s an analog, be it a sketch, model, experiment, rehearsal, and so on. No matter the project, problem, or goal at hand, Lamott’s bird-by-bird advice seems to have resonated with a generation of writers and makers of all kinds. ¶ As we ponder big tent notions of process in project-based work, a paradox of sorts emerges. While process adds structure to our work, that structure can occasionally provide the creative with freedom to explore. This may seem odd, as in popular culture, creativity is often associated with wild, chaotic, or bohemian notions of the artist. Along these lines, design educator Lefteris Heretakis once noted that, “A structured process may initially seem counterintuitive to the free-spirited nature of creativity. Many people associate creativity with freedom, exploration, and breaking the rules. However, in design, there is profound freedom in structure. A process provides a reliable pathway for creativity to flow, offering the scaffolding on which ideas can be built, tested, and refined.”30 ¶ With Heretakis’ notes structure and process in mind, let’s recall the aforementioned process-oriented culture of the art school. When the instructor wanted to see sketches, she actually wanted to see “where students have been” and “what they were looking at.” It should be noted that the terms “method” and “process” are closely related yet differ significantly, especially across contexts.31 The scientific method32 for instance, is generally based on empirical steps and collections of evidence in pursuit of a conclusion. The creative process is generally viewed as a “journey” in which the destination may or may not be known. Some “projects”—especially design-oriented ones may utilize both of these approaches. ¶ Since this p-word list set out to introduce broad concepts around project-based practices, notions of process naturally lead us to a timeless term that helps creatives of a wide variety advance ideas in an advanced “bird by bird” manner, such that feedback, iteration, testing, comparison, and other factors can be considered and potentially incorporated or removed. That term is prototyping.

  3. Prototyping: If we break the term “prototype” down into its two etymological parts, we get prōtos, meaning “first” or “earliest,” and typos, meaning “impression,” “mold,” or “model.” Interestingly, it appears that the term “prototype” was not widely in verb form until the early to mid-19th century. As is noted below, there is plenty that has been written about prototyping, especially in the context of architecture, innovation, engineering, and design. But alas, by returning to the term’s roots, we can ponder its essence: unlike a mockup, presentation, or sketch, a prototype is often one step closer to reality—one that actively seeks feedback through testing, validation, or demonstration. Prototypes can range in material, functionality, and scale, with these factors also informing the “fidelity”33 of the prototype. For instance, a low-fidelity prototype of a vehicle may be rendered by hand in clay at 1/8 scale, while a high-fidelity prototype may be full scale and perhaps even drivable. High-fidelity prototypes may also possess near-final aesthetic choices in color or materials. ¶ As noted above, prototyping has long been viewed as a central facet of project-based approaches. Entries and perspectives on prototyping can be found in Bella Martin and Bruce Harrington’s Universal Methods of Design,34 Lidwell et al.’s Universal Principles of Design,35 and Gjoko Muratovski’s Research for Designers,36 and more. For educators, practitioners, and students alike, the “Prototyping” section 3637 in Jones et al.’s open-access volume, Studio Properties, is both informative, well-researched, and concise. Within the Prototyping section of Studio Properties, the authors note that “Prototyping is a way of gaining knowledge through making.”38 Even a glance at the authors’ subheads alone helps one formulate a sense of the interest and value that prototyping offers. For instance, the second headline reads, “Prototyping focuses on aspects of a design, not the whole.”39 All one needs to do is walk into nearly any respectable architecture or design studio to see prototypes on display. In many cases, teams of designers may develop dozens or even hundreds of prototypes, each parsing one particular aspect of a larger project or problem from varied perspectives. ¶ Lastly, the authors of Studio Properties note that “Prototyping creates knowledge that is both contingent and explicit.”40 With this statement in mind, we might think back to our d-word section on “Discursivity”—in particular, how artifacts as things can also serve as springboards for discussion, analysis, speculation, and more. Also, regarding this latter point, prototyping often demands a sensibility we were all familiar with as children, but one that is all too often lost. Somewhere between prototyping and discovery, we find the very human notion of play.

  4. Play: Akin to prototyping, much has been written about play in the context of project-based and studio practices. It’s not at all surprising then to find that Jones et al. precede their section on prototyping with a scholarly exploration of play.41 Rather than recount that section here, this list maker will emphasize the intersection of learning, projects, and play. Scholarly explorations of play have a rich and fascinating history. From Friedrich Fröbel42 (1782–1852) to Caroline Pratt43 (1867–1954) to Jean Piaget44 (1896–1980), Lev Vygotsky45 (1896–1934), and many more—theorists, psychologists, and educators have researched and written extensively about the critical role of play in making, learning, and more. Several of these figures have argued that play is a primary vehicle through which children construct knowledge, develop social-emotional skills, and build a lifelong love of learning. ¶ One recent figure who seems to have embraced this play-oriented lifelong love of learning is MIT’s Mitchel Resnick.46 In 1992, Resnick formed a research lab aptly called the Lifelong Kindergarten group.47 Resnick’s group examines how technology can help people of all ages learn through creative expression ¶ In 2017, Resnick’s book Lifelong Kindergarten: Cultivating Creativity through Projects, Passion, Peers, and Play was released. In the book, Resnick draws upon his many years of teaching and research to explore modes of learning at the intersection of several p-words. In fact, four out of the six chapters are p-word themed. In order, the p-words are: projects, passion, peers, and (you guessed it) play. To help frame his argument, in Chapter 1, titled “Creative Learning,” Resnick states what remains ever true nearly ten years later—that we seem to be in a period of rapid change thanks to “a constant flow of new technologies, new sources of information, and new communication channels.”48 In response, Resnick suggests that “For people to flourish in this rapidly changing landscape, the ability to think and act creatively is more important than ever.”49 ¶ Resnick explores these ideas through the aforementioned p-words, but especially through the lens of play. Resnick’s exploration of play connect across several themes we’ve explored, from prototyping to discovery to experimentation and more. To be clear, Resnick’s lab is not a narrow investigation of toys and games. Instead, Resnick seems to leverage play-oriented behaviors and processes towards learning—be that through toys, games, pedagogy, and more. One well-known project that grew out of Resnick’s group is a highly interactive visual programming language called Scratch.50 Scratch makes learning to code more akin to a puzzle than a problem. Through projects like Scratch, Resnick shows how play-based notions of tinkering, calculated risk, boundary testing, and more can be incorporated into products, projects, classrooms, curricula, and more. ¶ Many years before Resnick, in the 1840s, Friedrich Fröbel, who is briefly mentioned at the outset of this section, designed a series of educational toys now commonly called Froebel gifts.51 Like Resnick, Froebel was an educator and inventor. Froebel’s toys consist of a structured sequence of geometric materials designed to help children internalize interconnected notions of logic, math, perception, and the physical world through self-directed play. These gifts are said to have been used in childhood by several prominent architects, including Frank Lloyd Wright. ¶ Like film directors of the physical world, architects are masters of human perception. By this, one might say that architects and other designers are concerned not only with how a space performs but also with how those who occupy it might perceive it, or how they might feel in a particular space or place. This fuzzy skill might be described as perceptuality.

  5. Perceptuality: As part of this literature review, this list maker naively sought out the term perceptuality. This search largely yielded what we might expect, perceptuality defined as “the quality of being perceptual”—but, at the time of this writing, not much more. Thankfully, there is well-established research and language around the notion of perceptual learning.52 Even so, in “bird-by-bird” fashion, this list maker kept asking: why insist on this particular variation of word perception within this particular list concerning projects? ¶ For many years, this list maker (who happens to be a graphic designer) would, in fact, encounter the word “perceptual” on a nearly daily basis. As many a graphic designer will attest, the term “perceptual” often appears as an option in graphic design software, especially when dealing with color in printing, exporting, or saving images. According to Adobe, a perceptual option, “Delivers colors that are natural for human eyes.”53 Perceptions, as we are all aware, come in a variety of flavors that are shaped by the human senses. ¶ By delving into notions of perception, this entry could more easily devolve into long-standing debates and discourses between rationalism and empiricism.54 Likewise, by adding “ity” to perceptual, scholars could infer a connection to scholarly notions of textuality55 or visuality. In fact, what is being explored here is much more project-focused and pedestrian. ¶ In his use of the term “pedestrian,” this list-maker is attempting to be clever. By this, we might infer that, in our use of “perceptuality,” it denotes the metaphorical concept of taking perception “for a walk.” As it turns out, one of the most productive ways to take notions of perception for a walk is through a project. Before I provide a more concrete example, let’s briefly note another designer’s more specific use of taking an idea for a walk. ¶ Paul Klee (1879–1940) was a Swiss-born German artist who taught at the legendary Bauhaus. In 1953, an English translation of his book Pedagogical Sketchbook was first published. The Pedagogical Sketchbook was originally published in 1925 as part of a series published by the Bauhaus school. Klee’s book outlines several theories of art and design, with a particular focus on the fundamental elements of line, form, and color, drawing on scientific, mathematical, and intuitive concepts. In the first of dozens of black and white figures that appear in the book, Klee attempts to show, “An active line on a walk, moving freely, without goal.”56 The English-translated edition of Pedagogical Sketchbook includes a concluding note, written by Sibyl Moholy-Nagy57 (who translated the book). Moholy-Nagy’s note includes the following text: “There are endless phenomena all around us on which to aim Klee’s ideas like a searchlight. The ‘line on a walk’ can produce new rhythmic curves. Any surface offers itself for definition through line-connected points.”58 Alas, like a line between two points, perceptuality identifies possible points (these being perceptions and perspectives)—and then lines of connection. Perceptuality then suggests a sensitivity towards connection. ¶ While there are countless project-based examples of perceptuality—a classic example of perceptual thinking might be Josef Albers’59 (1888–1976) series of paintings titled Homage to the Square.60 As it turns out, Alberts was a close collaborator of Klee. While Klee returned to Switzerland, Alberts went on to become one of the most influential 20th-century art teachers in the United States. The Homage to the Square series explored the perceptual relationships of color, and Albers’s work exemplifies this idea to an extreme. To accomplish this, Albers meticulously painted nested squares in various colors, knowing that the perceptual “interaction”61 between the colors would be relative (not absolute). ¶ With perceptuality in mind, what materials, ideas, or perspectives will you imagine, plot, or connect? While this list maker is resistant to jumping into the fray of discourse around AI, in the context of perceptuality, it may be worth noting a list of ten predictions by Neil Leach in the second edition (2025) of his book Architecture in the Age of Artificial Intelligence. While this list maker will not list all ten predictions, he will, with some caution, include just the last two. Leach suggests that, by the end of the decade, it will be “technically possible—although not perhaps implemented universally” to (#10) “design a building completely autonomously.”62 Prededing this on the list appears to be a cautionary note from Leach, which states, (#9) “The architecture profession will be disrupted.”63 ¶ By recounting Leach’s predictions here, one might further ponder or elevate humanistic qualities of perceptuality—in architecture, perhaps, but in many fields that require such understandings. ¶ Before moving on, and thinking back to Klee, in the business world, the metaphorical “connective points” of projects alluded to in this section are sometimes presented to us as particular problems, with such problems often articulated in a prospectus, a deck (presentation deck), or a brief. In the creative world, such ideas may similarly be framed within a proposal, script, or even the dreaded work order. But in an educational setting, where the risk of project failure is lowered, these creative kickstarters are often catalyzed as prompts.

  6. Prompts: “Begin anywhere and follow the flow.”64 That’s in part what Stephen Nachmanovitch suggests at the outset of the “Twists and Turns” section in his 2019 book The Art of Is: Improvising as a Way of Life. Nachmanovitch expands upon this advice by providing readers with guidance and assurance around the creative principle of free association.65 Much like in everyday conversation, where one thing so easily leads to the next, Nachmanovitch explains how notions of artistic improvisation apply to everyday living. While Nachmanovitch66 (an improvisational violinist and teacher) makes this improvisational attitude sound somewhat intuitive, as many creative educators can attest, telling students to “begin anywhere” often falls embarrassingly flat. Moreover, it may result in blank stares or glares. Thus, for what seems like ages, creative educators and leaders alike have devised strategies to get things moving in the right direction. The devices have traditionally been called prompts (or “project prompts”) ¶ There are endless examples and varieties of creative prompts, but for our p-word purposes, let’s return to Anne Lamott. At some point, Lamott began giving writing workshops, and in her book, she recounts how students’ day-one enthusiasm quickly fades as the challenge of writing something actually worth reading mounts. As Lamott recounts, eventually one or more students crack and state what many a creative educator has heard countless times: “I don’t even know where to start.”67 ¶ Here is where the art of the prompt comes into play. Lamott provides her writing students with some prompt-like threads: for new writers, she suggests starting with childhood and then guides students through a series of more detailed, specific questions to spark memories, connections, and more. ¶ Those who work on project-based anything know just how important prompts are in shaping, framing, guiding, and informing a wide variety of work. It is somewhat odd, then, that with AI and other technologies on the rise, the notion of prompting has taken on a whole new dimension. ¶ Along these lines, in some strange way, the creative educator of the future may need to let students “behind the curtain” in the sense that they, too, will need to understand the art of the prompt. Just as this list is being penned, a whole host of papers and courses on “prompt engineering” seem to be on the rise—various practices of and for designing inputs for technology-based tools. What’s even more bizarre, at least for designers, is that we have long used the term “table” as a metaphor for those (stakeholders) who contribute to a design. Without digressing too far into speculation, it would seem that the notion of those table-based conversations about the design may, over time, become the actual design process. ¶ As we ponder the prompt, this list maker might bring to light an emerging trend in the culinary arts. It hsoudl be noted that, in a time when chefs have access to a vast array of ingredients from all around the world, and with many of those raw ingredients vailable at faster speeds and at lower cost—some chefs seem to be heading into “zag” mode: decidedly sourcing ingredients that are locally produced, avialble only in season, or even growing herbs, fruits, and vegetables themselves. If you look closer, you will discover 21st-century chefs and restaurateurs building strategic local and global relationships with select farmers, fisheries, and other suppliers and partners. ¶ Now let’s circle back to projects and prompts. The chef’s zag-like self-imposed constraints can be viewed as prompts. What can be made with only x, y, and z? ¶ Here I must note the brilliance of some of the prompts I encountered in graduate school. One was simply “you are here.” The constraint, then, is framed by these three very open-ended words in the context of dynamic media (in my case). A second, which was brilliant in its symbolism, was a piece of thread. Each student was given a few inches of thread and was told to generate media concepts around it. ¶ More than ever, we are globally interconnected—goods, materials, and information seem to move across time and place at ever-accelerating rates, at lower cost and with greater efficiency. One way to parse this ever-present deluge of information, material, and complexity is to break it down into smaller, more manageable chunks.68 Those chunks can represent content, materials, tasks, and more. Yet as we ponder projects, one chunking-like p-word in particular is worth pondering: parameters.

  7. Parameters: Projects, big and small, usually have some sort of parameters. While definitions vary, parameters are factors that inform, shape, or limit a project, process, or function. Parameters inform projects in similar ways to contexts, but are generally more quantifiable. Parameters have long served as a foundational pillar in architecture, design, music, art, computational engineering, systems design, and more. In music composition, a time signature or tempo are but two easily understood parameters. ¶ Setting or understanding parameters establishes a functional limitation on a project. Access to this information at the outset of any given project is invaluable. In part, this is because a shared understanding of parameters helps creatives and teams of creatives maintain a consistent view of limitations, constraints, and opportunities. ¶ As is indicated above, the term parameters spans disciplines and domains. That said, some practitioners, especially architects and engineers, have leaned into the term in ways that have directly shaped projects and discourses alike. In architecture, one prominent voice around these discourses is Patrik Schumacher.69 In fact, Schumacher, a German architect, is said to have coined the term parametricism, a term used to describe parametric architecture70 and parametric design.71 While definitions vary, these varied uses of “parametric” may account for varied inputs and outputs affecting a design. Schumacher seemed to be on the avant-garde of all things parametric—using various technologies and approaches to manipulate those inputs and outputs to shape or inform form and content. ¶ As readers may recall, in the d-word section on data, we recounted the 41 Shades of Blue saga, which helped frame various discourses around data-driven design. Such discourses also emerge at the intersection of parametric approaches, technologies, and design. For instance, in a recent article published by Dezeen, Catherine Slessor gives all things parametric a particularly pointed critique. As Slessor states, “Ceding control to the algorithm, parametricism is even more disconnected, a reductivist, technophile triumph of fetishised process over outcome. Perhaps it will quietly atrophy, as decon did, and be superseded by the next big thing.”72 ¶ While this brief diversion into design discourse risks readers towards a discursive ditch, students might ponder the dialogic factors such as efficiency versus homogeneity, computation versus craft, evidence versus intuition. The fact that parameters and the parametric can spark so much debate in architecture tells us one thing for sure: more of us should meaningfully engage in such discourse. ¶ Like so many subjects that have succumbed to specialization, texts and discourses relating to parameters are generally discipline-specific, but there are also some broad principles that apply to many fields. One example is the Pareto principle73 (more commonly referred to as the 80:20 rule). This principle describes a phenomenon many have tacitly observed: that a generally small percentage of factors or variables (~20) result in, or are responsible for, most of the behaviors or outcomes (~80). For example, this list-maker is using a word processor to type these notes. Generally, in the process of composing and editing this text, this list maker uses only a fraction (~20%) of the tools most of the time (~80%). While this is anecdotal, such principles commonly inform software and interaction design. But, as we know, assumptions are sometimes but not always correct—this is why, when appropriate, designers rely on principles of human-centered design74 and usability testing.75 Testing helps designers understand trade-offs between flexibility,76 performance, and more. Sometimes, as we know “the solution” may actually be “many solutions” as one size does not always fit all. ¶ While notions of parameters certainly inform buildings and products, even planting a raised-bed garden requires identifying some basic parameters: the size of the bed, the average weather conditions, access to water, soil, and more. And beyond these parameters, we might ask: who is going to plant the plants? Who is going to water the plants? Who is in charge—or are we all in charge? In project work, questions around who does what and why are as old as time. Using our raised bed garden examples, the garden team role you wish to assume may, in fact, depend on your personality.

  8. Personalities: Contributing to a group project can be extremely rewarding. All too often, however, members of a group project experience frustration, miscommunication, and other issues. Thinking back to our 80:20 rule, in this case, it is not uncommon to hear complaints when one person does 80% of the work. One way to prepare for group projects is to develop a working vocabulary around personalities. In this case, personality is used as a big-tent term to encapsulate our working styles, communication styles, preferences, attitudes, and more. The most basic definition of personality is simply the “quality or state of being a person.”77 And surely there is truth to the saying, “no two humans are alike.” It is well known and extremely well researched78 that our personalities inform and affect our working styles. ¶ One common way that researchers describe personality is the Big Five model,79 sometimes called the “Big Five personality traits” or the OCEAN model. OCEAN, in this case, stands for openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism.80 ¶ At this juncture, readers might ask, how does this all relate to projects, and why does it matter? While positing this question, this list maker is reminded of a “future of design” workshop he attended at an architecture firm. The workshop was led by the editor of a well-known design publication, and as part of the discussion, this editor suggested that traditionally, those who worked in architecture were placed in one of three distinct camps: 1) sellers, 2) thinkers, and 3) doers. In one of the more memorable exchanges that followed, the editor surmised that in the 21st century, these three silos would likely “become blurred.” After hearing this from the editor, the list maker noted that, generally, it was the more extraverted staffers who would, unsurprisingly, volunteer to serve as the “sellers.” One office I worked for, in fact, called these communicative extroverts “best sellers.” While some designers excelled at presenting their own work, others preferred to have their concepts presented by another member of the film, project, or team—a “seller,” as the journal’s editor described. ¶ The notion of “thinkers” also aligns with aspects of the aforementioned Big Five model. These team members seem to excel at exploration, openness, and conscientiousness. ¶ The point in recounting this “future of design” workshop from 20 years ago is that it helps exemplify some of the useful research at the intersection of people and projects. ¶ The design publication editor’s three-point example can be identified in a number of project-oriented settings and pursuits. For instance, it is even exemplified in the founding of Apple. While most people are only aware of Steve Jobs as “the founder” of Apple, there were actually two more founders involved. Besides Jobs, there were Steve Wozniak and Ronald Wayne. Of the three, Jobs was likely the most charismatic (the seller), while Wozniak seemed like a classic tinkerer (the doer). Ronald Wayne brought past expertise from his time at Atari81 and likely served as a more pragmatic counterpoint to Jobs’ ambition. ¶ In art school, it is quite common, if not cliché, to hear instructors suggest that one should “put themselves into their work.” This advice shows up similarly when instructors encourage students to “develop a voice” or a “unique point of view.” While the intent is clear, this list-maker has long questioned a paradox that often surfaces in critique. During critiques, instructors in creative courses often remind students that critical feedback is directed at the work, not them. This, of course, is meant to depersonalize the feedback. For this list maker, this “put yourself in the work, but the work is not you” dynamic always seemed quite paradoxical. For now, let’s label this dialogic mismatch the project personality paradox, which yields the following question: is the maker of a thing ever not a factor in the making of a thing? ¶ With this question and the aforementioned paradox in mind, let’s imagine a scientist joining the class. With an almost dismissive tone, the objective scientist locks eyes with the art instructor and states, “For the projects I undertake, my voice and hand are invisible.” The art student remains quiet while the two prepare to square off. Then the art instructor pipes up with a rebuttal, “Is the human hand ever completely invisible?” With this, the debate abruptly ends. Then, perhaps to lighten the mood, the instructor suggests the three take a break and get espressos in the nearby piazza. Upon hearing this, the scientist suggests that tea in the courtyard would be much preferred, as it is one minute closer.

  9. Pattern: Years ago, while working in the Marketing department of an architecture firm, this list maker was asked to collaborate with the IT department on an initiative to make templates and other marketing materials more accessible to all firm staff. A day or two before we were scheduled to meet to kick off the project, the IT Director emailed this list maker in advance of the meeting. Attached was a PDF file and a short note advising me to review it before we met. ¶ Of course, this list maker expected that attachment to be some sort of primer on asset or access management or corporate intranets. Instead, the email attachment contained a copy of “Solving for Pattern,”—a seminal 1980 essay by the American farmer, philosopher, and writer Wendell Berry82 (1934–2026). “Solving for Pattern,” was first published in Berry’s literary collection The Gift of Good Land. After glancing at the attachment, I scratched my head and wondered why the Director of IT would send a reflective treatise on agriculture in preparation for a brand management project. ¶ “Solving for Pattern” reflects upon the complex and entangled nature of agricultural and ecological systems. Since the attachment seemed unrelated to corporate templates, I sensed I should read “Solving for Pattern” as a metaphor or proverb for the type of project or problem we were about to explore. Reading Berry’s essay shifted how I think about problems, especially how “solving” a specific problem might inadvertently create new or unforeseen ones. ¶ After reading the essay, my initial takeaway was threefold: 1) a design solution, like any sort of solution, is always entangled within a whole host of interconnected concerns: resources, energy, contexts, systems, and more. 2) Any attempt at a holistic solution thus requires some degree of equally entangled holistic thinking; and 3) designers have much to learn from nature, ecosystems, and yes, even farming, food, and agriculture. ¶ The first sentence in Berry’s essay sharply frames the reflective but tacitly informed thesis that follows. Berry states, “Our dilemma in agriculture now is that the industrial methods that have so spectacularly solved some of the problems of food production have been accompanied by ‘side effects’ so damaging as to threaten the survival of farming.”83 Then, in support of my metaphorical reading of the essay, the author himself briefly nods to such potential with the following line: “To the problems of farming, then, as to other problems of our time….”84 ¶ Years later, in his project-based courses, this list maker began assigning visual pattern-making projects in his introductory design courses. While these studio foundations projects center on aesthetics, they also offer an opportunity to explore big-tent notions of pattern. Beyond aesthetics, pattern recognition is becoming a valuable 21st-century competency across many fields. Indeed, cognitive scientists and educational theorists emphasize that pattern recognition underlies academic success across diverse subjects.85 ¶ One interesting aspect of having students explore patterns is there’s no exacting standard for what makes a pattern “good.” Patterns can be simple or complex, systematic or organic, logical, and at times illogical. Along these evaluative lines, Berry concludes “Solving for Pattern” with a 14-point list of provisional standards that attempt to articulate and discern “good solutions.” For example, the first of these points reads, “A good solution accepts given limits, using so far as possible what is at hand.”86 ¶ It soon became obvious why my IT Director sent along Berry’s essay days before kicking off a systems-oriented project. With nearly any problem or project-based effort, one should never lose sight of “the obvious”—the obvious in this case represents the interconnected and entangled nature of the problem—and crucially the forces, contexts, and factors that surround it. As Berry stated in his third point, “A good solution improves the balances, symmetries, or harmonies within a pattern.”87 ¶ For creatives, designers, and project-minded people, understanding various notions of pattern is an essential competency that supports and affords the ability to make connections across and between language, aesthetics, information, and ideas. While this ability isn’t rare, being skilled and practiced at it is. With this in mind, it may strike some readers of this list as odd that Berry, a farmer, was also a deeply reflective, nearly philosophical writer and thinker. This somewhat odd combination of concerns arriving at the intersection of head, heart and hand will be explored in the next two sections.

  10. Philosophy: For project-based practitioners, encountering thinker-doers such as the farmer-philosopher Wendell Berry [explored in the previous section on pattern] may at first seem like an odd combination of interests. But alas, this intersection of doing and thinking is consistently a hallmark of many project-oriented people. It is no surprise, then, to discover a rich body of literature at the intersection of philosophy and project-based practices, especially design. Below I will cite a few examples that, with any luck, will briefly serve to illuminate the vitality, possibility, and variety of these discourses. ¶ A good place to start might be Glenn Parsons’ 2016 book The Philosophy of Design. To my knowledge, Parsons is not a professional designer or design educator. Rather than a designer providing a view towards philosophy, Parsons and his book offer an observer’s view of design from a philosopher’s perspective.88 In the introduction, Parsons briefly parses the differences between theory and philosophy and, in doing so, claims that philosophy’s neglect of design is “rather glaring.”89 While this p-word section need not unnecessarily diverge into critiques, a portion of Parsons’ first chapter titled “What is Design?” seems (for this list-maker) a bit like a sense-making of design journey alongside the author. This is in fact less a critique than an observation. Ultimately, this journey leads to sections that contains much more salient positions. Just over 30 pages in, within a section titled “The Epistemological Problem,” Parsons states, “In thinking about the difficulty of Design problems, and the attempts to formulate a Design methodology that it has inspired, it will help us to get clearer about what the fundamental difficulty really is.”90 Of course, readers will then want to know: what difficulty Parsons is attempting to describe? Parsons then states, “This difficulty is not a problem of scale….” He then adds, “Nor is it a difficulty concerning the somewhat unstable nature of the Design problem itself.” Finally, the author gives in and reveals one of the sharpest points in his entire volume by stating, “the fundamental problem for the Design process is an epistemological problem, a problem concerning the sort of knowledge that good Designers apparently require.”91 ¶ Here, this list maker will note Parsons’ use of the term “good”—and likewise Berry’s repetitive use of the same exact term (as is noted in the previous section). With this use of the term good in relation to design, readers of this word list will likely see arising a small swell forming around these epistemological, ethical, and philosophical issues. We might well ask: What makes a good designer good? What makes a good design good? How do we know if a designer or design is good or bad. What evidence counts, who decides, and how? ¶ While the aforementioned questions will not be settled here—by luck or intent Brian Dixon’s 2026 book Philosophy Through Design: Rethinking Design Practice for a Changing World seems in some ways to pick up where Parsons left off. Unlike Parsons, Dixon is a practicing designer and design researcher with a substantial appetite for exploring the intersection of philosophy and the artificial with previous books that include Philosophy and Making Things Happen (2023). In Philosophy Through Design, Dixon’s “key argument is that design practice can itself become a mode of philosophical inquiry, supporting designers’ efforts to experiment, reflect and act responsibly and make and remake the ever-evolving future as potential ‘designer philosophers.’”92 Unsurprisingly, about 15 pages into his book Dixon nods to Parsons’ book noting that it offers, “arguments that draw together understandings of the design process, its histories, its key concepts adn how these link to aesthetics and ethics.”93 For this reader, Dixon’s book takes a facinating turn when the author states, “though design research involving practice is positioned exclusively as a form of knowledge production—i.e. a research approach that may be applied in the process of generating novel disciplinary and interdisciplinary insights—it can, at times, function as more than that.”94 Naturally, readers then want to know what “more” is in reference to. Without fully revealing the answer here, Dixon later states that in the context of design, “it is perhaps unsurprising that wider concerns such as the ethical aspects of given objects or processes creep into the frame as core motivational concerns.”95 ¶ Later, in references to the work of Anne Louise Bang and colleagues, Dixon shares what these scholars describe as “a number of complex motivational interweavings.”96 This list maker will add that architects, planners, designers, and other project-minded people should have a deft understanding of form and aesthetics, but also a sense of how to navigate these complex motivational interweavings—in particular the variety of stakeholders that oftentimes surround and inform complex projects. ¶ So what are some key takeaways from this brief p-word section on philosophy? If we return to common definitions of philosophy, one might suggest that the design process oftentimes tugs at several of philosophy’s core branches (aesthetics, logic, ethics, epistemology, and more). Thus, as part of a design education, students and educators alike might warm up to philosophy as part of the core curricula. Speculatively, we might assume that going so may provide future designers and design leaders a wider set of tools for navigating the ”complex interweaving” that so often arises in project-based work. ¶ With this notion of “complex interweaving” in mind, how might we more concretely identify and describe this complex process of weaving ideas, materials, people, concerns, and more? One old-school p-word worth noting here is phronesis97 and another is a renewed focus on people.

  11. People: In 1990, about ten years after publishing “Solving for Pattern,”98 Wendell Berry published a collection of reflective essays in a volume titled What Are People For? Over his lifetime, Berry wrote more than fifty books of poetry, fiction, essays, and more. In What Are People For?, readers encounter 22 essays that reflect Berry’s literary breadth, including industry, narrative, consumerism, ethics, the natural world, and more. ¶ Somewhat akin to the previous section on philosophy, the draft for this section on “People” arrives at a time when many are looking inward and asking deep questions about life, work, knowledge, education, wellness, and more. Such introspection has likely been fueled by the rapid introduction of powerful new technologies such as artificial intelligence and an increasingly polarized political landscape. ¶ In contrast to a technology-immersed lifestyle, Berry’s book seems to champion an almost agrarian ethos. Moreover, Berry argues that humans should steward resources and one another. To support this view, Berry elevates local economies, our connections to place, an affection for neighbors, and a renewed focus on natural surroundings and ecosystems. ¶ Interestingly, Berry never directly answers the question put forth in the title. Instead, readers indirectly receive an assemblage of complex, and at times somewhat poetic, reflections. For instance, one section, titled “The Responsibility of the Poet,” project-oriented readers may find such indirect insights. For this list maker, the following quote seems analogous to the oftentimes complex, evaluative, and dynamic process and life of projects. Berry states, “It has seemed to me increasingly that a poem—a good poem—exists at the center of a complex reminding, to which it relates as both cause and effect.”99 Later, Berry notes that “The process of this reminding is too complex ever to be fully mapped or explained, and therefore the order of the following remarks about it is somewhat arbitrary.”100 ¶ The aforementioned quote reminds this list maker of the complexity that frequently arises within project-based work, which likewise often requires a deep consideration of cause and effect and similarly attempts to integrate a whole host of complex and sometimes competing factors. One obvious factor in this complexity is people. People are both complicated and complex—and by that, this list maker merely acknowledges that humans vary widely in ability, preference, perspective, shape, taste, and more. In product development, we often use the term “human factors” as a catch-all nod to these varied, complex, social, and subjective qualities. ¶ Interestingly, in 2026, just as this list maker was penning this essay, he learned of a multimedia project that bears the same exact title as Berry’s book. This effort, similarly titled What Are People For: Design Philosophy by Patrick Whitney, is a multimedia legacy project101 composed of a documentary film by award-winning filmmaker Gary Hustwit accompanied by a book designed by Rick Valicenti. As a design scholar and leader, Patrick Whitney served as the Dean of the Illinois Institute of Technology’s Institute of Design from 1987 to 2016, where, to the best of this list-maker’s knowledge, he established the first Design PhD program in the United States. Whitney is viewed as a pioneering figure in human-centered and strategic design and, as such, he exemplifies how one might explore the rich intersection of people and projects at the highest levels. This is likely why Hustwit chose him as a worthy subject for a documentary film. ¶ Figures such as Whitney seem to have prepared, oriented, or “opened up” the design field in ways that more rigorously identify and address complex humanistic challenges. But despite Whitney’s role in ushering in notions of human-centered design, some his more recent scholarship seems to acknowledge its limits. In Whitney’s 2020 paper, “Cutting Cubes Out of Fog: The Whole View of Design” (co-authored with André Nogueira), the authors seem to channel a perspective that even Wendell Berry might find compelling. As the authors state, “human-centered design ignores the looming environmental challenges the world faces. Nature does not appear in its models or language, unless it is a rare green project.”102 The authors then share that they are “exploring these challenges with a new initiative named Design for Well-Being.”103 Not surprisingly, the authors provide an information diagram with various components centered around, you guessed it: well-being.104 Alas, as we posit, people—and, by extension, the projects powered by people—like Berry and Whitney, we simultaneously reflect upon the quality of our lives and our environment, as encapsulated by a term such as wellness. Such issues are likely well served by those interested in traversing the timeless and timely intersections of wellness, community, and design.105

  12. Proximity: Another p-word principle this list-maker has continually explored across many of his courses is proximity. In the second edition of her book Introduction to Graphic Design: A Guide to Thinking, Process, and Style, Aaris Sherin dedicates a short but significant section to proximity. In this section, Sherin states, “Proximity refers to the relative distance between objects in space and time.”106 Then Sherin points readers towards one of the most impactful properties of proximity—how distance and proximity can be used to create or accentuate contrast, relationships, distance, association, and more. ¶ While Sherin, like this list-maker, is mostly focused on attempting to impart the relational qualities of proximity in visual design—the term also denotes a potent conceptual frame that applies to the arrangement of people, ideas, resources, and more. One good example is Ezio Manzini’s perspectives on proximity in relation to cities. Manzini’s 2022 book Livable Proximity: Ideas for the City that Cares aptly seems to employ proximity as a non-visual device, as suggested above. Manzini’s book revives a proximity-based idea posited for years: “that of a city in which everything that is needed for daily life is just a few minutes away….”107 Beyond this, Manzini explores the social aspects and potential benefits of such arrangements. ¶ Lastly, pondering proximity also provides a foundation for discussion in teaching, learning, and education. This last intersection often reveals a host of complex opportunities and challenges. For example, in their 2025 book Studio Properties, Jones et al. (citing Güler, 2015) note that “it should not be assumed that providing proximate and synchronous spaces will automatically lead to the best learning experiences and outcomes: increasing educator-student contact time does not necessarily correlate perfectly with effective learning.”108 Then the authors note that in studio-based education, “Synchronicity and proximity are often conflated….”109 Such proximity-oriented questions and perspectives are vital not only in contemporary studio education—but—as a product of digital learning platforms, media, and tools—for all educators. While this list-maker cannot prescribe a resolution to these issues, they seem to increasingly affect learning and have thus become a concern of every teacher, learner, classroom, institution and school.

  13. Portfolios: In 2013, the American designer and visual artist David Laufer published Dialogues with Creative Legends: Aha Moments in a Designer’s Career—an autobiographical tale of a career in design that seems to capture the time, culture, and attitude of the graphic design profession in the second half of the twentieth century. The foreword of the book is written by Richard Saul Wurman. In his foreword, Wurman suggests that the central idea in Laufer’s book is mentorship—“the big brother or big sister who leads by example; the idea of reading, listening, and being in the presence of those who’ve pulled themselves out of the slime, who’ve become worthy and therefore can help us choose our path.”110 ¶ The reason for mentioning Laufer and his book here has little to do with design mentorship or design legends—but rather because it provides a first-hand account of how notions of project-based portfolios emerged. But as we will see, the portfolio, as an idea, has evolved drastically over the past century. ¶ For now, let’s travel back to 1974, when, as Laufer recounts in his book, he arrived at New York’s Penn Station “armed with examples of design unlike anything New York has ever seen.”111 As was standard practice for visual designers of the era, Laufer arrived in New York City with a physical (usually black) portfolio. In his book, Laufer describes his portfolio in detail: “a large sample case made of black bonded leather, quite possibly the largest sample case that can be carried by a single human.”112 ¶ As we fast forward from 1974 to the present day, the notion of a portfolio—what it is, what form it takes, who it’s for, what purpose it serves, and more has shifted quite drastically. As posited here and also within this list-maker’s c-word section on currency,113 our understanding of a “portfolio” has expanded well beyond visual examples of creative work. Today a portfolio stands as both a literal and conceptual device for gathering and curating work across a range of forms, formats, and mediums—and for a range of purposes. Perhaps the most timely and salient of these purposes is education. Here, a portfolio becomes a way to visably gauge progress across and between the formative (i.e., process, drafts, feedback loops, self-reflections) and the summative (i.e., the final product, one’s best works that work toward mastery). ¶ A portfolio, in both the Laufer-esque traditional sense, and also in this new educational sense alike, presents a way to collect and demonstrate with a variety of artifacts and evidence. As designers, architects, and other creatives have long known, portfolios not only capture and showcase completed work but also record and describe the process, research, and reasoning behind it. This long-practiced notion of the designer as author-learner also helps designers, and even their studios and firms, build metacognitive114 thinking, improvement, knowledge, and understanding over time. These portfolio-oriented concepts seem viable in subjects far from art and design.115 ¶ While it would not be prudent to speculate here, this list maker might wager with some confidence that project-based practices, learning through creating,116 and portfolios may garner far more attention as new technologies such as AI reshape the speed and access of information. The portfolio, not as the leather case designers like Laufer once carried, but as a tried-and-true concept, stands ready to capture such efforts. ¶ When Laufer arrived at Penn Station on that steamy morning in 1974, he had three contacts [phone numbers] written on an index card. After arriving, he made his way to a phone booth and, portfolio in hand, sought to chart his career and future. Although much had changed since 1974, the portfolio’s powerful future-charting, reflective, and growth-minded capacity remains.

With utmost gratitude to the many voices cited and referenced. First published 29 June 2026. Last updated 17 Sep 2026. Please send edits, corrections, and suggestions to this address.


Footnotes

  1. See: “Project.” Dictionary.com, 2026, www.dictionary.com/browse/project. Accessed 18 June 2026. ↩︎
  2. Also referred to as the “Technical Revolution.” See: “Second Industrial Revolution.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 24 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Industrial_Revolution. ↩︎
  3. See: “John Dewey.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 14 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Dewey. ↩︎
  4. Dewey, John. “My Pedagogic Creed.” The School Journal, vol. 54, no. 3, 16 Jan. 1897, pp. 77-80. ↩︎
  5. “Donald Schön” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 2 Mar 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Schön. ↩︎
  6. “Reflective practice” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 23 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reflective_practice. ↩︎
  7. Gentes, Annie. The In-Discipline of Design: Bridging the Gap Between Humanities and Engineering. Springer, 2017, p. 6. ↩︎
  8. “What is a Project Manager?” Project Management Institute, https://www.pmi.org/about/what-is-a-project-manager. ↩︎
  9. Definitions, roles, and responsibilities of “producer” vary slightly across music, film, radio, gaming, and more. ↩︎
  10. See: “Subject and object (philosophy).” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 28 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subject_and_object_(philosophy). ↩︎
  11. See: “Inversion (linguistics).” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 12 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inversion_(linguistics). ↩︎
  12. p. 3. ↩︎
  13. “Material turn.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 10 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Materiality_turn. ↩︎
  14. Ibid., p. 3. ↩︎
  15. See: “Engaged scholarship.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 10 January 2024, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Engaged_scholarship. ↩︎
  16. See: “Action research.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 9 March 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Action_research. ↩︎
  17. “Translational research.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 4 April 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Translational_research. ↩︎
  18. “Ernest L. Boyer.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 24 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ernest_L._Boyer. ↩︎
  19. “Boyer’s model of scholarship.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 24 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boyer%27s_model_of_scholarship. ↩︎
  20. “Charles Jencks.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 9 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Jencks. ↩︎
  21. Jencks, Charles, and George Baird. Meaning in Architecture. George Braziller, 1970, p. 18. ↩︎
  22. Titles include The Project Revolution (2019), Harvard Business Review Project Management Handbook (2021), Lead Successful Projects (2019), and Powered by Projects (2026). ↩︎
  23. See: Nieto-Rodriguez, Antonio. “Does Your Project Have a Purpose?” HBR.org, October 11, 2021, https://hbr.org/2021/10/does-your-project-have-a-purpose. ↩︎
  24. Ibid. ↩︎
  25. Ibid. ↩︎
  26. Ibid. ↩︎
  27. “Anne Lamott.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 11 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anne_Lamott. ↩︎
  28. “Kenneth Lamott.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 18 Dec 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kenneth_Lamott. ↩︎
  29. Lamott, Anne. Bird by Bird. Vintage Books Edition, September 2019 [1994], p. 18. ↩︎
  30. Heretakis, Lefteris. “Igniting Creativity: The Freedom in Structure, How Process Fuels Creativity in Design.” Medium, 12 Sept. 2024, heretakis.medium.com/igniting-creativity-the-freedom-in-structure-how-process-fuels-creativity-in-design-645677dd6638. ↩︎
  31. Workflows, practices, protocols, and other terms are similarly bound up in this discourse, but for brevity, these matters are left to rest. ↩︎
  32. “Scientific method.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 30 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_method. ↩︎
  33. See: Hartson, Rex, and Pardha Pyla. “Chapter 20 – Prototyping” in The UX Book (2nd ed.). Morgan Kaufman, 2018, pp. 405–432. ↩︎
  34. See: Martin, Bella, and Bruce Harrington. Universal Methods of Design. Revised and expanded edition, Rockport, 2019, pp. 176–177. ↩︎
  35. See: Lidwell, William et. al. Universal Principles of Design (3rd ed.), Rockport, 2023, pp. 151–152. ↩︎
  36. Prototyping is mentioned throughout the book, but Muratovski does provide a concise overview (pp. 176–177). See: Muratovski, Gjoko. Research for Designers (2nd ed.), Sage, 2022. ↩︎
  37. See: Jones et. al. Studio Properties. Bloomsbury, 2025, pp. 158–161, available at: https://www.bloomsbury.com/us/studio-properties-9781350407503/. ↩︎
  38. Ibid., 158. ↩︎
  39. Ibid., 159. ↩︎
  40. Ibid., 160. ↩︎
  41. Ibid., pp. 155–157. ↩︎
  42. “Friedrich Fröbel.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 25 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedrich_Fröbel. ↩︎
  43. “Caroline Pratt (educator).” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 24 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caroline_Pratt_(educator). ↩︎
  44. “Jean Piaget.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 18 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean_Piaget. ↩︎
  45. “Lev Vygotsky.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 19 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lev_Vygotsky. ↩︎
  46. “Mitchel Resnick.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 30 April 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitchel_Resnick. ↩︎
  47. See: “Lifelong Kindergarten.” MIT Media Lab, https://www.media.mit.edu/groups/lifelong-kindergarten/overview/. ↩︎
  48. Resnick, Mitchel. Lifelong Kindergarten: Cultivating Creativity through Projects, Passion, Peers, and Play. MIT Press, 2017, p. 3. ↩︎
  49. Ibid., p. 4. ↩︎
  50. “Scratch (programming language).” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 21 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scratch_(programming_language). ↩︎
  51. “Froebel gifts.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 9 Dec 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Froebel_gifts. ↩︎
  52. See: Gold, Joshua I, and Takeo Watanabe. “Perceptual learning.” Current biology : CB vol. 20,2 (2010): R46-8. doi:10.1016/j.cub.2009.10.066. ↩︎
  53. See: https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop-elements/desktop/kb/color-management-settings-best-print.html. ↩︎
  54. See for instance: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rationalism-empiricism/ ↩︎
  55. “Textuality.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 20 Feb 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Textuality. ↩︎
  56. Klee, Paul. Pedagogical Sketchbook. Frederick A. Praeger, 1953 [1925], p. 16. ↩︎
  57. “Sibyl Moholy-Nagy.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 11 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sibyl_Moholy-Nagy. ↩︎
  58. Ibid., 64. ↩︎
  59. “Josef Albers.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 29 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Josef_Albers. ↩︎
  60. “Homage to the Square.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 24 May 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homage_to_the_Square. ↩︎
  61. Albers published a book around these ideas titled Interaction of Color. ↩︎
  62. Leach, Neil. Architecture in the Age of Artificial Intelligence. Bloomsbury, 2025, p. 243. ↩︎
  63. Ibid. ↩︎
  64. Nachmanovitch, Stephen. The Art of Is: Improvising as a Way of Life. New World Library, 2019, p. 127. ↩︎
  65. “Free association (psychology)” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 7 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_association_(psychology). ↩︎
  66. “Stephen Nachmanovitch.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 30 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_Nachmanovitch. ↩︎
  67. Loc. cit., p. 4. ↩︎
  68. Yes, in the design professions, we use the word “chunking” to describe the relationship between larger units of information and smaller ones. See: Moran, Kate. “How Chunking Helps Content Processing.” Nielsen Norman Group, 20 March 2016, https://www.nngroup.com/articles/chunking/. ↩︎
  69. “Patrik Schumacher.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 16 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patrik_Schumacher. ↩︎
  70. See: “Parametric architecture.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 22 March 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parametric_architecture. ↩︎
  71. See: “Parametric design.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 4 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parametric_design. ↩︎
  72. Slessor, Catherine. “Parametricism Is a Technophile Triumph of Fetishised Process over Outcome.” Dezeen, 19 May 2026, www.dezeen.com/2026/05/19/parametricism-opinion-catherine-slessor/.  ↩︎
  73. “Pareto principle.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 11 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareto_principle. ↩︎
  74. See: “Human-centered design.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 12 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human-centered_design. ↩︎
  75. “Usability testing.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 15 April 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usability_testing. ↩︎
  76. See for instance: “Flexibility–usability tradeoff.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 9 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flexibility–usability_tradeoff. ↩︎
  77. “Personality, N.” Merriam-Webster, http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/personality. Accessed 26 June 2026. ↩︎
  78. One landmark paper, authored by Murray Barrick and Michael Mount in 1991, is worth noting here. Before this paper, scholars viewed the link between personality and work behavior as inconsistent. See: Barrick, Murray R., and Michael K. Mount. “The Big Five Personality Dimensions and Job Performance: A Meta‐Analysis.” Personnel Psychology, vol. 44, no. 1, 1991, pp. 1-26. Wiley Online Library, https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-6570.1991.tb00688.x. ↩︎
  79. “Big Five personality traits.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 16 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Five_personality_traits. ↩︎
  80. Ibid. ↩︎
  81. ᗧ···ᗣ···ᗣ·· ᗧ••… See: “Atari.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 29 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atari. ↩︎
  82. “Wendell Berry.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 10 Sep 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wendell_Berry. ↩︎
  83. Berry, Wendell. The Gift of the Good Land: Further Essays Cultural and Agricultural, North Point Press, 1981, p. 134. ↩︎
  84. Ibid. ↩︎
  85. See for instance: Beyazhancer, Rumeysa, and Baris Demir. “Pattern skills and computational thinking in early childhood education.” Journal of Child Development, Exceptionality and Education, vol. 5, no. 1, 2024, pp. 59–67, https://jcdee.com/index.php/jcdee/article/view/44. ↩︎
  86. Loc. cit., p. 140. ↩︎
  87. Loc. cit., p. 141. ↩︎
  88. At the time of this writing, Parsons teaches at Toronto Metropolitan University. See: https://www.torontomu.ca/philosophy/faculty-staff/glenn-parsons/ ↩︎
  89. Parsons, Glenn. The Philosophy of Design. Polity, 2016, p. 2. ↩︎
  90. Ibid., p. 35. ↩︎
  91. Ibid. ↩︎
  92. Description on the back cover. Philosophy through Design, by Brian Dixon, Bloomsbury, 2026. ↩︎
  93. Dixon, Brian, Philosophy through Design: Rethinking Design Practice for a Changing World, Bloomsbury, 2026, p. 15. ↩︎
  94. Ibid., p. 28. ↩︎
  95. Ibid. ↩︎
  96. Ibid. ↩︎
  97. “Phronesis.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 25 Mar 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phronesis. ↩︎
  98. Mentioned in this list-maker’s p-word section on “Pattern.” ↩︎
  99. Berry, Wendell. What Are People For? Counterpoint, 2010 [1990], p. 88 ↩︎
  100. Ibid. ↩︎
  101. “What Are People For: Design Philosophy by Patrick Whitney.” What Are People For, www.whatarepeoplefor.com/
    . Accessed 25 Sep 2026. ↩︎
  102. Whitney, Patrick, and André Nogueira. “Cutting Cubes Out of Fog: The Whole View of Design.” She Ji: The Journal of Design, Economics, and Innovation, vol. 6, no. 2, 2020, p. 149. ScienceDirect, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sheji.2020.04.001. ↩︎
  103. Ibid. ↩︎
  104. Ibid., p. 151. ↩︎
  105. These concerns, of course, call for an honest assessment of how we educate and train designers to engage with them meaningfully. See, for instance: Østergaard, Thomas. “The designer as agent of community.” ServDes 2018: Service Design Proof of Concept, edited by Anna Meroni, Ana María Ospina Medina, and Beatrice Villari, Design Research Society, 2018. Design Research Society Digital Library, https://doi.org/10.21606/servdes2018.66. ↩︎
  106. Sherin, Aaris. Introduction to Graphic Design: A Guide to Thinking, Process, and Style. Bloomsbury, 2nd ed., 2023, p. 84. ↩︎
  107. Manzini, Ezio. Livable Proximity: Ideas for the City that Cares. Bocconi University Press, 2022,  back cover. ↩︎
  108. Jones et al. Studio Properties: A Field Guide to Education. Bloomsbury, 2025, p. 128. ↩︎
  109. Ibid., p. 129. ↩︎
  110. Laufer, David. Dialogues with Creative Legends: Aha Moments in a Designer’s Career. New Riders, 2013, p. xii. ↩︎
  111. Ibid., 59. ↩︎
  112. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  113. See: “Currency” in An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course. ↩︎
  114. See: “Metacognition.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 25 Mar 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metacognition. ↩︎
  115. See for instance: Farahian, Majid, and Farnaz Avarzamani. “The Impact of Portfolio on EFL Learners’ Metacognition and Writing Performance.” Cogent Education, vol. 5, 2018, p. 1450918. https://doi.org/10.1080/2331186X.2018.1450918. ↩︎
  116. See, for instance, this Open Learning Library Course from MIT in which Mitchel Resnick, Director of MIT’s Lifelong Kindergarten group, introduces his group’s approach to creative learning and explains why he believes children can benefit from learning how to use the design process: MIT Teaching Systems Lab. “Design Thinking for Leading and Learning.” MIT Open Learning Library, 2019, http://openlearninglibrary.mit.edu/courses/course-v1:MITx+11.155x+1T2019/course/. ↩︎

An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains, 2026–Present.

An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains

contents

I. An Introduction to An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains

D-word sections

  1. Divergence
  2. Discovery
  3. Discursivity
  4. Dialogic
  5. Drawing
  6. Desire
  7. Data
  8. Doing
  9. Distraction
  10. Dignity
  11. Delta (knowledge)
  12. Documentation
  13. Dynamism
  14. Designful

See Also: An Illustrative Introduction to a Curious Compendium of Incomplete Lists for Productive Practice

—

An Introduction to An Incomplete List of d-Words for designerly domains

In 1970, John Chris Jones1 (1927–2022), a Welsh design researcher and theorist, published the first edition of his seminal book Design Methods. Indeed, Jones is viewed as one of the founders of the design methods2 movement. Jones’ book was eventually translated into Japanese, Romanian, Polish, Russian, and Spanish, and a second edition was published in 1992. In the second edition’s abstract, Jones notes that the book has two parts. Jones describes Part 1 as “a review of ancient and modern design methods from craft evolution and design-by-drawing to the logical, scientific and creative techniques that have been developed to assist designers and planners in recent years.”3|4 While Jones’ description of Part 1 might suggest a somewhat historical discourse, the author starts by guiding the reader through the general but evolving process of design. Students in this list maker’s design courses might assume a design-oriented analysis akin to that in an art history course—but that was not the case. Instead, Jones and his contemporaries seemed to be sowing the seeds for more critical analysis of design itself: a maturing field that today we most commonly refer to as “design studies.”5 Within Part 1, in a section on “The Developing Design Process,” Jones interrogated past, present, and future-oriented definitions of design and, moreover, the essential question: What is Designing? After presenting readers with a host of varied definitions, Jones concludes that “the effect of designing is to initiate change in man-made things.”6Post-Design Methods ¶ By the late 1970s, the design methods movement, led by Jones and such figures as Christopher Alexander7 (1936 –2022) and Bruce Archer, seemed to be fizzling out—at least in its initial form. As early as 1971, the movement’s seams seemed to be fraying. Signs of these frays are revealed in a Design Methods Group (DMG) Newsletter from 1971. Scholars such as Alexander seemed to be backtracking away from more logical, rigid, or technocratic approaches to design in favor of human-centric, participatory, and engaged design approaches. As Alexander stated in the DMG newsletter, “I believe passionately in the idea that people should design buildings for themselves. In other words, not only that they should be involved in the buildings that are for them but they should actually help design them.”8 ¶ Even Jones seems to have somewhat dramatically changed course. This change in direction is captured in John Chris Jones’s designing designing (1991), which was first published under the title Essays in Design (published by John Wiley & Sons) in 1984. Jones’s designing design has been described as “a savage auto-critique of his [Jones’s] own work on ‘methods’…”9 Yet, as Clive Dilnot noted in his introduction to a 2021 edition of the book—despite being “One of the most one of the most unexpectedly original volumes ever published on the subject of designing and the shaping of modern life and one of the most pertinent for today” the book “remains essentially unknown.”10The Birth of Design Studies ¶ To further grapple with these issues and tensions, in the late 1970s and into the 1980s, several design studies-oriented scholarly journals emerged, including Design Studies (in 1979) and Design Issues (in 1984)—and by the early 2000s, design studies seemed to have found its footing across various design disciplines. One example, in this case from graphic design, was the 2006 publication of Design Studies: Theory and Research in Graphic Design, a 464-page volume edited by Audrey Bennett. Fascinatingly, in the introduction, Bennett seems to grapple with tensions similar to those Alexander faced in 1971. Bennett states at the outset that “Graphic design is at a crossroads. Looking back, one sees designers engaged in a process where intuition informs the development of visual rhetoric intended to evoke a response from a target audience. Looking ahead, one sees them engaged in a process where research is integrated into the design of objects and experiences for and with the audience.”11 Note once again the uncanny parallel between Bennett’s remarks and those from Alexander years before. Bennett’s use of “with” signals or opens the door to an inclusive or participatory mode of designing. Then, with foresight, Bennett states, “By adopting interdisciplinary research approaches, graphic designers can both question and affirm their intuitive inclinations, and place this process in conversation with peers and even the lay public.”12 ¶ Texts such as Bennett’s from 2006 point readers towards the still unfolding discourses and issues of designing and design. Here, this list maker reminds readers that, in the 21st century, humans are surrounded by design: from environments to communication to experiences and more. As such, one might assume that, since most humans are literally surrounded by design, there would be a present-day correlation between the importance of design in our lives and our general understanding of it through education. But sadly, this is not the case. While design, as a practice, area of study, and a way of thinking, has come a very long way over the past century, it may be said with confidence that we have a long way to go. As noted in An Illustrative Introduction to a Curious Compendium of Incomplete Lists for Productive Practice, this list-maker calls this mismatch of importance and ignorance the design-dependency dearth-discourse dilemma. ¶ Don’t let the playful alliteration fool you: this longstanding dilemma draws serious attention to an essential deficit or “gap” in our common or general knowledge. With rare exception, the study of “design” methods is absent from most mainstream educational journeys. But when we map that deficit or gap onto our dependence on design, a whole host of cultural, social, and epistemological questions emerge. If, in our present day, we are literally surrounded by that which is designed (environments, interactions, systems, products, experiences, communication, policy, and more), should we not have a shared fundamental understanding of design and its importance? As John Heskett noted in this 2002 book Design: A Very Short Introduction, “One of the most curious features of the modern world is the manner in which design has been widely transformed into something banal and inconsequential.”13 Against this reality, like this list maker, Heskett attempts to elevate design discourse when he states, “In contrast, I want to argue that, if considered seriously and used responsibly, design should be the crucial anvil (emphasis added) on which the human environment, in all its detail, is shaped and constructed for the betterment and delight of all.”14 This notion of design, as the crucial anvil, in many ways underpins the core raison d’être for this d-word list—to meaningfully engage in the intersections of design and critical thinking and to posit this intersection as an essential facet of shared human understanding. Put another way, if one wishes to thoughtfully question why things are designed the way they are, by whom, for what purpose, and for whose benefit, then they need to understand design. Who then does not need to understand design? ¶ With these issues and opportunities in mind, this list maker hereby extends an invitation into the fascinating fold of design study and practice. Doing so, however, requires a shift in pedagogical mindsets. This lofty and well-meaning ambition is somewhat problematized by several factors. One issue is the dynamic quality of design as a term, subject, and field. Design, as a field—our tools, theories, and practices—seem always to be shifting—as new technologies and forms for designing emerge. As but one example. Today, thousands of people work full-time as UX (User Experience) designers—but before the 1990s this term did not even exist. Instead of resisting this dynamic reality, designers should embrace and attempt to understand it. ¶ A second interconnected concern those posited above centers on the somewhat confusing “territory” of design. This latter concern is evidenced by widespread misconceptions about design, especially in popular culture. Outside of scholarly debates and sometimes within them, some see design as an art, and for some it is a science—even worse for some, design is viewed as “style” or “decoration.” More recently, under the label “design thinking,” design found some footing in business as a way to generate new ideas and build consensus. Fields such as engineering, architecture, and more also find merit and identity within this “big tent” domain of design. And yet, discourses around design’s epistemological place still seem liminal, dynamic, and unsettled. Interestingly, this “unsettled” or alterplinary15|16 quality may be one of the key qualities or benefits of design-based approaches. Attempting to settle epistemological issues here would unnecessarily detract from this list’s purpose: to further cultivate design as a broad area of interest, skill, and literacy. ¶ With Jones’ seminal text as a touchstone and backdrop, An Incomplete List of D-Words for the Designerly Domains uses each d-word section below to explore and present an incomplete set of considerations that are typical to designing and design. Part 2 of Jones’ book explored “Design Methods in Action,” which examines design-oriented strategies and situations that expand on the divergent, convergent, and transformation-oriented qualities of design. Indeed, we will briefly explore these qualities. As one example within a chapter titled “Methods of Exploring Problem Structure (Transformation),” Jones includes a section on Functional Innovation (labeled Method 5.6).17 This section is as refreshing now as it likely was then, in that Jones avoids vanilla step-by-step process-oriented formulas for innovation—and instead describes the methods and goals of Functional Innovation, which Jones suggested seeks “a radically new design capable of creating new patterns of behavior and demand.”18 Jones then provides readers with three examples, which he describes as “not case histories but retrospective attempts to find a plan of action that could lead from existing designs to the well-known innovations that followed them.”19 For his first example, Jones uses a safety razor. Interestingly, the first step in each example showcases the designers’ identification of “the Functions of Each Physical Component of an Existing System.”20 This is recounted here to in part to reflect upon what Jones could not likely foresee in the mid-to-late 20th century: just how radically the design field would shift and expand. While some designers still design safety razors, “design” now encompasses the intentional prefiguration, development, and refinement of interfaces, interactions, experiences, communication, spaces, services, systems, and more. Thus, design, as a broad domain, encapsulates a multifaceted and applied process “into, through, and for”21 innumerable artifacts, systems, and experiences. Although Jones’ book may feel slightly dated now, I will continually refer to it in this d-word section, as we likewise posit “new methods […] presented as an extension of the methods of the past.”22

designerly doing, thinking, knowing and being

This list-maker might assume that most students in this course have never encountered the term “designerly.” Likewise, it may be safe to assume that you have yet to stumble upon the somewhat more common phrase “design thinking.” We will return to this latter phrase later. For now however, seeing that this list maker has so prominently elevated the term “designerly” by using it in the title of these lists, we should briefly explore and discern its origin and meaning. ¶ The term designerly first appeared in the 1982 journal article “Designerly ways of knowing.”23 The article was authored by the British academic, design researcher, and educator Nigel Cross.24 It’s likely no surprise to readers of this list that Cross worked with John Chris Jones at the [then new] Open University25 (OU) in 1970.26 Around this time, Jones, Cross, and others seemed to be asking another essential question: what makes designers designerly? Cross’s aforementioned 1982 paper provides clear clues that seem to be standing the test of time. To better understand all things designerly, this list maker suggests starting with a particularly significant word frequently used by Cross. That word is solution. In fact, in his relatively short paper on all things designerly, Cross used the term “solution” sixteen times.27 Fortunately, in their use of and explorations into “solutions,” Jones and Cross seemed to avoid all too common notions of solutionism,28 or blanket notions that technology or design could, will, or would solve all our problems. ¶ Cross’ oft-cited 1982 paper curiously stated that “Essentially, we can say that designerly ways of knowing rest on the manipulation of non-verbal codes in the material culture.”29 The curiosness of this statement yields an obvious question: how in the world would one “know” something if it has not been verbalized? Along these lines, Cross also states, “There is a great wealth of knowledge carried in the objects of our material culture.”30 Alas, as we will see, designerly doers sometimes make things to know things, and as much as they know things to make things. Along these lines, and somewhat conversely, it is often through the discovery of artifacts that we understand much about humans, their environments, habits and cultures—even when texts are not available. ¶ Design, Challenge, and Change ¶ In the early 1970s, scholars, especially in architecture, also began probing questions around how designers and architects so deftly solve problems. For example, this is evident, if not directly reflected, in Bryan R. Lawson’s 1972 Ph.D. thesis “Problem-Solving in Architectural Design.”31 Building upon such questions, Cross put forward “five aspects of designerly ways of knowing.”32 The first was that “Designers tackle ‘ill-defined’ problems.” The second suggests that the designer’s problem-solving mode is “solution-focused.” The third is that our mode of thinking is “constructive.”33 ¶ As designers and design moved into the 21st century, this latter suggestion—that design is a mode of thinking—seems to have garnered a wildly popular following and a somewhat unfathomable trajectory and level of interest, especially for those concerned with innovation. It would seem that even Cross could not have imagined or predicted what became a bit of a “design thinking” craze. For better or worse, this trajectory of design thinking as an innovative process is reflected upon and addressed in Cross’ aptly titled 2023 paper, “Design thinking: What just happened?” in which he parses the all-too-confusing differences between “designerly thinking” (noted earlier) and “design thinking.”34 Cross underpins his argument with similar critical distinctions by design scholars such as Laursen and Haase (2019).35 For better or worse, “design thinking” remains far more common than the somewhat more useful and scholarly term designerly. In summary, “design thinking” has come to represent a simplified, easy-to-follow step-by-step version of the design process [more on this in the divergence section]. “Designerly thinking,” on the other hand, encapsulates a more nuanced notion of how designers think, act, and know. ¶ Design as Domain ¶ Lastly, and before we delve right into our d-words, this list maker should also provide some further insight into the intentional choice of the term “Domain” in the titling of this list. As one might surmise, some viable alternatives were fields and disciplines. Here, the designerly list-maker faces a twofold dilemma. The first concern lies in the “how” versus the “what” of design. A discipline is generally viewed as a branch of knowledge—one that is commonly researched, explored, and taught at the university level. So, through this narrow lens, design is a discipline or a grouping of disciplines. This disciplinary stature signals the how and what, but as we consider the “who” and “where” of designers and design, things get messy. As an enormous-tent term, this list-maker might contend that design might be considered a discipline, a domain, or both, depending on the context.36 In more established design fields such as graphic design and architecture, design is viewed as a defined discipline with well-defined processes, methods, and principles. But for newer designerly domains, alongside these more established ones, design is sometimes viewed as a broad humanistic territory, process, and mode of thought. One, somewhat indirect inspiration for this list maker’s choice of “domain” can be found in the introduction to a paper published by Design Issues in 2026. In “Novelty ≠ Creativity: The Problem of Psychological Measurement in Design Practice and Education,” by Jon Kolko, the first sentence reads, “In design-forward domains, [emphasis added] such as interaction design, creativity and cognition, and human-computer interaction, creativity has been extensively explored through multiple scholarly lenses.”37 For the purposes of this d-word list, “domains” also serves as shorthand Kolko’s notion of design-forward domains. To be clear, and while it may be assumed, additional “design-forward domains” not listed by Kolko could and should be included. ¶ This discourse around design’s disciplinary expansiveness and cogency is explored and debated in countless articles, presentations, and texts. One worth noting here is a Chapter titled “Time for Change: Building a Design Discipline.” First published in 2009, Sharon Helmer Poggenpohl’s Chapter in Design Integrations notes that “Design is a term that encompasses many sub-forms or specific sub-disciplines, but unlike biology, design is not well organized.”38 Poggenpohl also notes something that this list maker has long observed, that “Design sub-disciplines tend to be isolated from each other and to look only internally at their own development.”39 ¶ For students of design history, this fragmented state of design as a discipline may seem somewhat perplexing, seeing that more unified instruction and approaches to design existed in the not-too-distant past. The most prominent of these schools was the highly influential Bauhaus.40 Alas, Poggenpohl and scores of others seem to be calling for a rethinking of design education. Ideally, such rethinking might more comprehensively recognize “the changing modes of design and the shifting forms of user experience.”41 As such, the scholarly contributors to Design Integrations call for “new methods of approach that focus on interdisciplinary collaboration between the academic and business worlds, and an appropriate understanding of research opportunities.”42 Along these lines, designers and design seem to be continually moving towards a facilitative and integrative capacity and stance. In their 2026 book Guiding Principles for Inclusive Design Values, Berry et al. describe contemporary designers as having the capacity to explore, facilitate, and negotiate communities, culture, ideas, values, and more. In a section on community and culture, the authors state that designers [and design educators] can, “Serve as a ‘bridge-maker’ who makes essential ideas and concepts clear in ways that have the potential to be understood by a broad audience.”43 ¶ Unfortunately, such a concise d-word primer cannot do justice to the long, vast history of design, its methods and its possible futures. Understandably, many design texts focus on artifacts, which sometimes yield narrowly curated collections of people, objects, and movements. As such, some of these texts gloss over the more complex evolution of design’s methods, research, processes, and theories. Likewise, many architecture and design books, especially monographs, are directly or indirectly funded, published, or influenced by marketers and marketing efforts. Some of these texts are also devoid of critical design discourses, or, to put it another way, why the work matters, or why readers should care. Alas, these books also have their place, on coffee tables, in museum gift shops, or otherwise. ¶ The aforementioned split state of publishing in design was echoed by Guy Julier in his book The Culture of Design, first published in 2000. Julier described the discipline as having “two methodological predicaments.”44 Akin to this list-maker’s notion of the coffee-table book, Julier described this as “popular design history”—which, as Julier emphasized, “design style over process or social impact.”45 Julier contrasts this with “academic design historians [that] had aligned themselves with Material Culture studies during the 1990s.”46 Julier suggests that such scholars were more concerned with “the significance of objects in the everyday lives of people.”47 Fortunately, thanks to a whole host of emerging writers and scholars, some of whom you will find cited in this list, the latter concern of presenting design in ways that bridge Julier’s aforementioned predicaments has steadily become a wider subject of interest to a wider academic and non-academic audience alike. ¶ Another notable testament to this evolution and shift is Donald (Don) Norman’s48 well-known book The Design of Everyday Things.49 When it was first published in 1988, the word “design” was not even part of the title, as the book was initially titled The Psychology of Everyday Things. As several sections that follow echo, The Design of Everyday Things seemed to offer a timely primer on how design can create both delight and frustration. ¶ Another recent example of this bridged approach is Maggie Gram’s timely 2025 book The Invention of Design: A Twentieth-Century History. As the book’s description notes, “Design has penetrated every dimension of contemporary society, from classrooms to statehouses to corporate boardrooms.”50 Alas, I very much share Gram’s [also a designer] view, when she states plainly, “I think what I do is interesting and challenging, and sometimes worthwhile. But I don’t think it’s coherent.”51 ¶ This aforementioned lack of coherence is but one reason for this designerly, literature-review-style annotated d-word list. Fortunately, a host of design scholars and researchers continue to pave new paths for designerly ways of doing, thinking, knowing, and being. One timely text, among many that could be cited here, is Navigating the Landscapes of Design Research (2026), edited by Michael R. Gibson and Keith M. Owens. In their Introduction, Gibson and Owens suggest that “at its core, design research consists of three irreducibly connected elements: discovery, decision, and action.”52 For more advanced design practitioners, Gibson and Owens’s timely text may serve as a next step in regard to recommended readings. The first chapter, authored by Gibson and Owens, is aptly titled, “Why We Need Design Research More than Ever.”53 Following each section, the editors provide useful and concise definitions of key designerly terms. Along these lines, as this design educator has learned, we cannot assume that students, clients, or those otherwise new to design will know what we mean when we use terms such as “prototype” in the context of design projects, methods, and practice. ¶ Alas, if design as research is further afield, design-interested readers might consider picking up Penny Sparke’s An Introduction to Design and Culture, which, at the time of this writing, is now in its fifth edition (2026). Since the first edition of Sparke’s book was published in 1986, much has changed in design, culture, technology, and the world, yet over many years Sparke has focused on what might be considered the key pillars of design. As Sparke notes in her introduction, “The same five themes – consumption/technology/designers/theory/identities–define the underlying structure of this book as it has appeared in all five editions.”54 Unlike Sparke’s focus on key pillars, the following primer offers readers a mix of design history and practical perspectives. As the title suggests, they are, like many forms of design, far from complete. Thus, as a brief but practical primer into a designerly world, I present An Incomplete List of D-words for Designerly Domains.


D-Words


  1. Divergence: Let’s briefly return to Jones’s Design Methods. In Chapter 5, Jones described design as a three-stage process. Here, I might also note that the design process is design-problem-dependent—meaning that what it looks like, how it is constructed, and how it unfolds is shaped by its goals and intents—what is being designed, how, and by whom. Alas, I am not alone in presenting this view.55 With that somewhat obvious assertion aside, some design methods seem more common than others. Remarkably, Jones seemed to be aware of these more salient design methods, processes, and qualities. As Jones curated these essential processes and factors, he noted that, “One of the simplest and most common observations about designing, and one upon which many writers agree, is that it includes the three essential stages of analysis, synthesis and evaluation [emphasis added].”56 But as Jones goes on to describe, “The three stages […] do not necessarily fit together to form a universal strategy….”57 Jones ultimately relabels these stages, “divergence, transformation and convergence.”58 ¶ Design practitioners and educators alike often refer to various visual diagrams59 meant to communicate the design process at a glance. Perhaps the most prominent of these diagrams is informally called the Double Diamond60 |61 (Fig. 1). In its most common formulation, the Double Diamond diagram presents the design process as moving through two major divergent-convergent phases. The first phase typically moves from “Discover” to “Define,” while the second moves from “Develop” to “Deliver.” ¶ In An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course, we briefly explored and reflected upon notions of convergence.62 Here, we briefly posit convergence’s big-tent dialogic nemesis, divergence. To diverge generally means to move away or disperse from a common point or path, or to generally move in varied directions. In designerly and creative work, divergence might suggest but is not limited to: a) approaching a singular project or problem simultaneously using multiple designers or multiple teams, b) looking at the problem through varied or expanded contexts, lenses, or frames, or c) using a varied combination of methods, precedents, iterations, and mediums to formulate and triangulate various concepts and ideas. With this in mind, the need for convergence and its cousin synthesis is clear. ¶ Unfortunately, at least in design, some tend to overly simplify notions of divergence by merely equating it to “brainstorming.” While brainstorming may work for some, this list-maker has found it often shortchanges or oversimplifies the design process.63 If we once again refer back to Jones’ Design Methods, we see that in the section on divergence, the author specifies that the term “refers to the act of extending the boundary [emphasis added] of a design situation [emphasis added] so as to have a large enough, and fruitful enough, search space [emphasis added] in which to seek a solution.”64 ¶ Note the language Jones uses when describing notions of designerly divergence—there is a boundary, a situation, and a space that help constrain desinerly divergence as an effective mode of problem solving and thought. Jones also states that designers should “deliberately increase their uncertainty, to rid themselves of preconceived solutions, and to reprogram their brains with a mass of information that is thought to be relevant.”65 In practice, this is harder said than done, for it has been said that occasionally the designer’s first idea is the best idea, and likewise, oftentimes it is the worst. ¶ It would seem that Jones knew something that some contemporary designers and educators all too often forget: that “the design process” is oftentimes a non-linear space rather than a linear [step-by-step] method. Thus, like Jones and others, I encouraged students to see design as a highly dynamic space (physical and/or intellectual) where various actors, media, materials, and methods can mix.66 ¶ But why is any of this important for students in this course? As Kees Dorst notes in the “Design Intelligence” Chapter of Design Integrations, “More and more companies, governments, and institutions are turning towards the field of design for help.”67 Design seems to productively unite the hand, head, and heart. While this is sometimes overly romanticized, this latter point is, of course, one reason designers are often viewed as productive, curious, and “studious.” And if you want to be studious, you will need to be open to discovery.

  2. Discovery: Marjorie Elliott Bevlin (1917–2009) was an American artist, author, and educator best known for her contributions to art and design education. Bevlin is widely recognized for her 1967 book Design Through Discovery, which was likely a required text for thousands of art and design students—mostly at the college level. Across six editions and three abridged versions, Bevlin’s book analyzed the elements and principles of two-dimensional and three-dimensional design. According to Bevlin’s obituary68 during World War II, she worked for the naval architecture firm of Gibbs and Cox in New York City. She was one of only 12 women in the firm. It seems only fitting, then, that as we commence our deep dive into design, we start with Bevlin and her somewhat dated, but still insightful and beloved book. ¶ In the Preface to the first edition, Bevlin notes that her book “is intended as a threshold, and opening through which the beginning design student may pass into exhilarating new worlds.”69 While such language may sound fluffy to some, design is very much about world-building—whether it is exhilarating or not is a matter of perspective. Interestingly, in the Preface to her last (6th) edition, Bevlin also states, “Accepting the fact that the world often seems arbitrary and chaotic, designers seek, through personal associations and imagery, a sphere in which they can induce order, a harmony reached through the sensitive application of the elements and principles of design [emphasis added]”70 Even in the present day, in design-education it is not uncommon for instructors to casually refer to the elements and principles—such languge is likley passed down if not rooted in the teachings of educators such as Bevlin. ¶ In each edition of Design Through Discovery, Belvin seems to have maintained a concerted emphasis on “the limitless inspiration nature offers the design.”71 Let us briefly interpret these words, and as an extreme, let’s take Bevlin’s notion of “limitless inspiration” seriously. If we stop, listen, look, and explore the world, inspiration, especially in nature or “the natural world,” is vast and limitless. If we conversely interpret Belvin’s nature-oriented statement more rationally, one path of arrival would be what contemporary designers and scholars refer to as “biomimetics” or “biomimicry.”72 Beyond nature as inspiration, by intentionally emphasizing discovery, Belvin viewed design not as a rigid discipline but as an observational connection to a natural order awaiting investigation. Thus, a Belvinistic view of design is akin to being an active explorer of nature, order, behavior, form, and more. Indeed, if we glance once more at Belvin’s first edition, she reveals her hope that the reader might “learn to make discoveries [emphasis added] of his own.”73 As a big-tent term and very much like design, discovery can be used to describe either a process or a product. It is no surprise, then, that in disciplines as diverse as product development, software engineering, design, science, law, and more, methods around, or discrete phases of “discovery”74 are consistently referenced. ¶ While not the focus of this review, a wide variety of learning opportunities arrive at the intersection of design and discovery. In fact, one can find an entry for “Discovery Learning” in the Encyclopedia of the Sciences of Learning, where this mode of learning is described as “a general instructional approach that represents the first broad development of constructivist learning for school-based learning environments.”75 Constructivist76 theories of learning, championed by Jean Piaget77 and others, suggest that humans do not passively absorb information like an empty cup being filled. Instead, they actively build (or construct) their own understanding based on their unique experiences, what they already know, and their interactions with the world. With its emphasis on building knowledge and understanding, we can easily see how notions of design and discovery help inform methods of active learning.78 ¶ Under the big tent intersection of design and discovery, we find additional flavors of learning, including learning by design, design-based learning, project-based learning, problem-based learning, action research, and more. It is no wonder then that design is often cited as a “catalyst for learning.”79 ¶ A final design and discovery-minded trait worth noting is that while designers use discovery as a problem-solving mindset, they likewise use it as a problem-finding mindset.80 Along these lines, with design and discovery as mindsets, one is given a reasonable amount of space to explore and uncover what’s possible—to explore unexpected solutions that a strictly linear process might miss or not afford. ¶ But how might we exercise discovery as a method or mindset? Next, we will explore two design and discovery-oriented d-words that further these exploratory ideas: the discursive and the dialogic. Not to digress, but let’s start with the former.

  3. Discursivity: Like two stones skipping as one across a pond, design history is dotted with designerly duos who together have made lasting ripple-like impacts. From Charles and Ray Eames,81 to Massimo and Lella Vignelli,82 and more, these double-doses of design have helped shape our products, communication, spaces and more. My point in commencing with this off-topic bit of design history is, in part, to illustrate the very principle we are about to explore. Discursivity, or the quality of being “discursive,” is in part a way to describe that which is adjacent or indirect. As a big-tent term, the meaning of discursivity varies across disciplines. Along these lines, the term is somewhat odd in that it can have somewhat opposing meanings. On the one hand, the term can suggest being marked by a reduction in complexity through analytical reasoning; on the other hand, it can indicate rambling or bouncing around between topics. The Latin roots of the term (from dis and curro)—which translate roughly to “run about” suggest a formal discourse in which concepts are conjoined or “run through.”83 This notion of “running through” ideas and formally evaluating them has long resonated with designers. ¶ Why discusivity resonates with designers is not conclusive, but his list-maker might suggest that the answer lies less in how design is produced and more in how design is analyzed. As such, “discursive design” is less about “objects of use” and more about objects as springboards for discourse. Let’s pause and agree—at first, notions of discursive design, especially for those new to the field, may seem a bit odd. But once we back things out a bit, readers may realize that they have likely encountered notions of discursive design without even knowing it. ¶ First, let’s circle back to Jones’ aforementioned description of design, “to initiate change in man-made things.”84 If the goal is to initiate change, then in some ways the actual artifact is, or at least could be, irrelevant. Next, let’s circle back to what we learned in the critique85 section of An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course. Within this c-word section, this list maker suggested that critique “has long served as the touchstone for how creatives interrogate ideas, form, materials, solutions, and more.”86 ¶ With these design critique-oriented ideas in mind, one way to begin positing notions of discursive design might be to imagine going through the critique process without actually producing the real “thing”—the artifact, experience, system, or service being critiqued. Another way to posit this might be to actually make a thing whose chief goal is the resultant dialog it might foster. If this all sounds like science fiction, you are actually not that far off. ¶ Let’s now add to our aforementioned short list of designerly duos as this list-maker further introduces notions of discursive design. This next designerly duo I want to introduce is Bruce M. and Stephanie M. Tharp. At the time of this literature review, both Tharps teach at the University of Michigan’s School of Art & Design. The Tharp’s are mentioned at this discursive juncture because of their 2018 book Discursive Design: Critical, Speculative, and Alternative Things. At the outset of Chapter 1, the Tharp’s contend that, “Discursive design’s primary agenda is to convey ideas.”87 ¶ Rightfully so, after exploring our c-word section on concepts, students in this course might say, “Well, lots of things convey ideas.” This is indeed a valid point, and moreover, one that leads us to ask what makes discursive design different? One easy way to posit discursivity is to further elevate the root word: discourse. As noted above, design as discourse may yield an artifact, but not always. In addition to the critical, speculative, and alternative areas reflected in the subtitle of Discursive Design, the authors also explore notions of “design fiction.”88 Within the domain of design, this is where the disciplines of film, media, and design begin to collide. Said more plainly, just like science fiction helps us imagine the future through cinema, sometimes interrogating or producing an imagined thing helps us imagine the real thing and its possible implications. ¶ At first, this notion of producing artifacts and ideas to provoke new ways of thinking may seem a bit odd, but in many ways, architects, designers, and other creatives have always worked this way. For any given solution, artifact, product, or plan, there are often countless prototypes, presentations, drafts, edits, options, and alternative proposals that the public never sees. We might thus imagine these design-process-oriented conversations as valuable media or material. Thus, in some ways, discursive approaches such as critical design89 merely bring language, attention, research, and space to these sometimes hidden practices. ¶ With notions of discursivity in mind, it may come as no surprise to hear that many designers and design studios often describe their process as interrogative. One of my previous design directors frequently described this interrogative process as “poking holes in the design.” By “poking holes,” I believe he meant attempting to identify potential issues and opportunities as the project or design develops—ideally before it is produced. This interrogative approach to design comes in various flavors, including human-centered design,90 participatory design,91 and more. No matter what it’s called, such language indicates a shift away from a solitary “operating in a vacuum” model of design towards one rooted in discourse, contribution, inclusion, analysis, and dialogue. In response to this, our next big-tent d-word briefly explores these intertwined notions of design, dialogue, and logic, or what some simply call dialogic.

  4. Dialogic: In the Conclusion of her 2018 book Design Theory to Go, Sharon Helmer Poggenpohl92 primarily argues for two things. The first concern centers around access to design as a subject of study. As Poggenpohl states “design is a shared process that is important to understand beyond the restrictions of any sub-discipline….”93 The second concern is aimed at the subject of our design efforts. Regarding this latter concern, the author states, “designers need to step up to addressing more significant human problems that go beyond the tight tradition and limitations of these sub-disciplines.”94 In support of these two gestures, as the book title suggests, Poggenpohl’s text provides readers with a highly digestible set of considerations that encourage designers to “take a larger, more holistic approach to design.”95 ¶ As we delve into the dialogic, one of Poggenpohl’s 24 “theories to go,” Rhetoric and Prototype, seems to fuse two designerly concerns into one interwoven section that deals with designerly ways of communicating and evaluating. This list maker assumes that Poggenpohl thus viewed these two concerns as interdependent. In one subsection, Poggenpohl describes rhetoric as “a civic approach to practical rationality and judgment.”96 This contextual definition helps encapsulate Poggenpohl’s somewhat pragmatic link between rhetoric and designing. To better understand this link, we might posit Poggenpohl’s later statement, which indicates that “prototypes are a demonstration of an idea that requires deliberation and judgment.”97 ¶ While a full reading of Poggenpohl’s section would be prudent, even with these fragments, some timely questions emerge. Are designers makers, thinkers, facilitators, or all three? If [professional] designers are also design facilitators, are they properly trained or equipped to take on such roles? If not, how might we [educators] develop designerly facilitation and deliberation as a literacy, competency, or skill? ¶ As readers recall, such evaluative and epistemological questions are also briefly explored in the countenance and complexity sections of An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course. Within the section on complexity, this list-maker briefly mentions Edgar Morin and a 2008 English translation of his writings concerning complexity. It was within a section of On Complexity titled “Paradigm of Complexity” that this list maker more seriously pondered the term dialogic—frequently used by Morin, but not concerning design per se. In its simplest form, the term dialogic denotes that which is characterized by dialogue. Taking things one step further, this list-maker will note that the term dialogue is frequently used in film, writing, and media, but, unfortunately, it is rarely used intentionally as a design method. Before we proceed, this list maker will note that dialogue, as posited here, is distinct from narrative, or “storytelling.” ¶ Rather than digress into philosophical notions of the term dialogic, as noted above, its use here largely indicates dialog and also discourse. These I put forth as possible **new literacies** for 21st-century designers. To better understand this position, let’s look at a metaphorical example from a translation of Morin’s writing. In his “Three Principles” section, Morin states: “What I have said of order and disorder can be conceived in dialogic [emphasis added] terms. Order and disorder are two enemies: one abolishes the other, but at the same time, in certain cases, they collaborate and produce organization and complexity.”98 With Morin’s flowery statement in mind, notions of dialogic, as described by Morin, suggest that, in certain cases, it is possible for opposing forces to “collaborate.” If we then rein in this statement’s relationship to designing, those who have worked in architecture and design can attest to this dialogic quality. While tacit, the basis of truth of such a statement lies in the fact that design is nearly always developed through a series of dialogic and iterative steps. The problem is that these steps are usually hidden and sometimes ephemeral. ¶ Unlike some forms of art, there is rarely a design problem or solution without some sort of constraint. Thus, the designer must navigate and facilitate a set of dialogic steps and integrative concerns. This notion multiplies when multiple designers approach the same problem, often yielding vastly varied solutions—or, said more plainly, multiple viable paths. Then, of course, sorting through these options also requires dialogic assessments and critique. ¶ Alas, designers and architects have not been so good at communicating the value of such designerly-dialogic skills. How we demystify these skills and tacit understandings is not resolved here, but it is refreshing to see that in Design Theory to Go, Poggenpohl chose “tacit knowledge” as one of her 24 areas of focus. As Poggenpohl notes, “A basic distinction of interest to designers and design teachers is the relationship between explicit and tacit knowledge.”99 To help readers understand these issues, Poggenpohl describes explicit knowledge as “codified,” meaning that it can be “pointed to.”100 Tacit knowledge, on the other hand, is “hidden” or ephemeral, and sometimes needs to be experienced or practiced. ¶ In this course, we will attempt to become familiar with some of the theories put forward by Poggenpohl and others while attempting to advance our dialogic and discourse101 oriented skills as a practice. ¶ As nearly any seasoned designer, planner, or architect will attest, it is much easier to discuss something when there is something to react to or see. To parse this insight further, we will build upon the c-word section on concepts, in which we explored the value and meanings of sketching. Not matter where your practice lies within the domain of design, the next logical step might be to more formally explore such notions. The tried-and-true way to do this is to draw. We known that sketching helps us explore and communicate. Depending on your level of commitment, drawing takes the sketch one or even many steps further. As we will see, for many artists, architects, and designers, drawing is a way to express, record, and represent—but also a way to think and “see.”

  5. Drawing: In 2006, Chris Coy (1980–2025) filmed a wonderfully conceived, minimalistic, single-take, five-minute film titled Milton Glaser Draws & Lectures.102 Even those who have never taken a design history course are likely familiar with Milton Glaser’s work. Glaser (1929–2020) was an internationally known American graphic designer and illustrator, widely considered one of the most influential figures in the history of visual communication. The work of Glaser and his contemporaries fundamentally shaped and transformed the visual landscape of post-war America, blending fine art, commercial illustration, and pop culture into immediate, universally recognized icons. Glaser is best known for creating the iconic “I ❤ NY” logo. ¶ Coy’s film commences with the classic snap of a clapperboard. Once the clapperboard retreats from the composition, viewers encounter a macro-level top-down shot of what appears to be an artist’s or designer’s drawing table. Within seconds, a hand holding a pencil enters from the base of the frame, revealing an arm adorned with a blue pin-striped dress shirt sleeve, its classic white cuff clasped shut by a stately metal link. After a few seconds, we are greeted by Glaser’s voice, who, over the next five minutes, delivers an unscripted monologue on the many merits of drawing. ¶ Glaser, whose voice appropriately feels like New York, begins by casually stating what for this list-maker is the most profound of his message. Glaser states, “For me, drawing has always been the most fundamental way of engaging the world.”103 ¶ As Glaser proceeds, the viewer watches him deftly render an expressive portrait of an unknown male figure. Glaser then states, “I am convinced that it is only through drawing that I actually look at things carefully and the act of drawing makes me conscious of what I am looking at.”104 Alas, this list maker will here note that scores of artists, architects, and designers have long shared in Glaser’s fundamental understanding of drawing as a uniquely human ability and sensibility. The brilliant simplicity of Coy’s film lies in its self-exemplification. At some point during the film, Glaser reveals that he was preparing a book on the merits of drawing. Two years later, in 2008, Glaser published Drawing is Thinking, which features 210 of Glaser’s original drawings and illustrations. Some of these drawings emerged as commissioned works, while others seem more akin to the kind of visual interest most people capture with a point-and-shoot camera: casual depictions of scenes and memories from travels, vacations, and more. ¶ In Coy’s film, Glaser also contends that if he were not drawing, he “would not be seeing.”105 Like Glaser and others, this list-maker contends that drawing remains an essential way to think and engage with the world—and as such it is one that should not be abandoned in one’s life, education, or practice. Even as advanced technologies provide us with tools that quickly produce visuals that appear more polished than what we can render more slowly “by hand”—drawing affords us a direct connection to the subject matter that allows us to engage with it more deeply. Beyond this, briefly consider what Glaser was rendering during the film: a portrait of Shakespeare. As Glaser notes in the film, in truth, nobody really knows what Shakespeare looked like as no actual portraits have survived. ¶ There are countless excellent books on drawing, seeing, and visual language—far too many to list or acknowledge here. Given that this d-word list is focused on designers and design, I might recommend a book that is less concerned with theory and more geared towards the subject at hand: actually drawing. Fortunately, just as I was compiling my course notes, I stumbled across Bradford J. Prestbo, FAIA’s recent (2024) book, From Mind to Paper: Enhance Design Thinking Through Drawing. The first thing this list maker did after obtaining a copy of Prestbo’s book was to purchase a fresh set of moderately priced pens. From Mind to Paper provides just enough instruction for anyone at any level to get started with drawing. For more seasoned designers, books such as Prestbo’s may offer a renewed excuse to draw. In a section titled “From Mind to Paper,” Pablo Savid-Buteler, LEED AP, an architect from Sasaki, writes, “As a designer, I believe sketching is a way of thinking about design that brings direct verification to the pursuit of multiple possibilities.”106 As evidenced in this quote, much like Glaser, Savid-Butler seems to appreciate and understand the timeless relationship between drawing, thinking, and design. ¶ Earlier in this section, I briefly mentioned my one-time quest for the perfect pen. A rubric for this seemingly inconsequential choice might include factors such as the pen’s weight, cost, performance, color, size, and more. Any pen, no matter its quality or origin, has been designed. It may be well-designed or poorly designed, and there’s even a good chance it was designed by someone who does not even consider themselves a designer. My point here is that we all have these imaginary “rubrics” as we make, use, and acquire things. If we were to imagine the various “rubrics” we use to choose things more deeply, we very likely stumble upon some formulation of a somewhat odd factor. That odd factor, or at least one of them, serves as the basis for our very next topic: desire.

  6. Desire: What do an ancient hand-axe, a vegetable-peeler, a trash can, and a rock concert have in common? The somewhat strange answer presented here is desire. In my 2025 motion graphics film, Towards a Dynamic Discipline of Design, viewers are initially presented with one of the oldest known human-made artifacts—a small, somewhat primitive stone tool commonly called a “hand axe.”107 The reason for showcasing this ancient artifact at the outset of a film exploring notions of 21st-century design was largely to illustrate a rather peculiar observation. As described in the film, thanks to recent work by archaeologists and anthropologists, we now know much more about these ancient objects—not only where they came from and how they were used, but also what their shapes and forms reveal about their users. The hand-axe was used for skinning, trimming, and woodworking. But beyond these core functions, these ancient stone tools seem to have been prized not only for their function but also for their aesthetics—what they looked like and maybe even how they felt. ¶ That peculiar property is exemplified by the big-tent d-word: desire. The story of the hand-axe tells us something fundamental about who we have long been as humans. Much like my pen example, we each develop and possess a rich mix of peculiar rubrics that inform how we shape, make, consider, evaluate, choose, and comprehend human-made artifacts. ¶ Let’s now leap forward to the present day and specifically to the scholarly realms of design management and innovation, where desirability is recognized as one of the three core pillars of design thinking, alongside feasibility (what is technically possible) and viability (what is financially sustainable).108 Of course, as we evaluate various artifacts in the present day, our notions of desire are oftentimes influenced by advertising, marketing, and other forms of communication—but this is not the subject at hand here. Instead, we will briefly bring to light this link between design and desire. To do so, let’s move on to my second example, a utilitarian object most of us keep in our kitchens: the hand-held fruit and vegetable peeler. ¶ For designers of my generation, the kitchen-peeler story that follows is well-known. It is safe to assume that many designers in this list-maker’s age group grew up using an all-metal vegetable peeler. This particular metal vegetable peeler I have in mind had notoriously sharp edges and was, oddly enough, quite hard to hold. The more you squeezed, the more it hurt, and even for young, able-bodied persons, peelers like this metal one were quite literally painful to use. As the story is told, in 1989, Sam Farber,109 a retired housewares executive, noticed that his wife, Betsey, who was suffering from arthritis, was struggling to peel apples. Betsey was likely using a version of the old-school metal peeler this list-maker just described. Farber set out to solve Betsey’s peeler pain problem. To do so, Farner partnered with the industrial design firm Smart Design.110 The team at Smart Design developed a vegetable peeler that, compared to the metal one, was much more comfortable and easy to use—not only for those with arthritis, but for everyone. The team at Smart Design seems to have embraced designerly concepts such as affordance,111 user-centered design,112 ergonomics,113 universal design,114 accessibility,115 materials science,116 and more. The resulting product, which came to be known in shorthand as the “OXO Peeler,” featured a thick, soft, non-slip rubber handle that absorbed pressure. To add extra comfort and grip, the designers added rows of thin, pliable “fins” to the grip. This peeler performed well and looked great too—by that, this list-maker means that the industrial designers at Smart Design made the object feel friendly to use, but they also made it look friendly. This latter concern is achieved by thoughtfully considering the peeler’s visual and material vocabulary. The OXO peeler was a massive leap forward in kitchen tool design and to this day remains a consumer success. In 1994, a few years after its introduction, the peeler was even inducted into the permanent collection of the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) in New York.117 Much like the hand-axe, the OXO peeler is a simple tool designed for a necessary task, but its combination of aesthetics, performance, and comfort also makes it a beautiful object of desire—because people love(d) it. ¶ My second example is seemingly less desirable than the kitchen peeler example: an indoor trash can. Of all things you might ask—how could a stinky old trash can become an object of desire? Around the same time the OXO peeler was developed, a rather odd-looking trash can began appearing in stores. Instead of a classic rectangular trash can, this one took on a flowing, tulip-like shape. Much like the OXO peeler, the trash can was also designed for ease of use. For instance, its handles are easy to locate and easy to grasp, making it intuitive to pick up. The handles were neatly integrated into the singular form of the trash can’s design (rather than tacked on as an afterthought). The tulip-like trash can was made of injection-molded polypropylene, which is extremely lightweight, affordable, durable, and recyclable. The trash can was given the nickname “Garbo,” and it was sold in a variety of uplifting colors. Much like the OXO peeler, it somehow seemed classic even though it was brand new. The “Garbo” trash can was designed by Karim Rashid,118 and it was first released in 1996. Like the OXO peeler, the Garbo, or the “Garbino,” as the smaller version was called, was also added to the Museum of Modern Art’s permanent collection.119 ¶ But here we must pause, reflect, and ask the obvious question: do we really need a stylish tulip-shaped garbage can? Twenty years after Garbo’s release, Misha Volf, writing for Metropolis, reflected critically upon the object and its place in the world. The last two sentences of her review seem to encapsulate a long line of critical voices of consumerism and design.120 Volf ultimately states, “Rashid’s can leaves us to parse trash and meaning. The Garbo, after all, is not a thing. It’s an idea.”121 ¶ Volf’s final statement helps us recognize design’s strange significance and breadth—from the symbolic to the functional to the social—but, perhaps most remarkably in this list-maker’s view, is the nebulous “inbetweenness” of design. As a noun and a verb—a synthesis of thinking and doing design seems endlessly fascinating but also consequential. ¶ As we entered the 21st century and further into the information age,122 the trajectory of “design and desire” seems to have garnered even greater significance. Along these lines, in 2010, Chris Anderson123 emphasized the role of desire in a Wired article on the subject of “Crowd Accelerated Innovation.” The article (which now feels very 2010) argued that the explosion of online video would drive a worldwide learning revolution as profound as the invention of the printing press. With this bold premise aside, this list maker recounts the three memorable components that Anderson used to cogently organize his thesis. According to Anderson, the three key ingredients for this open form of innovation are [or would be] 1) a crowd, 2) light, and 3) desire.124 As is reflected in Anderson’s work with the TED conference,125 notions of “radical openness” (note the use of Wikipedia in this literature review) have helped ideas move and spread faster and more efficiently than in the past. The sheer amount of ideas, content, and individually designed texts, media and products now available, along with how we parse and value them, has often been described as “the long tail.”126 By referencing Anderson’s article from Wired in this section, this list maker is prompting design-minded students in this course to further posit past, present, and future intersections of design and desire. What ethical dimensions arise, how economic models have responded, and more. ¶ Note something essential: the word desire itself does not indicate or suggest what is desired. In some design work, interviews with users and community members might reveal that stakeholders, in fact, desire less of something and nothing new. Along these lines, in his Wired article on desire, Anderson ultimately states the obvious: “We’re social animals.”127 This social aspect of design is one that designerly doers cannot and should not ignore—from places to products to environments—much like concerts, people come for the music, but they show up for the experience. Positive social responses to experiences and design frequently conjure up notions of delight. It is not a surprise then to see terms such as desire, delight, discovery, and other d-words used frequently by designers, architects, and planners alike. ¶ Alas, scholarly discourses around design and desire seem to be expanding. Such notions are explored in Harold G. Nelson and Erik Stolterman’s 2012 book The Design Way, and in particular, a chapter titled “Desiderata.” In their book, Nelson and Stolterman “use the concept of desiderata (i.e., desires) as an inclusive whole.”128 The inclusive whole in this case denotes three design-oriented concerns: aesthetics, ethics, and reason. The authors also note that “the aggregated effect of these three approaches transcends their summation, forming an emergent quality….”129 The design of artifacts affects our mood, behavior, performance, motivation and more. It is no surprise to see design entering spheres such as education—not, in this case, as the study of design as a subject, but, conversely, as a way to posit the design of instruction and learning. Along these lines, we can sense when we are using tools, products, and spaces that help us learn and advance. Again, we can easily see how such design-oriented ideas are connected to the c-word care. Likely in place of words such as care or desire, Nelson and Stolterman use the term “splendor.”130 In somewhat poetic terms, the authors state, “sometimes a design becomes the conveyor of the soul.”131 ¶ Alas, while desire serves as a timeless constant in design, over the course of this list maker’s design and teaching career, the materials, methods, tools, and practices of our disciplines and domain seem to do the opposite. They seem to be in an ever-increasing state of change, evolution and flux. While many factors have contributed to the (sometimes frustrating) dynamism of design, one more recent factor in particular has risen to this list-maker’s short list. Like design, we are seemingly surrounded by it, even though few seem to fully comprehend its inner workings and significance. That d-word is data.

  7. Data: Within the complexity section of An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course, this list-maker briefly cites John Maeda’s landmark 2006 book, The Laws of Simplicity. More than ten years after publishing his 100-page book on simplicity, Maeda released another timely and highly accessible book—this one titled How to Speak Machine (2019). Somewhat akin to how Maeda’s book on simplicity provided non-designers with a window into the world of aesthetics, How to Speak Machine served, and continues to serve, as a guide for non-programmers to understand computation. For those like this list-maker, who have no formal training in computer science, the book provides an understanding of grammar, if you will, around logic and “laws” of computation, data, and more. As Maeda reflects in his Introduction, “So I came to wonder if I could find a way for more nontechie people to start building a basic understanding of computation. And then, with that conceptual grounding, to show how computation is transforming the design of products and services.”132 As Maeda’s notes, computation has and will continue to transform many products and services. ¶ For designers like this list-maker, in the 1990’s, designing for or with data seemed fringe. Terms such as interactive design, interaction design,133 and user-experience design134 were on the horizon but still seemed distant. In the mid-90s, when one of my professors told us that compact disks, digital video disks, and disks in general would “disappear” within a few years, we students responded skeptically. ¶ A wise mentor of this list maker once advised him to seek out the teachers of the teachers. With this advice in hand, we can trace some if not much of John Maeda’s thinking, writing, and practice to the designer and educator Muriel Cooper135 (1925–1994). Cooper was one of Maeda’s most influential mentors at MIT.136 Cooper exemplifies many, if not most, of the words chosen for these lists: curiosity, discovery, and yes, even data. Even though Cooper was trained and practiced as a graphic designer, with curiosity, she and her students embarked on a voyage at the intersection of data and design ¶ While some feared the intersection of technology and design, Cooper seems to have leaned right into it—somehow knowing or sensing that the inputs and outputs of design were about to shift. Cooper later founded MIT’s Visible Language Workshop and then became co-founder of the MIT Media Lab.137 ¶ Cooper seemed to keep a low profile and rarely appeared in photos—and for far too long, her work, teaching, and influence were neglected in the canon of design history. Fortunately, in 2017, David Reinfurt and Robert Wiesenberger assembled a beautifully designed, large-format, lavishly illustrated volume on Cooper and her work. ¶ In the Introduction to Murial Cooper, the authors share that, “in the MIT Media Lab, she developed new software and interfaces and mentored a generation of designers.”138 As noted earlier, one of those mentees was Maeda, whose work equally exemplifies many of the words chosen for these lists. But alas, readers might point out that at MIT, Maeda and Cooper were surrounded and influenced by technology-focused students and colleagues. Why should ordinary designerly thinkers and doers be concerned with such nerdy notions of data? And for that matter, what is data exactly? ¶ Just briefly, let’s briefly explore the aforementioned questions and concerns. In 2001, Lev Manovich139 published The Language of New Media—a text well known to those who have taken a college-level film or media studies course. Manovich’s book was and still is widely considered one of the first comprehensive texts on “new media.”140 Although Manovich’s text was focused on media and not design per se, it still serves as a convenient data-oriented reference point. Manovich’s explorations at the intersections of cinema and computers likewise provide valuable, timely, and graspable considerations for designers. For instance, in response to our earlier question around data, we can look to a section of Manovich’s book titled “The Database.”141 Indeed, at the start of this section, Manovich states, “Before proceeding, I need to comment on my use of the word database. In computer science, database is defined as a structured collection of data. The data stored in a database is organized for fast search and retrieval by a computer, and therefore, it is anything but a simple collection of items.”142 ¶ Since Manovich first published his text in 2001, notions of databases and data have become ever more influential, pervasive, interconnected, and consequential—to state the obvious, data seems to be everywhere. This webpage, for instance, is stored as data—its text and images are saved remotely on a giant hard drive connected to the internet. Somewhat ironically, these giant warehouse-sized drives are called servers. In summary, nearly anything saved in digital form can be considered data. ¶ Why does any of this matter for those in the designerly domain? Following Manovich’s earlier-cited definition of data, he states, “But it is also appropriate that we would want to develop a poetics, aesthetics, and ethics of this database.”143 Much like Manovich understood the vast implications of data and cinema, we can and should likewise view data as “material” in and for design. And much like a chef chooses ingredients, when it comes to design, material makes the meal. ¶ Let’s briefly circle back to the definition of design provided by Jones at the outset of this d-word list. As readers recall, Jones suggested that “the effect of designing is to initiate change in man-made things.”144 Unlike some more unfavorable definitions, Jones’ is neutral and non-prescriptive in regard to the outcome of the act of designing. Now let’s go one step further, in the process of designing, data (as a selected material) can very much shape, influence, or inform a design. While these informed or inspired material choices have traditionally been the designer’s—things are getting a bit more complex. ¶ In design circles, one of the first, or at least most well-known, stories that helps frame this complexity at the intersection of data and design occurred in 2009. For designers in industry and academia alike, h the story and dilemma it presented are now commonly referred to as 41 Shades of Blue. The 41 Shades of Blue debate first entered the world of design discourse when Google executive Marissa Meyer led an in-house project that tested the impact of using various colored links in ads.145 In short, instead of letting the designers pick the color, Google decided to run a test and let the data decide. The obvious question then arises—why would they not just trust the design experts? At the time, Google claimed that such a small decision, such as the shade of blue used on a button, amounted to an extra $200m a year in ad revenue.146 Shortly after the experiment, Doug Bowman, Google’s top designer at the time, cited 41 Shades of Blue as one reason for his departure.147 ¶ One can easily see the dilemma that unfolds, not only for designers such as Bowman but for all of us—any profession, domain or discipline where judgment or taste are, or at least have been, valued just as much as the data. At the intersection of data and design, one takeaway for list-readers is to posit the benefits, drawbacks, and differences among that which is 1) data-driven, that which is 2) data-informed, and that which is 3) data-agnostic. There’s also a fourth iteration of these data-oriented approaches, one that first surfaced in various design circles in the mid-2010s: that which is data-inspired design148 (sometimes referred to as data-enhanced). This last flavor of design and data often uses data as a creative prompt. ¶ Lastly, list-readers might now think back to the 41 Shades of Blue dilemma and posit it from a long-term perspective: in some contexts, being strictly “data-driven” may kill the designer’s ability to innovate, differentiate, and critically evaluate. On its own, data is not relational, ethical, or creative. While some systems can provide access to or even rapidly synthesize data, such data-driven synthesis can also lead to homogenization. These are just a few reasons why those in the designerly domain should consider adding data to their growing lists of competencies, literacies, and fluencies.

  8. Doing: One of the wonderful characteristics of designing is that, by its very nature, design tends to be action-oriented. That action could be instigated by a project, a problem, a passion, or even a peculiar prompt from a Professor. Again, using Jones’ definition of design as a touchstone, doing seems to be central to design—we might recall Jones’ suggestion that design, in part, initiates change. There is thus a transformational quality to design and to designing. But why should we briefly explore a concept as seemingly basic as doing? To briefly explore this question, let’s look to a book from 1999 that is aptly titled The Knowing-Doing Gap. ¶ The Knowing-Doing Gap was written by Jeffrey Pfeffer and Robert Sutton—both Professors at Stanford. While the book was written primarily for readers interested in leadership and business, some aspects seem more crucial than ever to a general reader—especially designers. This list maker’s assertion seems to be well supported by the last chapter in Pfeffer and Sutton’s book chapter titled “Turning Knowledge into Action.” At the outset of this chapter, the authors state the obvious: “Knowledge and information are obviously [emphasis added] crucial to performance.”149 The next statement is more surprising, especially given that this book is now nearly 30 years old and the internet was still in its infancy. Pfeffer and Sutton state, “But we now live in a world where knowledge transfer and information exchange are tremendously efficient….”150 ¶ With this last statement in mind, this list maker might assume that the authors had no sense of just how quickly and efficiently data and information now travel. In part, this likely informed the authors to assert that “there are fewer and smaller differences in what firms know than in their ability to act on that knowledge.”151 Finally, as the authors attempt to emphasize this all-too-common gap between knowing and doing, they point to a term coined by Harlow Cohen, which Cohen memorably called the performance paradox.152 ¶ Cohen makes clear what many list-readers have likewise observed: while we often know “what to do” we may “actually ignore or act in contradiction.”153 Fascinatingly, just as this list maker referenced Theodore Levitt’s landmark paper, “Creativity Alone is Not Enough,” in the c-word section on concepts, Pfeffer and Sutton similarly suggest that knowledge is not enough. ¶ In light of or even in spite of these knowing-doing challenges, design seems to do surprisingly well. We are literally surrounded by the evidence of this: otherwise, buildings would not be built, products would not be launched, communication would get stuck in endless editing, and so on. Architects, designers, and other designerly doers somehow seem to get things done and move things forward when others seem to get stuck. There are two points this list maker wishes to make regarding this reality. The first is more obvious: architects and designers are trained to make. In fact, our pedagogies, vocabularies, modes of analysis, and more all center upon doing—visualizing and initiating change and, in many cases, making that change reality. ¶ The second point is less obvious, but it is still worthy of noting here. The act of making things can likewise serve as a catalyst for change (hopefully positive) for the recipient of that which is made. This list-maker has witnessed this phenomenon countless times firsthand. A new hospital, for instance, might create the right atmosphere or conditions for positive improvement or change in patient care. Sometimes that same new hospital also improves employee satisfaction. Along these lines, designerly doers might help launch a refreshed brand that then attracts top talent to the organization, thereby strengthening the business, institution, or organization itself. ¶ Let’s now circle back to Pfeffer and Sutton’s book. The problem the authors described is all too common: excessive talk, fear of failure, internal infighting, lack of will, lack of funding, planning that results in more planning to a point of no return. But then, along comes design, and we show what’s possible—then, using an informed approach, we do it. When things get stuck, when the silos are siloed, and when there’s plenty of data but no one seems to act on it—design offers an alternative or alterplinary154 option. It’s no surprise that “The Knowing Doing Gap” appears155 as one of the 200 entries in the third edition of Universal Principles of Design. Designers are prolific doers—we know how to make, develop, iterate, curate, and facilitate—and we do so efficiently and repeatedly. This is both how and why those who are designerly tend to get things done.

  9. Distraction: In 1943, the poet, essayist, and playwright T. S. Eliot156 (1888–1965) compiled four poems that were originally written and published separately over several years, grouping them into a collected volume titled Four Quartets.157 The first of the four poems in this volume is titled Burnt Norton. The title of this poem refers to a historic manor house located in Gloucestershire, England. The property, originally called Norton House, it earned the name “Burnt Norton”158 after the estate’s owner, Sir William Keyt, tragically set fire to the mansion in 1741. The house was later rebuilt and renamed to reflect its fiery history. ¶ For designers, this bit of poetic trivia may at first seem irrelevant or inconsequential—but as this list maker seeks to expose students to various design-oriented discourses, there’s a peculiar line from Eliot’s poem Burnt Norton (originally published in 1936)159 that may help readers frame and reflect upon notions of distraction. ¶ About halfway through the poem, in the third section, at line 101, we encounter the following line: “Distracted from distraction by distraction.”160 Eliot’s poetic line on distraction is widely considered one of the most prescient, memorable, and frequently quoted in modern poetry. Scholars and cultural critics have analyzed it from several key exegetical perspectives. ¶ With Eliot’s triple reflective poetic line in mind, I invite readers to join me in reflecting upon notions of distraction in the present day—the positives, the negatives, and more. To do so, first, this list-maker will invite readers to place distraction in dialogic tension with broad notions of contemplation. Then, I invite readers to posit distraction as an applied principle, in this case for designing and design—with two obvious flavors: positive distraction and negative distraction.161 Lastly, we will give a brief nod to focus and attention in relation to learning. ¶ During the classical period in ancient Greece, Aristotle used the terms bios praktikos (βίος πρακτικός) and bios theoretikos (βίος θεωρητικός) to describe a life (bios) of practical action (praktikos) and contemplation (theoretikos). Beyond this, Aristotle seemed to believe that attention is not passive; instead, he viewed it as a moral and intellectual muscle or hexis (ἕξις) to be actively exercised and habituated. Hexis162 comes from the Greek verb echein (ἔχειν), which can mean “to have” or “to hold.” Thus, notions of hexis may represent active-sustained presence and attention. Said another way, hexis, or attention, can be placed in opposition or tension with distraction. So why does any of this matter for designerly doers? One answer lies in the fact that, as a profession, design is very much associated with practical action (praktikos). But, let’s take this one step further. A critical reader might then ask how designers, as convenors of practical action, subjectively or objectively, decide what is “practical.” This is an excellent point, which is addressed somewhat below [largely through references to evidence-based design and tacit knowledge]. Going even further, designers, depending on the design, simultaneously explore and, in many cases, incorporate the practical and the impractical (aesthetics, etc). To this latter point, as they say, the plot thickens. ¶ At this intersection of the practical and impractical, we once again arrive at the contemplative. Aristotle considered contemplation, or the contemplative life, the highest form of human existence. While Aristotle saw practical action as necessary, he viewed contemplation (theoria) as the ultimate space or place where humans reflect on eternal truths. Thus, as we fast-forward to the present, for designerly doers, contemplation represents the point in the design process where we “step back” from doing so that we can think, reflect, observe, and understand. ¶ Now let’s bring some of these lofty philosophical ideas back down to earth. Here, students might argue (rightly so) that there is likely no field for “contemplation” on a timesheet. This list maker can attest that for most corporate jobs this is true. But what you can assign time to, [and with approval bill clients for] is design research—which leads us to our next few points. ¶ Let’s shift gears and posit distraction itself as an applied principle for designing and design. First, let’s briefly consider opportunities for positive distraction by design. In 1984, Roger Ulrich (a professor of architecture) first published his landmark paper “View Through a Window May Influence Recovery from Surgery.”163 For the rest of this section, this list maker will casually refer to this paper as “View Through a Window.” Ulrich’s 1984 study found that surgical patients with a view of nature suffered fewer complications, used less pain medication, and were discharged sooner than those who looked out on a brick wall. Today, many design scholars view Ulrich’s paper as seminal because it helped popularize principles of evidence-based design (EBD).164 This list maker will frame this another way—after “View Through a Window,” a hospital window was not just a window, something that’s nice to have—but something that architects and designers could argue is essential to the design of spaces for efficient healing and care. ¶ “View Through a Window” thus seemed to unlock a world of questions at the intersection of design and distraction. For instance: can a plant placed in a classroom affect the result of an exam? In this example, the impact on test scores is minimal or non-significant, but meta-analyses165 show that indoor plants contribute to relaxed physiological functions, including lower diastolic blood pressure and reduced anxiety. ¶ While there are countless examples this list maker could point to, over 15 years after “View Through a Window” was published, Jiang Shan (2020) published “Positive Distractions and Play in the Public Spaces of Pediatric Healthcare Environments: A Literature Review”166 in HERD (Health Environments Research & Design Journal). This systematic, four-phased literature review categorized the use of positive distraction strategies in pediatric environments into six themes: 1) art and environmental aesthetics, (2) spatial arrangement and atrium, (3) considerations of socialization patterns, (4) play and interactive technologies, (5) sound and lighting interventions, and (6) access to nature. The research indicated that positive distractions in the pediatric healthcare environment provide a series of health benefits for patients.167 ¶ Let’s now shift gears and briefly posit some negative or questionable uses of distraction in design. In the world of user-experience design, a handful of these “distraction by distraction” deceptive practices have been given ominous labels. These include “dark patterns”168 and a form of infinite scrolling169 termed “doomscrolling.”170 Even the Pope seems wary of technologically driven distraction. In his 2026 encyclical Magnifica Humanitas, Pope Leo XIV states, “Such power should be constantly guided by the pursuit of truth and respect for human dignity, so that the culture fostered on the internet does not become an instrument of excessive distraction.”171 The point here is that these potentially distracting practices are designed just as much as the positively distracting window in the patient room is designed. ¶ Lastly, at the intersection of design, distraction, and education, this list maker will briefly mention James M. Lang’s 2020 book, Distracted: Why Students Can’t Focus and What You Can Do About It. Firstly, despite the title of this book, this list maker does not contend that all students are distracted. Rather, we might reference Lang’s scholarship to reflect upon and acknowledge that individual qualities of attention help shape who we are, how we work, how we learn, and how we think. As one ponders Lang’s introduction titled “From Distraction to Attention,”172 one might assume that the author is attempting to help educators reclaim responsibility for attention. Indeed, within this section, Lang notes that educators should be “Stewards of Attention.”173 This list maker cites Lang here to make an argument, or case, much like educators, designers are also (or can be) stewards of attention. Along these lines, for educators, Lang articulates a series of attention-oriented principles, one of which holds that “attention remains achievable.”174 While attention may or may not be achievable, the “hidden hand” of design is a powerful factor and has an increasingly critical role to play. ¶ As we have explored in this section, architects, designers, educators, and other designerly doers have long explored, acknowledged, and grappled with various understandings of distraction and attention in their work. With this in mind, take a moment to think of a space that, for you, might embody a sense of awe. It is likely that the magic “hand” of design, distraction, attentiveness, and contemplation is at work.

  10. Dignity: In May of 2026, Brian LeDuc gave a design-oriented TEDx talk at the Price Center Theater at the University of California, San Diego. LeDuc is a design strategist working at the intersection of education, workforce, and innovation. LeDuc’s timely talk was titled “Using design to bring back our humanity in a world full of code.”175 LeDuc begins his talk with a reminder and assertion: “Everything around you was designed, either on purpose or by accident.”176 In this list maker’s observation, for designerly presenters akin to LeDuc, this type of “design is everywhere” reminder is fairly common. It is meant to prompt conversations about, through, and around design—its value, ubiquity, and, at times, somewhat opaque power. But then LeDuc’s talk takes a dialogic turn away from these more common, sometimes preachy “power of design” discourses. As LeDuc bluntly states, “When we have an experience that sucks or doesn’t make sense, it’s the result of bad design.”177 Then, a couple of minutes into his talk, LeDuc suggests that “good designers bring dignity [emphasis mine] to the people they’re learning from and build with [emphasis mine] them.”178 Going one step further, LeDuc says, “As designers, the goal of a design and who it serves matter a lot.”179 ¶ The Universal Declaration of Human Rights of 1948 seemed to elevate the term dignity akin to how it is posited here. Article 1 stipulates that “All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights.”180 But what does this have to do with design—and why would the aforementioned design strategist use the term dignity in a talk seeking to elevate the contemporary importance of design? While this short passage cannot adequately answer these questions in detail, it can begin to orient readers towards designers, scholars, texts, and research thoughtfully exploring the intersections of design and dignity. ¶ An understanding of this dignity-design intersection might be best served by mentioning Victor Papanek181 (1923–1998) and his landmark book Design for the Real World. First published in 1971, Papanek’s book initially landed with a whimper; but over the year it has steadily gained traction among legions of designers into the present day. Papanek’s teaching, writing, and advocacy were deeply rooted in honoring the worth, agency, and fundamental needs of human beings and our planet. In particular, Papanek attempted to elevate the voices of those who are marginalized, overlooked, or commonly exploited. Notably, at the start of the second chapter of Design for the Real World, Papanek stated, “The ultimate job of design is to transform man’s environment and tools and, by extension, man himself.”182 As an aside, this list maker was first introduced to Papanek’s work by his undergraduate design history professor, Al Gowan, a close colleague of Papanek.183 While the environmental and ecological aspects of Papanek’s work have garnered sustained attention, points explicitly related to dignity have drawn less interest. A noteworthy exception is William L. Lebovich’s Design for Dignity.184 Published in 1993, Lebovich’s guidebook assembled a timely and heavily illustrated guide to architectural design for accessibility. It is likely without coincidence that Lebovich’s book fell on the heels of the 1990 passage of The Americans with Disabilities Act.185 ¶ While Papanek himself did not necessarily situate this work under the big tent of dignity—this list maker will do so ex post facto. Following in the footsteps of Papanek, a whole host of designers and design scholars have directly and indirectly built upon his work in vast areas related to (but not limited to) accessibility, access, sustainability, affordance, and more. For conciseness, two contemporary figures exploring the intersections of dignity and design are listed below. These figures, and those like them, seem to exemplify what Paola Antonelli stated in her recent Forward to Jain et al.’s Designing Questions. As Antonelli states, “Without clear, just, and sustainable goals, no method or material can save us. With the right goals—acknowledging entanglement with nature, responsibility to others, and the pursuit of dignity, for example—methods and materials will follow.”186 In support of the authors’ thesis, Antonelli then suggests that “without the right questions” such goals might remain unachievable.187 ¶ In 2025, this list maker was fortunate to meet fellow design educator Sara Hendren when she gave an invited guest lecture at his university. Hendren’s talk and her 2020 book What Can a Body Do? seem to explicitly exemplify notions of dignity in design. In the introduction to What Can a Body Do? Hendren states, “Every day every body is at odds with the built environment.”188 Hendren then provides a host of design-oriented examples from stairs to sidewalks to subway platforms. Later, Hendren questions the idea of what “normal” is—considering that we are all in one way or another so very different. As Hendren later states: “The idea of normalcy—a normal, average body or mind—is so ubiquitous and mundane that it’s settled into sleep in much of our collective cultural imagination.”189 Then, through a series of contextual case studies, Hendren helps readers understand, imagine, and reimagine a future where design might better serve a wider range of needs and desires. Readers not only get a sense of what these design interventions enable, but also how they provide dignity to those whom designers serve. ¶ A second example that alludes to a connection between design and dignity is John Cary’s 2017 book Design for Good.190 Like Papanek, Cary seems to push back against design’s all-too-often association with style and luxury, showcasing projects that link the intentionality of our spaces to the quality of our lives. In the Introduction (once again in the lineage of Papanek), Cary states, “those who need design most—regular people—aren’t even sure how to describe what it is they desire in their environments, products, and services.”191 This list maker might suggest that what Cary describes is not unlike, or even disconnected from, what this list maker earlier posited as the “design-dependency dearth-discourse dilemma.” Notably, the foreword to Design for Good was written by Melinda Gates. In the foreword, Gates states, “great design is not a finite resource; it is a choice we can all make by listening more, empathizing more, and demanding more for humanity.”192

  11. Delta (knowledge): How do we begin to describe, define, and validate the tacit knowledge often associated with or employed in designerly doing? In the d-word section on doing, we explored the “gaps” that occasionally occur between knowing and doing. In this section, we will extend that discourse to parse how certain types of “doing” may underpin certain forms of human knowledge and knowing. While such doing-oriented questions have long been approached from various angles, those specific to design seemed to enjoy a noteworthy thread of exploration in the late 1980s and into the early 2000s. To the best of my knowledge, in 1989, Wim Gilles193 (1923–2003) and Gilles Paquet194 (1936–2019) proposed the concept of Delta knowledge, which they viewed as a fourth category of knowledge meant to encapsulate modes of methods doing.195 Years later (in 2001), Wim Gilles co-authored another paper with design educator Jacques Giard196 that once again attempted to advance notions of Delta knowledge. Their paper, “Delta Knowledge: Place and Significance in Industrial Design Education,” sought specifically to address “fundamental issues associated with the question of knowledge in industrial design.”197 In a section titled “Classes of Knowledge,” Gilles and Giard state the following:
     
    Knowledge has long been a part of the intellectual evolution and history of society. So, too, has the study of the development of knowledge and its classification. A simple classification of academic disciplines, as it is widely used in Europe, recognizes three types of disciplines. They are Alpha, Beta and Gamma. The Alpha disciplines, commonly referred to as the humanities, are the oldest of the three; Beta disciplines, those of the exact sciences, developed later. The recognition of Gamma disciplines only occurred in the last century after the development of the social sciences. Each of the three types of discipline uses its own characteristic language. Alpha disciplines use the language of words, Beta disciplines use that of numbers, and Gamma disciplines use a combination of word language and numbers, often that of statistics and analyses.198
     
    The authors then note that by the end of the 20th century, some scholars felt that doing-oriented disciplines did not fit neatly into these categories—including design.199 This formulation and use of alpha, beta, and gamma to classify intellectual and academic disciplines was first described in 1980 by Fritz Machlup200 (1902–1983) in his multi-volume work Knowledge: Its Creation, Distribution, and Economic Significance.201 Readers might assume that such sustained scholarly arguments for Delta knowledge over many years would, alongside design’s growing influence, similarly gain broader understanding and recognition, but, with a few exceptions, this does not seem to be the case. Giard and Giles did garner at least some traction with their 2001 paper, which delineated “new and adjusted operational devices and pedagogical vehicles commensurate with the nature of Delta knowledge.”202 The authors offered five operational devices, including studio design projects, case studies, and the learner’s report. These “operational devices” connect to several of the themes explored in this list-maker’s Incomplete List of P-Words for Project-Based Pursuits, especially the section on process. ¶ Some might fear that Giard and Giles’s demand for case studies and reports placed an undue, and in many cases uncompensated, burden on the designer or design team. Going further, some might fear that learning reports and case studies would, over time, potentially have the effect of rationalizing or post-rationalizing the subjective. While these rebuttals are not without substance, outside of that which is captured through evidence-based design methods, how would those outside of a design project understand the intent of a designer, design, or design team? Here we admittedly enter a “grey zone”—as design ideas may arrive at the most inopportune time and in strange, unexpected ways. It is well known that some ideas, even design-ideas arrive in indirect and sometimes even accidental ways. ¶ On “Mode 2” Knowledge Production ¶ In compliment to Delta knowledge, in 1994 Michael Gibbons et al. contrasted traditional academic knowledge production (Mode 1) with an emerging paradigm they described as “Mode 2” knowledge production. In 1994 such ideas were explored in a 192 page volume titled The New Production of Knowledge: The Dynamics of Science and Research in Contemporary Societies. This list maker first encountered notions of “Mode 2” knowledge in a fascinating book titled The Dynamic Library: Organizing Knowledge at the Sitterwerk—Presencents and Possibilities edited by Ariane Roth and Marina Schütz (translated by Alta L. Price). In a section titled “Design Research and ‘Mode 2’—Knowledge Production” contributing author Claudia Mareis describes Mode 2 knowledge production as “application oriented.”203 Moreover, according to Mareis, the Mode 2 designation “aimed to codify a different approach to knowledge production—one in which the clear delineation between scientific knowledge production and other, ‘non-scientific’ methods would steadily dissolve.”204 Along these lines, and as an brief aside, in the d-word section on dynamism this list maker advovates for design as fluid space for this blending of disciplines. Later in the essay, Mareis contrasts Mode 1 as “developed in the departmentalized context of academic interests and institutions” versus Mode 2 as “carried out predominantly in the broader ‘context of application.'”205 Such discourse, however, reveals one of the great tensions in academic and knowledge production—whether Mode 2 knowledge is lesser knowledge, or different knowledge. This discourse is further complicated by how one constitutes, defines, or measures impact. For instance, how would one evaluatelely compare the knowledge and impact of a Mode 2 scholar who has designed a public policy that affects millions versus a Mode 1 scholar who then writes a paper about the Mode 2 scholar who designed a public policy that affects millions? While matters will not be settled here, such discourse paves the way for how we think about research and education well into the future. ¶ The Introduction to Gibbon’s et al.’s book confirms much of what Mareis describes. The authors state, “By contrast with traditional knowledge, which we will call Mode 1, generated within a disciplinary, primarily cognitive, context, Mode 2 knowledge is created in broader, transdisciplinary social and economic contexts.”206 Then the authors boldly state that, “The emergence of Mode 2, we believe, is profound….”207 ¶ What Gibbons et al. viewed as “profound” seems to have made negligible changes to the enduring primacy of Mode 1 knowledge. But alas, with the emergence of AI these Mode 2 oriented ideas may quickly resurface. For instance, in his 2026 book, The Cognitive Revolution: How AI is Reorganizing Intelligence, Expertise, and Institutions, Jiajie Zhang begins with a provocative preface titled, “Intelligence Has Left the Building,” in which Zhang states, “For centuries we believed it [intelligence] lived inside the human mind—trained through education, measured through exams, and validated through credentials. We built institutions on that belief.”208 But then, even more boldly, Zhang states, “That belief is now obsolete.”209 While one might be quick to brush off such claims or contend that they are presented by a fringe scholar, Zhang is hardly categorized as such. At the time of this writing Zhang is dean, professor, and The Glassell Family Foundation Distinguished Chair in Informatics Excellence at D. Bradley McWilliams School of Biomedical Informatics at UTHealth Houston. According to Zhang’s academic bio,210 he has authored over 200 publications and has contributed to grant-funded projects supported by millions of dollars in research funding. ¶ Interestingly, Zhang seems very interested in design. In fact, Chapter 14 of his book is titled, “Designing for a World That Thinks.” Within a section of that chapter titled, “Designing Cognitive Systems” Zhang states, “Design in the cognitive era is not primarily about products, interfaces, or services. It is about systems of thinking.”211 After the word “thinking,” Zhang places a footnote that cites Hollan, Hutchins, and Kirsh’s 2000 paper212 on distributed cognition and Herbert Simon’s Sciences of the Artificial from 1969. ¶ One common argument against Mode 2, Delta, or designerly ways of knowing is that such knowledge is A) difficult to attribute to a single researcher, designer, author, artist, or scholar, and B) such knowledge is oftentimes deemed “tacit” or practice-based—and as such it is not always substantiated or codified in texts. Thus, once again, even if Mode 2 knowledge has a positive impact, can we link or attribute that impact to one’s projects, interventions, or practice? As readers of this list know well, the life of an artifact and idea is often shaped by a whole host of unpredictable factors. ¶ At best, we can document our efforts. And while there are surely limits to what can and should be documented, the notion of documentation is worth exploring.

  12. Documentation: In July of 2026, on a college campus in Ohio, this list-maker was scheduled to initially present his word lists at an academic design conference. As this list-maker made his way to the lecture-style room where the talks in his session were scheduled to take place, he eventually reached the podium to connect his laptop, where he noticed a handmade, poster-sized sign on the wall. Above this sign, in large, sparkle-birthday-party-style text, was a poster title of sorts with text that read “Health Information Management.” Below this larger text sat a handmade poster (Fig. 2) that read, “Coding Rule 1: If it is not documented, it did not happen.” ¶ Curious to learn what this meant, this list maker did some quick research and sent the image to a friend who works in healthcare. As it turns out, in the context of Health Information Management (HIM), “coding” and documentation are tightly interconnected concepts—and in this list maker’s view, they are ones that designers might be able to learn something from. In healthcare, documentation may include the original narrative or record written or dictated by doctors, nurses, and other healthcare providers. Such documentation can include patient histories, physical exams, progress notes, surgical reports, discharge summaries, and more. Then, as a complement to this documentation, coding might be described as a process in which a trained HIM professional (or “medical coder”) reads this clinical documentation and translates it into standardized alphanumeric codes. These “codes” are used for reimbursement, data tracking, analytics, patient records, and more. The point in noting this healthcare-related poster here is for designers to similarly ponder the relationship among action, documentation, and “coding”—defined here as a communicable or systematized version of that documentation. ¶ In his Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course, this list-maker explored notions of the portfolio and how it differs from and complements other knowledge-skill-and-experience conveyance tools and approaches (such as the Curriculum Vitae). Further in this section, the author cited key scholarly figures such as Sir Christopher Frayling, Dan Serig, and others who, in the 20th century and beyond, sought to articulate and advance art- and design-based inquiry as research and scholarship. These figures helped substantiate creative practice, creative research, and creative pedagogies and posited how such knowledge might be appropriately coded and communicated. ¶ In this section on documentation, we will interweave these portfolio-oriented ideas with more epistemological-operational devices like the ones described by Giard and Giles in the previous section on Delta knowledge. This will surely spark debate in the classroom and beyond. For instance, one might ask what level(s) of documentation, if any, are appropriate for designers and design? Is there a point at which documentation becomes a hindrance to the creative-design process? More speculatively, we might ponder a future (with the coding example from healthcare in mind) in which some design professionals might be relationally akin to primary care physicians [aka primary care architects and designers]? ¶ To parse these ideas a bit further, following the aforementioned design conference, I asked a healthcare professional (who is also trained in design) about the curious handmade sign that I encountered on the college campus in Ohio. In response, this figure stated, “In healthcare… generally, it’s not enough to provide exceptional care, […] everything you do must be reflected in your documentation, because it will be the only lasting record of what happened.” ¶ Before we advance this documentation conversation further, let’s briefly review some previous ideas from An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course. At one point, as part of the creative process, this list maker asked readers to imagine “a series of footnotes within footnotes.”213 This is based on the idea that as one develops creative, design-project-oriented ideas, those ideas can often be contextually mapped and situated within research and precedents. Later, this list oftentimes advises students to start a creative or design project by collecting such nested “footnotes” (ideas, precedents, images, research, literature, etc.)—all under the broad categorization of contextual research. ¶ Now for some good news. This collection of contextual footnotes may count or contribute not only towards the discovery phase or contextual research, but when preserved (as a record of one’s thinking, reference points, process, and more) much of that process can then be used in one’s documentation: portfolios, learning records, case studies, project descriptions, and more. ¶ Beyond footnotes, as designerly professionals, when it comes to documentation, one can [and should] be thinking in terms of “figures.” Just as we broadly posited footnotes earlier, we can now posit this notion and use of a “figure.” A figure (or “future figure”) is another way for designers to think about capturing contextual documentation as part of the design process. ¶ Let us now reflect on the start of this section. This listed maker essentially employs a figure, in this case a photographic reference from outside the world of design, to frame a conversation around documentation in design. Thus, even a photo on a wall, if relevant, can potentially become a figure. Then the documentation is essentially “encoded” in this essay as a figure (Fig. 2). Making the photo from the design conference venue into a figure gives it a label that can be referenced, debated, pondered, and discussed further in literature, promotional material, design research, and more. An incomplete list of what can constitute a figure in design documentation might include, but is not limited to: photos, scans, sketches, models, prototypes, iterations; videos, interviews; audio recordings; charts, infographics, diagrams, data; and so on. ¶ Unlike pure science or even pure art, the alterplinary214 and dynamic qualities of design afford the designer and design team a wider variety of inputs and outputs from a diverse range of disciplines and domains. In line with this view, designerly documentation may explore and include a wide range of forms, materials, media, and methods. As described in the c-word section on countenance,215 these evaluative factors and options exhibit a meta-mixed methods quality. ¶ Lastly, readers might wonder what format and structure are appropriate for designerly documentation. How one shapes a design case study or project summary largely depends on multiple factors, including the project type, project intensity, the intended audience or reader, and other considerations. As Kevin and Jeanine Flores note in their Design Career Handbook (2024) “different design disciplines have slightly different approaches to a case study,”216 but the authors add that case studies very often use similar “building blocks.”217 While the Floreses’ book provides lots of useful advice, one indirect takeaway worth noting is the possibility of mapping one’s case study format (to varying degrees) directly to one’s design process. While this mapping need not be exactly 1:1, this notion of mapping one’s process also affords a quasi-educational component: the reader may learn more about, appreciate, or understand the design process itself by reading the case study.

  13. Dynamism: Perhaps now more than ever, no field, discipline, domain, trade, or practice is static. So why would this list maker elevate the term dynamism in specific relation to design? As is argued below, design seems to uniquely or at least uncommonly exemplify a fluid, non-static, or dynamic quality in curious ways that exceed other fields. But this list-maker should first clarify what he means by choosing the terms dynamism and dynamic as descriptive indicators of design. ¶ Design as a field has rapidly evolved and continues to evolve—but so does a whole host of fields: technology, science, art, and countless other fields. Thus, constant evolution, defined as dynamism, is indeed an attribute of design, but it falls short as a strong argument for dynamism as a special quality of design. Second, we might posit design’s frequent association with and ability to pair form with time and motion, as in motion design, kinetic experiences, interactive arrangements and environments—but here too those who work in media, film, and other fields could make similar and equally compelling claims upon the dynamic. So, as explored thus far, neither change nor motion as described above seem substantial enough to make a strong dynamic-design relational claim. Thirdly, the practice, tools, and outputs of design are continually affected by technology. In a somewhat circular way, the “things” designers design are always evolving, and thus new roles, tools, and approaches for design are in constant emergence. As an obvious example, digital interfaces did not exist until digital devices did. Thus, those who design the multivariate interactions, interfaces and experiences that shape and inform digital products did not exist until such technologies eventually emerged. But then again we could say the same about the book, the building, or any number of artificial artifacts that have emerged along our techno-historical timeline. Those all needed designing too. ¶ Thus, this third argument is valid but seems somewhat weak, or even obvious when against other disciplines and domains. In health, for instance, the cancer researcher did not emerge until we adequately understood cancer. Thus, many disciplines outside of design exhibit a dynamic and emergent quality in relation to invention, culture, and discovery over time. ¶ As we attempt to parse and interrogate the intersection of the dynamics and design further, let’s parse our language in what might at first seem like a simplistic lexical analysis: that dynamism suggests a quality of being dynamic. But as we pull at this language-oriented thread, we see that dynamic, as an adjective, is used to suggest change, movement, enthusiasm, or—as in music218—changes in volume over time. As a noun, dynamic often describes relationships or behaviors between individuals, groups, and things. It is with this latter capacity in mind that we inch closer to a salient understanding of design’s domain-defining dynamic property.

    A Mindset Shift: Design as “the Table” Versus Designers and Design Wanting a “Seat at the Table”

    Over the past century, designers have continually clamored for a “seat at the [decision-making] table.” Driven by changes and advances and shifts in technology and values, design is now less a seat at the table, but in many ways is the table itself—a collaborative, challenge-based space for preconfiguring, figuring, and assessing what has been figured. Following the section above that posits design as an active, social, and relational space, this list maker might point to uses of “dynamic” that likewise embody this intersection: one might encounter the social-relational use of the term “power dynamics” or, along these lines, “interpersonal dynamics.” Here we can couple “dynamics” and “design” as social and relational. ¶ On Design Dynamics ¶ Let’s proceed one step further and attempt to parse “dynamics.”As alluded to at the outset of this section—“dynamic” seems dialogically antithetical to the static. Interestingly, physicists, engineers, and others use the term “fluid dynamics”219 to describe the flow of liquids and gases. With this use of dynamics from the world of physics in mind, we inch closer to design’s uncommon capacity to prefigure and organize “the flow of things”—the flow of ideas, plans, intentions, materials, aesthetics, concerns, and more. ¶ Here, this list maker suggests that future curricula in design might thus include courses with titles such as “Design Dynamics 1” or “Introduction to Design Dynamics” or “Advanced Design Dynamics.” The locus of such inquiry and study lies in an understanding of how design operates in and between a range of contexts, materials, roles, and scales. Rather than abstractly attempt to describe this as the “designerism” of design—we might be better served by attributing this uncommon quality to existing language: dynamics. Indeed, this list-maker is not the only design scholar elevating this thorny territory into and around the dynamics of design. For instance, in 2026, Bryan Boyer and Greg Lindsay published a white paper titled Chain Drain: Why the Built Environment Struggles to Learn and How to Fix It. While the paper focuses on issues in the AECO (Architecture, Engineering, Construction, and Operations) industries, it provides a vital contribution to a scholarly intersection that sits between design methods and design actors: what this list maker will call “design dynamics” (See: Fig. 3).220 In their paper, Boyer and Lindsay describe the “chain drain” as “the cumulative loss of value and intelligence across the industry’s horizontally organized delivery model, resulting from discoordination and disconnection.”221 With Boyer and Lindsay’s paper in mind, design dynamics may (at least in part) begin to parse and examine such issues of discoordination and disconnection. Along these lines, in their paper, the terms “workflow” or “flow” appear 13 times, “dynamics” appears 11 times, and “actors” appears 18 times.222 One of the most salient themes of this paper is that it seems to recognize the tensions and relationships between design as something inherently relational and technical without jumping to the conclusion that the latter can or will always solve issues related to the former. ¶ With notions of design dynamics in mind, readers might reflect back upon the introduction to this d-word list, the rise and fall of the design methods movement in the 1960s and into the 1970s, and then the subsequent (and much needed) arrival of design studies in the 1970s, the rise and (it seems likely) fall of design thinking around the turn of the millennium, and lastly and in parallel to this, the casting and recasting of design history alongside all of this. Following this trajectory, this list-maker posits a more integrated time-based relationship between design history, design dynamics, design futures, and design studies (See: Fig. 4).

    The Four “Legs” Supporting the Dynamic-Integrative “Table” of Design-Centered Design (DCD)

    With this language-based and relational exploration of design in mind, this list-maker will present four interlinked positions or “legs” that may advance or “underpin” an integrative-dynamic-design-centered design argument further: 1) holistic systems thinking 2) epistemology and understanding 3) evaluatory synthesis, and 4) applied aesthetics. ¶ A mature field of design more confidently stands on its own 223 between (rather than alongside) a whole host of other “big-tents”—art, science, business, health, law, theology, psychology, and more. Together, the four “legs” of design posit a structural foundation of factors and actors that inform design as a domain where many disciplines contribute. Leg 1) Holistic Systems Thinking: This first leg underpins and supports design as a relational space where designers study and apply a holistic understanding of concepts not limited to complexity, cost, causation, systems, transitions, feasibility, viability, loops, patterns, processes, production, waste, value, and flow. Leg 2) Epistemology and Understanding: This second leg suggests that future designers may benefit from a new set of curricula aimed at arming the designer with tools, methods and study that may afford them a capacity to serve as “epitemological bridges” between disciplinary experts, stakeholders, cultures, clients, creators, customers, policy-makers and more. In this way, those trained in design might be uniquely versed, skilled, and empowered to facilitate projects and initiatives that require fluid, mixed, collaborative, and flexible approaches to knowing things, understanding things, and making things. Leg 3) Evaluatory Synthesis: This third “leg” attempts to address a common but somewhat weak argument: one that prima facie suggests that architects and designers exhibit “reasoned judgment: and “good taste.” The weakness of this “taste” argument often lies in the claim’s tacit nature, rather than in substantive evidence or insight into the dynamics that shaped it. Architects and designers indeed possess an uncommon capacity to positively navigate evaluative synthesis. This oftentimes refined capacity needs to be presented more cogently and overtly. This third leg builds on the thinking- and knowledge-oriented aspects of the first two legs and advances them through a combinatory-evaluative approach. In this way, the designer helps shape the assembly of “things” (tangible and intangible) which, of course (depending on the “thing”), requires a whole host of evaluatory choices along the way. The future designer does so using a host of dialogic,224 conversational,225 and “countenance”226 based methods. With these first three “legs” supporting the table, the designer is better equipped to facilitate a wide range of transdisciplinary issues spanning people, ethics, aesthetics, domains, culture, material, knowledge, form, concept, content, and more. In Towards a Dynamic Discipline of Design,227 this list-maker has attempted to describe and visualize such a model or capacity using kinetic diagrams. Building upon that effort, here the “table of design” is put forth as a dynamic and integrative challenge space. In this way, design provides alterplinary228 and designerly229 positions, platforms, and processes that effectively bring together and facilitate projects and people across a wide range of scales—especially projects of high complexity. ¶ Leg 4) Applied Aesthetics: This last leg is perhaps the thorniest of all four. This thorniness lies in design’s long entangled relationship with art, and as subsets of this are issues of form, composition, curation, and “style.” For the longest time, this skill, craft. and desirability-oriented “leg” (for better or worse) underpinned the value of architects, designers, and their educational foundations. It is no surprise that this list-maker was twice trained at a college of art and design. On the design side of the house, much of the 20th century seemed to focus on “the beautiful and the useful.”230 Then, as we approached the turn of the millennium, designers, critics, and scholars seemed to continually expand the aesthetic scope, lenses, and concerns of design towards critical, cultural, and speculative spaces. Thus, in this post-post-modern era, art and design have moved beyond the traditional aesthetic boundaries that defined their past. In short, Leg 4 suggests that expressive, emotional, and poetic voices remain essential at the dynamic-integrative table of design. Furthermore, for a designer or design project centered on craft or decoration, the concerns offered in the first three “legs” may be diminished or null.

    The Operation and Occupants at the Dynamic-Integrative “Table” of Design-Centered Design (DCD)

    As we posit design as a metaphorical “table”—who are the actors or occupants at the table—how do they interact, and who orchestrates this complex process and flow? To answer this question, let’s look at how this system of tables, legs, and chairs might operate:

    A. The Dynamism of Design: If we were to attempt a visualization of design, or better yet, a visualization of the process of design, design thinking, or designerly thinking. What would such a process look like?231 Such efforts have been explored endlessly and exhaustively—and as such, any mature designer will likely scoff at these broad-brush, oftentimes diagrammatic attempts. This dismissive position stems from senior designers’ basic understanding that no two design problems are alike, and thus rarely are any two design processes alike.

    B. The Participatory Contributors to the [Dynamic-Integrative] “Table” of Design: From the design of a poster to the design of a regional master plan, we might imagine a table with any number of chairs. Those seated in these chairs may contribute in multivariate ways, not limited to form, content(s), perspective(s), or material(s), ethics, and more. Using architecture as an example, we might imagine this table as an extended and engaged version of the more traditional integrated team: the architects, owners, engineers, financiers, community, and more. ¶ Here one might ponder what role AI will or could have as a potentially participatory participant at the table of design. Thus far, research examining the use of generative artificial intelligence (GAI) in tandem with design thinking methodologies seems to present both opportunities and drawbacks that suggest that designers need to carefully consider the role of AI in tadem with design efforts. For instance, one study published in 2026 examined how generative artificial intelligence (GAI) influences university student creativity in collaborative learning environments that employ design thinking methodologies.232 According to the authors, the findings suggest that, “while GAI may assist with aspects of the design thinking process, its use can undermine creative engagement when it replaces rather than supports human ideation and reflection.”233 Such research suggests that while GAI might well serve to quickly provide data, references, and information to participants at the table of design, for now it might not be beneficial to consider GAI a participant at the table itself. Beyond this, some designers assert that our understanding of human behavior (essential to design) is, in fact, one of design’s234 core “mediums.”235 This list maker contends that this medium might best be assessed by humans.

    C. The Operation and Behavior of the [Dynamic-Integrative] “Table” of Design: At the table of design, we might observe the convergence of expertise, perspectives, and concerns that may, in many cases, be in tension or conflict. Here, using principles of countenance evaluation,236 the designer encounters the thorny question of who decides and how. While the designer does not always decide, the designer helps lead the decision-making process. Some architects or designers may have a strong or leading voice in this process, while others may take on a more passive stewardship (rather than leadership) oriented role.

    The [Proven] Value of Design-Centered Design (DCD)

    As is noted in the introduction to these lists, this list-maker explores design as an uncommon combinatory challenge space “at the center of that which is meant to be centered.”237 Such a bold claim seems to be supported by the consistent but especially recent emergence of countless hyphenated variants of design: e.g., x-centered design, or x-based design. Such foci and methods range from user-centered design to evidence-based design, human-centered design to all life-centered design, and more. Now, paradoxically, it may be time for design to reconverge in what we might, in non-paternalistic 21st-century terms, call “design-centered design” (DCD). This evolution of design might be described as one of accumulation, as a multitude of factors are continuously centered and decentered. Over time, we could imagine these centered and decentered factors and concerns leaving trails of sand over the “table” of design—such that the trails of accumulated sand over time have paradoxically created a cogent new folded-in “whole” of design. ¶ Design as “Collage” ¶ In academia, we might thus posit design as a “big-tent” domain, which might be imagined (or reimagined) as the “collage of design as college of design.” Between tables, tents, and collages, this list-maker asks readers for forgiveness as he attempts to find metaphors that might help them understand the nature and trajectory of design in the 21st century. This notion of linking design’s epistemology to “collage” is at least somewhat supported in a 2026 paper by Steven McCarthy and Jessica Barness. In their paper, “Dancing with scissors: collage as visual design scholarship,” McCarthy and Barness begin to articulate the merits of collage, not only as a formal and aesthetic process but also a methodological one. Central to understanding this methodological “turn” is (as this list maker has explored in An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course) 1) seeing “text” as more than “text” (images, sound, and movement are also texts in the sense that they can be “read”) and 2) (as McCarthy and Barness describe at the outset of their paper) seeing collage as a broad combinatory mode that is becoming at once more accessible, ubiquitous, and also, in some contexts an accepted form of research and inquiry. As McCarthy and Barness state, “The term research implies the act of looking again, the re-searching of sources, as essential to its meaning. Collage shares this quality, as both employ a methodology of closely combing through existing data to create new combinations and interpretations.”238 ¶ Here, this list maker might ask readers to posit this Curious Compendium, with its many fragments, references, quotes, and citations, as a “collage” of sorts. The concept put forward in this section— DCD, supported by scholarship around design dynamics, take these ideas one step further by staking a claim not on collage itself, but rather on the humanistic, organizational, and epistemological tensions and concerns of design as “collaging.” ¶ The Value of Placing Design at the Center ¶ As this list maker has explored elsewhere, one might counter this position by arguing that if everything and anything can be centered on design, then design is merely an empty vessel. This argument, however, conflates design as a final destination rather than the far more salient usage posited here: design as an integrative-intellectual “space.” Thus, design is not just the vessel but the agent for reactions to occur in that vessel. Unlocking this agent- and agency-oriented understanding of design may yield tremendous value for communities and corporations alike. This argument seems to be well supported by the undeniable success of businesses that have consistently and intentionally placed design at the center. Apple is but one example. As of this writing (in 2026) Apple is viewed by some as the most valuable company in the world.239 Couple that fact with, what Apple’s CEO John Ternus noted in a 2026 interview with TIME: “I think what’s so special about this place is design [emphasis added] is at the center of it.”240 Ternus follows that with the following statement: “design means everything to us.”241 ¶ The average listener of Ternus’ interview might assume that Ternus is specifically referring to design as style, shape, form, and aesthetics. Still, Ternus quickly points out that at Apple, design is a cross-disciplinary capacity spanning software, hardware, engineering, and more. Yet this discourse also follows a “yes, and” structure: it is also true that many people view Apple products as aesthetically beautiful. This latter statement, and what follows, briefly indicates that design need not abandon its concern for form and aesthetics. ¶ The In-Disciplinary and the Aesthetic ¶ As is indicated above in Leg #4, as big-tent design continues to mature, it need not abandon the aesthetic and formal aspects that sparked its remarkable identity and growth. This is indicated in the aforementioned notion of the “collage of design as college of design.” Let us now literally imagine a collage of design as college of design that welcomes scientific evidence as much as it welcomes artistic expression. ¶ Paul Rand once said, “Design is the method of putting form and content together. Design, just as art, has multiple definitions; there is no single definition. Design can be art. Design can be aesthetics. Design is so simple, that’s why it is so complicated.”242 While Rand’s sentiment is well understood, one could easily counter it with a line of reasoning that posits design as everything and thus design as nothing. This calls for scholars also to draw uncomfortable lines around what design is not. The collage of design as college [or school] of design is not an “art school”—but it welcomes artists; likewise, the collage of design is not “engineering” or “business” or “design science” or “health” or “fashion” or “technology” or “media” or “language” or “style.” As one example from those just mentioned, engineers are welcome to take part in the design collage as college—but design is not engineering and engineering is not design. Such formulations of design as a disciplinary “bridge” have been described in various combinations and in various ways. For instance, in a heavily researched 2017 book, The In-Discipline of Design,243 Annie Gentes posited design as not belonging entirely to engineering, the hard sciences, or the humanities. Instead, Gentes describes how design can operate across and between them. Along these lines, Mitesh Dixit et al.’s 2026 book Pedagogies for Anti-Disciplinary Design Education244 gathers perspectives from over a dozen contributors from just as many countries to posit and engage disciplines beyond the traditional architecture and design schools. In the afterword, the editors state, “Anti-disciplinary pedagogy begins from a straightforward premise: design is a way of making knowledge. It is not secondary to art or a stand-in for science, but a mode of inquiry that can reveal things neither field can see alone.”245 Later, the editors state, “An anti-disciplinary stance centers situated knowledges and improvised, hands-on methods as much as remote sensing (Collard and Heller).”246 The latter part of this statement reflects the role of and availability of data in relation to design. Regardless of the disciplinary modifier chosen, from the in-disciplinary, to the anti-disciplinary to the alter-disciplinary and more, 21st-century designers and design educators are steadily leaning into the centering epistemological qualities of designing and design. ¶ Alas, scholars arguing for design as an indisciplinary or even antidisciplinary space seems to be gaining international attention and appeal. Several examples of this discourse can be found in an issue of the DIID (Disegno Industriale Industrial Design) journal from 2020. In an editorial written by the Italian architect and design scholar Tonino Paris, we can trace designers grappling with the patterns and bounds of knowledge itself. For instance, Paris states, “Each ‘knowledge pattern’ should contain reasonable margins of flexibility that would capture, preserve and enhance the differences and peculiarities of the disciplines and the operational practices involved in research.”247 Paris follows that with, “The different expertise having their roots in sectorial knowledge should be able to communicate to each other through a common language that can convert and adapt specialized knowledge.”248 Design seems to be emerging as the common space for such communication. ¶ Alas, this list maker hopes that these brief reflections on design’s intermixing of knowledge might provide some clarity and substance towards his argument and around the “collage” as an apt description of design. Collage typically describes the combining of materials, forms, or “fragments” into a unified whole. Artists of all ages often use glue to “stick” fragments together to create a collage. This use of collage as a metaphor exemplifies design because design systematically brings a wide range of “things” together. “Things” in this case span people, disciplines, materials, form, content, expertise, and more. How or why this defining property of design has gotten lost is beyond the scope of this research. To the detriment of this expansive definition, we encounter narrow views of design that, among other things, merely suggest preference or a change in form, or change of state. If instead, we ponder what a “space for design” is, just as we might ask what a “space for engineering” is, or what space science generally occupies, we begin to posit a more mature understanding of what it means to design. ¶ Notably, the collage of design is not meant to cannibalize any of the aforementioned disciplines or fields—but rather, it serves as the alterdisciplinary meeting point—the collage, the table, the college where a range of ideas and perspectives collide. If anything, it reinforces, elevates, and celebrates the richness and plurality of “knowing” that spans our vast human traditions and institutions. While this may all sound a bit speculative, such discourse reflects the qualitative reality of designing in the 21st century. For instance, in a 2023 interview between design educators Sven Ingmar Thies and Fritz Frenkler, Frenkler and Thies reflect upon the “cross institutional and cross-disciplinary”249 capacity of design. In the interview, Frenkler’s description of what happens in his studio might reframe stereotypical notions of what design can do. Frenkler, who was Professor of Architecture at the Technical University of Munich, notes how in his studio you will now find projects involving “designers, programmers, engineers and other specialists” and states that, “It is becoming increasingly important for everyone to develop in-depth understanding for and engage in communication with other colleagues.”250 Later in the interview, Frenkler notes how disciplines not limited to engineering, economics, psychology, sociology, marketing, and a discipline that Frenkler regards as key, philosophy, can contribute to design. Frenkler notes that, “designers need to be in a position to moderate processes and not appear arrogant.”251 ¶ To moderate such processes, designers, especially architects and planners who wish to lead design efforts, thus need to deeply understand the nature, behaviors, flow, and expertise present at the table and “in the collage.” This understanding is all too often undermined by the design-dependency dearth-discourse dilemma highlighted in this series’ introduction. The causes of this dilemma lie within the slow pace of change in design education. Instead of developing an understanding of moderating, integrative, and thinking processes of design, many design students still partake in (and are thus the products of) a form and skill heavy curriculum. Then paradoxically other disciplines seem more interested in the “thinking” aspects of design. ¶ As one example of how this plays out in academia and industry alike, let’s imagine an alternate scenario whereby a domain such as science were treated just as the domain of design all too often is. For instance, in such a scenario we might imagine an undergraduate instructor in music who wishes to immerse students in the methods of science. Imagine this music instructor taking a two-hour course in “science thinking”—and then, when finished, hosting a “science thinking” workshop within their music course. All too often, as this list-maker can attest, this is how “design” is viewed, explored, and applied. ¶ Within sizable academic institutions, domains such as business, art, law, and health are typically organized as colleges or schools. With design, this is occasionally the case, as in design schools, or colleges of design—but just as frequently design is awkwardly placed within other domains (design placed within business, within engineering, within the arts, within any other number of things). In other cases, design is placed alongside two or three adjacent disciplines to create any number of awkward disciplinary-soup acronyms. In yet other cases, and perhaps even worse, design is treated as an initiative rather than a real academic pursuit. ¶ Interestingly, 20th-century architects and educators such as Joseph F. Hudnut252 (1886–1968) seemed to avoid any number of these traps when they founded some of the first schools of design in North America. They also intuitively viewed architecture not as separate from design, but as one of many core disciplines under the very big tent of design. Without digressing too far into the history of design education, many of these figures also seemed to intuitively understand the designer as someone who broadly plans, orchestrates, and facilitates projects across a range of media, typologies, and scales. Even then, in such “design-centered design” spaces, the tools and technologies used seemed less important than the principles underpinning design’s pedagogical focus. ¶ As a consequence of the more recent uses and occasional misuses of “design,” the figures charged with orchestrating, facilitating, and leading the “table of design” initiatives are somewhat ill-equipped to do so. By this, this list-maker suggests that these figures sometimes lead design-oriented initiatives without a deep understanding of design. As this list-maker has witnessed, these figures attempt to learn as they go. Often, as noted earlier, these design-interested parties stumble upon pre-packaged thinking methods that dismantle the dynamic qualities that make design so special by replacing them with linear steps. ¶ One should not place the blame on these well-intentioned facilitators; such occurrences are in part the product of design education’s often narrow focus on ever-changing software, skills, and technologies. In some cases, we [design-educators] have focused on the “tress of design” rather than the “forest of design.” For design students, this overemphasis on production has, in some cases, replaced time for “thinking” with time for tools. Moreover, these students risk never encountering the principles that underpin a life in design. ¶ We can do better. We have to do better. The collages, tables, and disciplines within the domain of design are too crucial to be left adrift. Science is led by scientists—those who demonstrate a commitment to and understanding of scientific materials, methods, and means. Designers should likewise lean into, return to, claim, and embrace its uncommon, potent, and dynamic quality. As we will explore in the next section, this designful quality is somewhat paradoxically design’s aesthetic.

  14. Designful: The previous section on dynamism posits the dynamics of placing design “at the center” and how that placement might affect processes and approaches to designing itself. For years, this list-maker has been intrigued by organizations that, in one way or another and to various degrees, already seem to exemplify this design-centric attitude. Then, in 2009, a succinct book seemed to crystallize the notion of the design-centric organization: The Designful Company by Marty Neumeier. ¶ Between the lines, Neumeier seems to have foreseen a structural opportunity for design—not by placing “the designer” at the center, but by placing design, as a strategic and humanistic value, at the center. In the first line of the preface, Neumeier boldly proclaims: “Welcome to the future of business,” and then suggests that his book was positioned to help employees and leaders alike “ride the powerful currents of change.”253 Some, if not many, critical readers might pause after reading these few lines and immediately fear an onslaught of false-confidence-building consultant chatter. Even worse, in the last line of the first paragraph, Neumeier states, “I hope The Designful Company will serve as your personal guide to nonstop innovation.”254 Neumeier’s use of terms such as “hope” and phrases such as “nonstop innovation” did not exactly scream of scholarly rigor or nuance. ¶ After this arguably weak opening gambit, Neumeier’s “airplane book” encouraging editorial style is, somewhat surprisingly, consistently paired with remarkable insight—some of it backed by tangible data. Moreover, page by page Neumeier emerges as a mature, observant strategist who (many years before AI) seems to foresee design as a potentially perfect partner for addressing the growing complexities of business in the 21st century. Even four pages into the book, Neumeier begins unpacking this cogent thesis: “Today we’re finding that innovation without emotion is uninteresting. Products without aesthetics are uncompelling. Brands without meaning are undesirable. And business without ethics is unsustainable.”255 Before jumping to design as a possible cure, Neumeier reveals a symptom: “The management model that got us here is underpowered to move us forward.”256 ¶ This list-maker was so intrigued by the book’s premise that he somehow convinced the President of the firm he was working for to buy a copy for all employees. As anyone who has worked in the corporate world can attest, building alignment around anything can be difficult. Yet design as the book’s focal point and, by extension, design as the firm’s focal point seemed to resonate. The Designful Company is delivered in three concise sections: 1) The Power of Design, 2) The Rebirth of Aesthetics, and 3) Levers for Change. As the book approaches its 20th anniversary, and as I reread it now, this list maker suggests that Neumeier may have unnecessarily limited the book’s scope to business. Nearly 20 years later, this list maker is likely not alone in positing the designful community, the designful school, the designful university, and even (gasp) what it might mean to be a designful person. This next stage “unlocking” of the designful lies in design not as a “process” or “method” but as a “way of being” beyond the corporate—but one that likewise elevates and centers a whole host of complexities around design.

With utmost gratitude to the many voices cited and referenced. First published 18 Apr 2026. Last updated 31 Oct 2026. Please send edits, corrections, and suggestions to this address.


Footnotes

  1. See: “John Chris Jones.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 11 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Chris_Jones. ↩︎
  2. See: “Design methods.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 9 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Design_methods. ↩︎
  3. Jones, John Chris. Design Methods (2nd ed.). Van Nostrand, 1992: p. iv. ↩︎
  4. Since Jones notes “craft evolution,” see also “Craft” in An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course. ↩︎
  5. See: “Design studies.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 14 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Design_studies. ↩︎
  6. Loc. cit., p. 4. ↩︎
  7. “Christopher Alexander.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 28 Oct 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christopher_Alexander. ↩︎
  8. Alexander, Christopher. in “The State of the Art In Design Methodology: Interviewed by Max Jacobson.” Design Methods Group (DMG) Newsletter, Vol. 5, No. 3, pp. 3-7, https://christopher-alexander-ces-archive.org/article/the-state-of-the-art-in-design-methodology-interviewed-by-max-jacobson/. ↩︎
  9. Jones, John Chris. designing designing. Bloomsbury, 2021, back cover. ↩︎
  10. Ibid., xii. ↩︎
  11. Bennett, Audrey, editor. Design Studies: Theory and Research in Graphic Design. Princeton Architectural Press, 2006, p. 14. ↩︎
  12. Ibid. ↩︎
  13. Heskett, John. Design: A Very Short Introduction, Oxford, 2002, p. 1. ↩︎
  14. Ibid. ↩︎
  15. At present, this list maker has found merit in the term “alterplinary” as an apt description of design as an epistemological area. The term “alterplinarity” is credited to Paul A. Rodgers and Craig Bremner. It was first introduced in their 2011 paper “Alterplinarity—‘Alternative Disciplinarity’ in Future Art and Design Research Pursuits.” See: Rodgers, Paul, and Craig Bremner. “Alterplinarity: ‘Alternative Disciplinarity’ in Future Art and Design Research Pursuits.” Studies in Material Thinking, vol. 6, Dec. 2011, pp. 1-16. AUT University, http://materialthinking.aut.ac.nz/sites/default/files/papers/Rodgers_Bremner.pdf. ↩︎
  16. Rodgers and Bremner expanded upon this position in their 2017 paper, “The Concept Of The Design Discipline,” in which the authors put forward orward an “alterplinary manifesto,” with alterplinary described as “a portmanteau of ‘alternative’ and ‘disciplinary.’” See: Rodgers, Paul A., and Craig Bremner. “The Concept of the Design Discipline.” Dialectic, vol. 1, no. 1, 2017, pp. 19–38. https://doi.org/10.3998/dialectic.14932326.0001.104. ↩︎
  17. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  18. Loc. cit., p. 331. ↩︎
  19. Ibid. ↩︎
  20. Loc. cit., p. 332. ↩︎
  21. “Into, through and for” is a nod to Sir Christopher’s oft-referenced paper, “Research in Art and Design.” See: Frayling, Christopher. “Research in Art and Design.” Royal College of Art Research Papers. 1(1), (1993/4), pp. 1-5. ↩︎
  22. Loc. cit., p. iv. ↩︎
  23. See: Cross, Nigel. “Designerly ways of knowing.” Design Studies, vol. 3, no. 4, Oct 1982, pp. 221-227. ↩︎
  24. See: “Nigel Cross.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 29 Dec 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nigel_Cross. ↩︎
  25. “Open University.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 26 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_University. ↩︎
  26. See: Cross, Nigel. “Developing Design as a Discipline.” Journal of Engineering Design, vol. 29, no. 12, 2018, pp. 691-708. ↩︎
  27. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  28. See: “Solutionism.” Cambridge Advanced Learner’s Dictionary & Thesaurus, Cambridge University Press, www.dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/solutionism. Accessed 12 June 2026. ↩︎
  29. Loc. cit., 225. ↩︎
  30. Loc. cit. 224. ↩︎
  31. Lawson, Bryan R. Problem Solving in Architectural Design. 1972. University of Aston in Birmingham, PhD dissertation. Aston Publications Repository, publications.aston.ac.uk/id/eprint/40597/1/Lawson_BR_1972.pdf. ↩︎
  32. Loc. cit., 226. ↩︎
  33. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  34. See: Cross, Nigel. “Design thinking: What just happened?” Design Studies, vol. 86, 2023, p. 7, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.destud.2023.101187. ↩︎
  35. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  36. See also: “Context” in An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course. ↩︎
  37. Kolko, Jon. “Novelty ≠ Creativity: The Problem of Psychological Measurement in Design Practice and Education.” Design Issues, vol. 42, no. 2, Spring 2026, p. 4, https://doi.org/10.1162/DESI.a.727. ↩︎
  38. Poggenpohl, Sharon and Sato Keiichi. Design Integrations: Research and Collaboration. Intellect, 2009, pp. 10–11. ↩︎
  39. Ibid. ↩︎
  40. See: “Bauhaus.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 20 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bauhaus. ↩︎
  41. Poggenpohl and Soto, Back Cover. ↩︎
  42. Ibid. ↩︎
  43. Berry, Anne H. et al. Guiding Principles for Inclusive Design Values: Reimagining Design Practice and Education. Rockport, 2026, p. 201. ↩︎
  44. Julier, Guy. The Culture of Design. 2nd ed. Sage, 2014, p. xi. ↩︎
  45. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  46. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  47. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  48. “Don Norman.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 9 Aug 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don_Norman. ↩︎
  49. “The Design of Everyday Things.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 28 Apr 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Design_of_Everyday_Things. ↩︎
  50. Gram, Maggie. The Invention of Design. Basic Books, 2025, Inside Front Jacket. ↩︎
  51. Ibid., p. 6. ↩︎
  52. Gibson, Michael R., and Keith M. Owens, editors. Navigating the Landscapes of Design Research: Finding Your Way. Routledge, 2026, p. 1–3. ↩︎
  53. Ibid., p. 4–20. ↩︎
  54. Sparke, Penny. An Introduction to Design and Culture. Fifth ed. Routledge, 2026, p. 6. ↩︎
  55. See: Mejía, M. “Assemblages of Design Activities: From Trade to Strategy”. Diid, no. 88, May 2026, pp. 89-95, doi:10.30682/diid8826f. ↩︎
  56. Loc. cit., 63. ↩︎
  57. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  58. Loc. cit., 64. ↩︎
  59. In 2004, the American designer Hugh Dubberly collected and compiled over a hundred examples of such “how” diagrams and then self-published them in a book titled How do you design? A Compendium of Models. See: Dubberly, Hugh. How do you design? A Compendium of Models. Dubberly Design Office, 2005, Available at: https://www.dubberly.com/articles/how-do-you-design.html. ↩︎
  60. See: “Double Diamond (design process model).” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 19 Apr 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Diamond_(design_process_model). ↩︎
  61. For a short history of the Double Diamond, see: https://www.designcouncil.org.uk/resources/the-double-diamond/history-of-the-double-diamond/. ↩︎
  62. See: “Convergence” in An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course. ↩︎
  63. As an alternative to brainstorming, see “Charettes” in An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course. ↩︎
  64. Loc. cit., 64. ↩︎
  65. Ibid. ↩︎
  66. A more thorough exploration of these ideas can be found in this list maker’s 2025 motion graphics film, Towards a Dynamic Discipline of Design. See: Vlahos, Dan, and Steven Cotroneo. “Towards a Dynamic Discipline of Design.” Motion Graphics Film, Presented at the 2025 Motion Design Education Summit (MODE ’25), June 2025, Prague, Available at: https://danvlahos.com/work/towards-a-dynamic-discipline-of-design/. ↩︎
  67. Loc. cit., 278. ↩︎
  68. “Marjorie Elliott Bevlin.” The Islands’ Sounder, 6 July 2009, https://www.islandssounder.com/2009/07/06/marjorie-elliott-bevlin/. ↩︎
  69. Bevlin, Marjorie Elliot. Design Through Discovery (1st ed.). Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1963, p. v. ↩︎
  70. Bevlin, Marjorie Elliot. Design Through Discovery (6th ed.). Harcourt Brace, 1991, p. vii. ↩︎
  71. Ibid. ↩︎
  72. See: “Biomimetics.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 25 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biomimetics. ↩︎
  73. Loc. cit., v. ↩︎
  74. Ibid. ↩︎
  75. Seel. N. (Ed.). (2012) Encyclopedia of the Sciences of Learning (pp. 1009-1012). New York: Springer Science & Business Media. ↩︎
  76. See: “Constructivism (philosophy of education).” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 11 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constructivism_(philosophy_of_education). ↩︎
  77. “Jean Piaget.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 14 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean_Piaget. ↩︎
  78. See: “Active learning.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 1 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Active_learning. ↩︎
  79. See: Davis, Meredith et. al. Design as a Catalyst for Learning. Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development, 1997. ↩︎
  80. See: McLaughlin, Jacqueline E., et al. “Design Thinking Teaching and Learning in Higher Education: Experiences across Four Universities.” PLOS ONE, vol. 17, no. 3, 2022, e0265902. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0265902. ↩︎
  81. See: “Charles and Ray Eames.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 17 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_and_Ray_Eames. ↩︎
  82. The Vignelli’s Archives currently reside at Rochester Institute of Technology. See: “Vignelli Archives.” Rochester Institute of Design, https://www.rit.edu/vignellicenter/vignelli-archives. ↩︎
  83. See: Muller, Richard A. Dictionary of Latin and Greek Theological Terms: Drawn Principally from Protestant Scholastic Theology. Baker Academic, 2017. ↩︎
  84. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  85. See: “Critique” in An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course. ↩︎
  86. Ibid. ↩︎
  87. Tharp, Bruce M. and Stephanie M. Tharp. Discursive Design: Critical, Speculative, and Alternative Things. MIT Press, 2018, p. 5. ↩︎
  88. Ibid. ↩︎
  89. See: “Critical design.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 6 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_design. ↩︎
  90. See: “Human-centered design.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 4 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human-centered_design. ↩︎
  91. See: “Participatory design.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 16 April 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Participatory_design. ↩︎
  92. “Sharon Poggenpohl.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 17 Dec 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sharon_Poggenpohl. ↩︎
  93. Poggenpohl, Sharon. Design Theory to Go. Ligature Press, 2018, p. 195. ↩︎
  94. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  95. Poggenpohl, p. Back Cover. ↩︎
  96. Ibid., p. 168. ↩︎
  97. Ibid., p. 176. ↩︎
  98. Morin, Edgar. On Complexity. Hampton Press, 2008, p. 49. ↩︎
  99. Loc. cit., p. 183. ↩︎
  100. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  101. Students interested in design might benefit from more focused study in subjects such as discourse analysis. See: “Discourse analysis.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 17 Dec 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discourse_analysis. ↩︎
  102. Coy, Chris. “Milton Glaser Draws & Lectures.” Vimeo, uploaded by C Coy, 9 Oct 2006, https://vimeo.com/6986303. ↩︎
  103. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  104. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  105. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  106. Prestbo, Bradford J., FAIA, From Mind to Paper. Prestbo Press, 2024, p. 3-7. ↩︎
  107. “Hand axe.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 17 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hand_axe. ↩︎
  108. See: Brown, Tim. Change by Design. HarperBusiness, 2009. ↩︎
  109. “Sam Farber.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 11 Mar 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sam_Farber. ↩︎
  110. “Smart Design.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 13 Apr 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_Design. ↩︎
  111. “Affordance.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 15 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affordance. ↩︎
  112. “User-centered design.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 4 Oct 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User-centered_design. ↩︎
  113. “Ergonomics.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 6 Jun 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ergonomics. ↩︎
  114. “Universal design.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 10 Jun 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_design. ↩︎
  115. “Accessibility.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 7 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accessibility. ↩︎
  116. “Materials science.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 31 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Materials_science. ↩︎
  117. “Good Grips Peeler, 1989.” The Museum of Modern Art, Object no. 401.1994, https://www.moma.org/collection/works/3758. ↩︎
  118. “Karim Rashid.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 15 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karim_Rashid. ↩︎
  119. “Garbino Trash Can, 1996.” The Museum of Modern Art, Object no. 503.2005.1-11, https://www.moma.org/collection/works/98330. ↩︎
  120. One of the earliest and most notable of these voices was Victor Papanek, who first published his book, Design for the Real World: Human Ecology and Social Change, in 1971. See: “Victor Papanek.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 20 Nov 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victor_Papanek. ↩︎
  121. Volf, Michael. “Karim Rashid’s Garbo at 20: Does It Still Hold Up?” Metropolis, 19 Jan. 2016, metropolismag.com/viewpoints/karim-rashids-garbo-20/. ↩︎
  122. Also known as the “digital age.” See: “Information Age.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 11 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_Age. ↩︎
  123. “Chris Anderson (entrepreneur).” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 14 Feb 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chris_Anderson_(entrepreneur). ↩︎
  124. Anderson, Chris. “TED Curator Chris Anderson on Crowd Accelerated Innovation,” Wired, December 2010, https://www.wired.com/2010/12/ff_tedvideos/. ↩︎
  125. “TED (conference).” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 28 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TED_(conference). ↩︎
  126. “The Long Tail (book).” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 28 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Long_Tail_(book). ↩︎
  127. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  128. Nelson, Harold G., and Erik Stolterman. The Design Way (2nd ed.). MIT Press, 2012. ↩︎
  129. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  130. See: “The Splendor of Design” pp. 191–200. ↩︎
  131. Loc. cit., p. 191. ↩︎
  132. Maeda, John. How to Speak Machine. Portfolio/Penguin, 2019, p. xiii. ↩︎
  133. “Interaction design.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 3 Feb 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interaction_design. ↩︎
  134. “User experience design.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 11 Jun 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_experience_design. ↩︎
  135. “Muriel Cooper.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 27 Apr 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muriel_Cooper. ↩︎
  136. An event celebrating Cooper’s life and work was held at MIT in 2017, where many of her former students and colleagues reflected on her impact. See: “Muriel Cooper’s Lasting Imprint.” MIT Media Lab, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, www.media.mit.edu/posts/muriel-cooper-lasting-imprint/.. ↩︎
  137. “MIT Media Lab.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 29 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MIT_Media_Lab. ↩︎
  138. Reinfurt, David, and Robert Wiesenberger. Muriel Cooper. The MIT Press, 2017, xv. ↩︎
  139. “Lev Manovich.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 6 Jun 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lev_Manovich. ↩︎
  140. “New media.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 28 Apr 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_media. ↩︎
  141. Manovich, Lev. The Language of New Media. The MIT Press, 2001, pp. 218–243. ↩︎
  142. Ibid., p. 218. ↩︎
  143. Ibid., p. 219. ↩︎
  144. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  145. See: “Why Google Engineers Design by Numbers.” The Guardian, 5 Feb. 2014, www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/feb/05/why-google-engineers-designers
    . ↩︎
  146. Ibid. ↩︎
  147. Ibid. ↩︎
  148. See for instance: Darzentas, Dimitrios. et. al. “Data-inspired co-design for museum and gallery visitor experiences.” Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing, 36, Article e14. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0890060421000317. ↩︎
  149. Pfeffer, Jeffrey, and Robert I. Sutton. The Knowing-Doing-Gap. Harvard Business School Press, 2000. ↩︎
  150. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  151. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  152. Cohen, Harlow B. “The Performance Paradox,” Academy of Management Executives, 12 (1998): 30. ↩︎
  153. Ibid. ↩︎
  154. As referenced in the D-Words Introduction. See: Rodgers and Bremner. ↩︎
  155. See: Lidwell et. al. Universal Principles of Design (3rd ed.). Rockport, 2023, 104-105. ↩︎
  156. “T. S. Eliot.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 10 July 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T._S._Eliot. ↩︎
  157. “Four Quartets.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 11 July 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Quartets. ↩︎
  158. See: “Burnt Norton.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 4 Feb 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burnt_Norton. ↩︎
  159. “Burnt Norton.” Encyclopædia Britannica, Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc., Accessed 22 Jul. 2026,  www.britannica.com/topic/Burnt-Norton. ↩︎
  160. Elliot, T. S., The Four Quartets, HarperCollins, 1971 [1943], p. 15. ↩︎
  161. This list maker will note that while these terms [positive and negative distraction] are somewhat subjective and context-dependent—for instance, in architecture and design, a positive distraction may describe an environmental feature that reduces stress or diverts attention. The use of positive distraction here is both inclusive of and broader than such a definition. ↩︎
  162. “Hexis.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 8 July 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hexis. ↩︎
  163. Ulrich, Roger S. “View Through a Window May Influence Recovery from Surgery.” Science, vol. 224, no. 4647, 1984, pp. 420–421. PubMed, https://doi.org/10.1126/science.6143402. ↩︎
  164. “Evidence-based design.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 82 July 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evidence-based_design. ↩︎
  165. Han, Ke-Tsung, et al. “Effects of Indoor Plants on Human Functions: A Systematic Review with Meta-Analyses.” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, vol. 19, no. 12, 2022, p. 7454. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph19127454. ↩︎
  166. Jiang, Shan. “Positive Distractions and Play in the Public Spaces of Pediatric Healthcare Environments: A Literature Review.” HERD: Health Environments Research & Design Journal, vol. 13, no. 3, 2020, pp. 171–197. https://doi.org/10.1177/1937586720901707. ↩︎
  167. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  168. “Dark pattern.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 18 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_pattern. ↩︎
  169. “Infinite scrolling.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 26 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infinite_scrolling. ↩︎
  170. “Doomscrolling.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 16 July 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomscrolling. ↩︎
  171. Leo XIV, Pope. Magnifica Humanitas. The Holy See, 2026, sec. 136. ↩︎
  172. Lang, James M. Distracted: Why Students Can’t Focus and What You Can Do About It. Basic Books, 2020, pp. 1–22. ↩︎
  173. Ibid., p. 4. ↩︎
  174. Ibid., p. 17. ↩︎
  175. LeDuc, Brian. “Using design to bring back our humanity in a world full of code | TEDxUCSanDiego.” YouTube, uploaded by Tedx Talks, 4 Aug. 2026,  ↩︎
  176. Ibid. ↩︎
  177. Ibid. ↩︎
  178. Ibid. ↩︎
  179. Ibid. ↩︎
  180. UN General Assembly. “Universal Declaration of Human Rights.” United Nations, 217 (III) A, 1948, https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-human-rights. ↩︎
  181. “Victor Papanek.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 20 Nov 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victor_Papanek. ↩︎
  182. Papanek, Victor. Design for the Real World. 2nd ed., 1971, p. 28. ↩︎
  183. This relationship between Gowan and Papanek is chronicled in: Gowan, Al. Victor Papanek: Path of a Design Prophet, Merrimack Media, 2015. ↩︎
  184. Lobovich, William L. Design for Dignity: Accessible Environments for People with Disabilities. John Wiley & Sons, 1993. ↩︎
  185. “Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 24 July 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Americans_with_Disabilities_Act_of_1990. ↩︎
  186. Antonelli, Paola. Foreword. Designing Questions, by Anab Jain et al., Hatje Cantze, 2026, p. 9 ↩︎
  187. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  188. Hendren, Sara. What Can a Body Do?. Riverhead Books, 2020, p. 3. ↩︎
  189. Ibid, p. 10. ↩︎
  190. Cary, John. Design for Good: A New Era of Architecture for Everyone. Island Press, 2017. ↩︎
  191. Ibid., p. 20. ↩︎
  192. Gates, Melinda. Foreword. Design for Good, by John Cary. Island Press, 2017, p. 13. ↩︎
  193. See: “Wim Gilles.” Dutch Design Daily, 10 Dec. 2017, https://dutchdesigndaily.com/stories/wim-gilles/. ↩︎
  194. “Gilles Paquet.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 15 Nov 2024, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilles_Paquet. ↩︎
  195. Gilles, Willem and Paquet, Gilles, “On Delta Knowledge,” in Edging Toward the Year 2000: Management Research and Education in Canada, Canadian Federation of Deans of Management and Administrative Studies, 1989. ↩︎
  196. Jacques R. Giard is Emeritus Professor of Design in The Design School at Arizona State University (ASU). Before ASU he was director of the School of Industrial Design at Carleton University in Ottawa, Canada. ↩︎
  197. Giard, Jacques, and Wim Gilles. “Delta Knowledge: Place and Significance in Industrial Design Education,” Presented at the ICSID Educational Seminar 2001, Seongnam, Seoul, Korea, October 2001. ↩︎
  198. Ibid. ↩︎
  199. Ibid. ↩︎
  200. “Fritz Machlup.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 13 Mar 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fritz_Machlup. ↩︎
  201. Machlup, Fritz. Knowledge: Its Creation, Distribution, and Economic Significance. Vol. 1: Knowledge and Knowledge Production, Princeton University Press, 1980. ↩︎
  202. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  203. Roth, Ariane, and Marina Schütz. The Dynamic Library: Organizing Knowledge at the Sitterwerk—Precedents and Possibilities. Soberscope Press, 2015, p. 108. ↩︎
  204. Ibid., p. 111. ↩︎
  205. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  206. Gibbons et al. The New Production of Knowledge: The Dynamics of Science and Research in Contemporary Societies. Sage, 2011 [1994], p. 1. ↩︎
  207. Ibid. ↩︎
  208. Zhang, Jiajie. The Cognitive Revolution: How AI is Reorganizing Intelligence, Expertise, and Institutions. Open Intelligence Press, 2026, p. 1. ↩︎
  209. Ibid. ↩︎
  210. Zhang, Jiajie. “Jiajie Zhang, PhD.” D. Bradley McWilliams School of Biomedical Informatics at UTHealth Houston, http://sbmi.uth.edu/zhang/. ↩︎
  211. Ibid., p. 150. ↩︎
  212. Hollan, James, Edwin Hutchins, and David Kirsh. “Distributed Cognition: Toward a New Foundation for Human-Computer Interaction Research.” ACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction, vol. 7, no. 2, 2000, pp. 174–96. https://doi.org/10.1145/353485.353487. ↩︎
  213. Vlahos, Dan. “Codex.” An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course, [2026–], https://danvlahos.com/work/an-incomplete-list-of-c-words-for-the-creative-course/#codex. ↩︎
  214. As referenced in the D-Words Introduction. See: Rodgers and Bremner. ↩︎
  215. See: “Countenance” in An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course. ↩︎
  216. Flores, Kevin, and Jeanine Flores. Design Career Handbook, 2024, p. 115. ↩︎
  217. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  218. “Dynamics (music).” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 28 Sep 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamics_(music). ↩︎
  219. “Fluid dynamics.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 28 Sep 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluid_dynamics ↩︎
  220. This list maker contends that the term dynamics and the term methods refer to entirely different dimensions of how systems operate and also how we approach projects and tasks. “Dynamics” describes behavior sand forces of change within a system, while methods represent the deliberate, structured techniques we use to study, manage, or accomplish something. In architecture and design, dynamics and methods are deeply intertwined and often form a essential (and if captured valuable) feedback loops. ↩︎
  221. Boyer, B. and Lindsay, G. (2026) Chain Drain: Why the Built Environment Struggles to Learn and How to Fix It. v1.11. White Paper. University of Michigan. https://doi.org/10.7302/dspace/30234. ↩︎
  222. Ibid. ↩︎
  223. One might rightly posit what evidence supports this maturing of design. Some qualitative evidence can be found here: Other Tomorrows, and Swissnex in Boston and New York. The Expanding Scope of Design: A Survey of Swiss and US Designers on the State of the Design Landscape, 2023, https://swissnex.org/app/uploads/sites/8/2023/12/The-Expanding-Scope-of-Design-report-1.pdf ↩︎
  224. See: “Dialogic.” ↩︎
  225. See: “Conversation” in An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course. ↩︎
  226. See: “Countenance” in An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course. ↩︎
  227. Vlahos, Dan, and Steven Cotroneo. “Towards a Dynamic Discipline of Design” in Edited Conference Proceedings of the 2025 Motion Design Education Summit, June 19-21, 2025: edited by Jessica Barness et al., MODE Society, 2025, pp. 169-186. ↩︎
  228. Rodgers and Bremner, 2011. ↩︎
  229. Cross, 1982. ↩︎
  230. As but one example, in his seminal book Thoughts on Design, graphic designer Paul Rand stated that visual communications should be viewed as the embodiment of form and function, representing “the integration of the beautiful and the useful.” ↩︎
  231. In part this list maker explored this question in Towards a Dynamic Discipline of Design. See: Vlahos and Cotroneo, 2025. ↩︎
  232. Candi, Marina, et al. “How the Integration of Generative AI in Design Thinking-Based Collaborative Learning Impacts Student Creativity.” The Design Journal, vol. 29, no. 5, 2026, pp. 1251–1270, https://doi.org/10.1080/14606925.2026.2652387. ↩︎
  233. Ibid. ↩︎
  234. This assertion in now way is meant to asuggest that design maintains any central authority around human behavior—but rather an understanding of how such knowledge might be actively applied in collaboration with experts (especially social and behavioral) from other fields. ↩︎
  235. See for instance: Fabricant, Robert. Behavior is our Medium. Vimeo, uploaded by [Interaction Design Association], 2009, https://vimeo.com/3730382
    . ↩︎
  236. See: “Countenance” in An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course. ↩︎
  237. See: An Illustrative Introduction to a Curious Compendium of Incomplete Lists for Productive Practice, https://danvlahos.com/work/an-illustrative-introduction-to-a-curious-compendium-of-incomplete-lists-for-productive-practice/. ↩︎
  238. McCarthy, Steven. “Dancing with Scissors: Collage as Visual Design Scholarship.” Visual Communication, vol. 24, no. 4, 2025, p. 1041. SAGE Journals, https://doi.org/10.1177/14703572251328345. ↩︎
  239. “Apple Just Became the Most Valuable Company in the World. It Faces a Key iPhone Test.” Yahoo Finance, 27 Oct.2026, finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/apple-just-became-most-valuable-174837517.html. ↩︎
  240. “Apple CEO John Ternus on the iPhone Duo, Apple Intelligence AI, and Apple’s Next Big Thing.” YouTube, uploaded by TIME, 20 Oct. 2026, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tNK0lRgi6_w. ↩︎
  241. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  242. Maeda, John. “Thoughts on Paul Rand.” Design Observer, 14 Nov. 2016, designobserver.com/thoughts-on-p-rand/. ↩︎
  243. Gentes, Annie. The In-Discipline of Design: Bridging the Gap Between Humanisities and Engineering, Springer, 2017. ↩︎
  244. Dixit et al. Pedagogies for Anti-Disciplinary Design Education. Routledge, 2026. ↩︎
  245. Ibid., p. 195. ↩︎
  246. Ibid., p. 196. ↩︎
  247. Paris, Tonino. “Design 2030: Knowledge.” diid Disegno Industriale Industrial Design, no. 70, 2020, p 5. ↩︎
  248. Ibid. ↩︎
  249. Thies, Sven Ingmar, editor. Teaching Graphic Design. Birkhäuser, 2023, p. 112. ↩︎
  250. Ibid. ↩︎
  251. Ibid. ↩︎
  252. “Joseph Hudnut.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 28 Sep 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Hudnut. ↩︎
  253. Neumeier, Marty. The Designful Company: How to Build a Culture of Nonstop Innovation. New Riders, 2009, preface. ↩︎
  254. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  255. Ibid., p. 4. ↩︎
  256. Loc. cit. ↩︎

An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course, 2026–Present.

An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course

Contents

I. An Introduction to An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course

C-Word Sections

  1. Care
  2. Craft
  3. Composition
  4. Curation
  5. Curiosity
  6. Consistency
  7. Countenance
  8. Concepts
  9. Currency
  10. Collaboration
  11. Convergence
  12. Comprehensive
  13. Charrettes
  14. Critique
  15. Context
  16. Complexity
  17. Codex
  18. Conversation
  19. Clocks
  20. Clouds
  21. Culture
  22. Change

See Also: An Illustrative Introduction to a Curious Compendium of Incomplete Lists for Productive Practice

—

An Introduction to An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course

In 2002, Richard Florida, an American urban studies theorist and author, released his bestselling book, The Rise of the Creative Class. Florida’s book chronicled the emergence of a broad socio-economic group which Florida labeled the “creative class.”1 Florida’s book identified a segment of the workforce whose economic function is to create new ideas, technologies, creative content, and more. Florida also explored the impacts and implications of the creative class on the economy, regional planning, and other areas of concern. In the book’s original preface, Florida estimated that the “Creative Class” encompassed 30 percent of the US workforce and broadly defined this class as those “who use creativity as a key factor in their work.”2 ¶ About four years after publishing The Rise of the Creative Class, Florida published a follow-up volume titled The Flight of the Creative Class, in which Florida took things one step further by arguing that competition for creative talent would be not only national but global. Florida’s books are highlighted here at the get-go largely because Florida’s notion of the creative class helps frame the typical “who” I’ve encountered in my own creative courses over the years. Thus, the c-words listed below in someways reflect and are also geared towards the “creative class” taking an undergraduate creative course. In fact, it was in my creative course syllabi and lectures that I first developed a variation of the annotated c-word notes summarized below. Beyond reflecting the college classes I teach, the word course in the title of this c-word list might also suggest a direction—a route or path to a particular goal, destination, or place. ¶ As is noted above, Florida’s creative class, when viewed as a socio-economic group or broad demographic, may help readers “bucket” this wide group of contemporary creatives. This bucket, of course, includes designers, architects, writers, artists, and musicians. But more interestingly, Florida also included those who use creativity in their work [emphasis added]­—professions and professionals, working in or across business, education, healthcare, law, and more.3 Fast forward to the present day, and some might argue that Florida’s broadly defined creative class is even wider than it was in 2002. A recent article by Sheon Han serves as a fitting, albeit somewhat anecdotal, example. In a 2024 issue of Wired magazine, Han, who (at the time of this essay) is a Software Engineer in the San Francisco Bay Area, wrote, “Many of today’s programmers—excuse me, software engineers—consider themselves ‘creatives.’”4 Han, who is originally from Seoul, South Korea, first came to the US to study philosophy, literature, and computer science.5 ¶ As a college educator teaching undergraduate courses, I frequently encounter a wide swath of students who possess a variety of skills and interests. Like Han, some of these students—regardless of their academic major or goals—view creativity as integral to their identity, profession, or both. For them, creativity is not merely a “soft skill” listed on a resume, but rather a way of doing, thinking, or being. Some of these creativity-inclined students sense that studying, practicing, or just attempting to better understand creativity will help elevate their professional, personal, and civic pursuits alike—this is, in many cases, why they enroll in my course. Like Han and others, they view creativity as integrative and integral. Thus, as we explore the c-words below, specific applications are not necessarily the focus. Instead, this list merely highlights and explores language, terms, references, and ideas that [I hope] may spark further interest and exploration. ¶ Calls for broader disciplinary connections around, to, and through creativity are certainly not new.6 As such, this c-list largely attempts to resurface some of these ideas in a semi-logical order and in memorable groupings. Along these lines, this c-word list maker owes a debt to a long line of c-word list makers who came before him. For example, in 2015, Sir Ken Robinson published Creative Schools, and within chapter six, “What’s Worth Knowing?” Robinson listed eight c-word competencies. They were: curiosity, creativity, criticism, communication, collaboration, compassion, composure, and citizenship.7 Another c-word-themed exploration appeared in a 2023 paper by Branden Thornhill-Miller et al., who published, “Creativity, Critical Thinking, Communication, and Collaboration: Assessment, Certification, and Promotion of 21st Century Skills for the Future of Work and Education.” Thornhill-Miller et al.’s paper not only conveys and explores these ideas but also, to some degree, offers an assessment that goes beyond mere valorization.8 For those interested in writing, Wendy Bishop and David Starkey cover ten c-word sections in their 2006 book Keywords in Creative Writing. As Bishop and Starkey note in their Introduction,9 their book follows in the tradition of similar works, including Peter Vandenberg’s Keywords in Composition Studies (1996). ¶ As many educators and educational administrators can attest, terms such as skills, competencies, abilities, attitudes, practices, literacies, and behaviors are sometimes used and [unfortunately] abused interchangeably. Furthermore, we [educators] often speak of “soft skills” versus “hard skills,” or practical skills versus theoretical ones, without a clear understanding of the differences. ¶ In yet another c-word-oriented effort from 2023, the Royal Society of Arts convened a group of over 50 businesses and educators to explore life-centric values and perspectives. Their effort yielded what they labeled the “Capabilities for Life” framework, which built upon Sir Ken Robinson’s aforementioned 8 c’s while adding two more (“change” and “courage”).10 ¶ In this thick forest of c-words and pedagogical pairings, I hope students are not already “lost at c.” Thus, let’s slow down and imagine a spectrum with practice-oriented language, such as “skills,” on one side, and more analytical attributes, such as “competencies” or “theories,” on the other. Such a spectrum affords us a horizontal view of knowledge, thereby enabling a more nuanced discussion that avoids tired discourses of “higher” versus “lower” order knowledge. ¶ While dozens of c-words made this list-maker’s short list, and while some c-words could be added later, I’ve selected an initial set of terms that I sense are timely. I understand that timeliness is subjective, but by selecting these big-tent terms, students and fellow educators can use them as frames for considering the multivariate challenges and opportunities before them. States of knowing, making, and doing continually and dynamically shift in response to new technologies and more. With this in mind, I invite students to view this list critically, or perhaps even with skepticism. Doing so will further define and cultivate one’s own practice, pathways, and perspectives. Even if one supports the ideas presented here, I would also encourage students to ponder what Thornhill-Miller et al. describe as “the challenges of teaching and institutionalizing”11 them.

be a list maker

As you explore the c-words that follow, I encourage you to make your own word lists and, likewise, ponder how these references might open up new pathways, possibilities, or perhaps even help close perceptual gaps that can prohibit creative collaboration. But what is a perceptual gap? In their 2002 book Creating Breakthrough Products, Jonathan Cagen and Craig M. Vogel briefly explored differences in disciplinary perspectives—labeling them “perceptual gaps.”12|13 In my creative practice and teaching, I have witnessed these project-stalling disciplinary gaps firsthand. The good news is that we can proactively prepare for and manage these gaps. Despite a sometimes common misnomer that creatives “live in their own heads,” high-performing creatives, architects, designers, directors, and others tend to be quite adept at closing perceptual gaps and disciplinary divides. But like any skill, the ability to productively gather people around ideas takes practice, and some are better suited to the task than others. ¶ With each problem and project, creatives can become more adept at navigating the complexity of the creative process itself: at once seeing the opportunities, challenges, perspectives, and innumerable factors before them. This is where things get “fuzzy”—in business and creativity alike—because this knowledge or skill becomes tacit, making it harder to qualify and quantify. But those who practice and master the creative process may be well-equipped to solve some of the peskiest problems and close such otherwise persistent perceptual gaps. ¶ In 2005, just a few years after Florida published The Rise of the Creative Class, Daniel H. Pink, another creativity-minded American author, released his best-selling book A Whole New Mind: Why Right-Brainers Will Rule the Future. Somewhat akin to Florida’s book, Pink posited the growing value of creative and critical thinking in a post-information age economy. For many—this list-maker included—the book struck a creative chord. In fact, Oprah Winfrey, as part of her 2008 commencement address at Stanford University, gave Pink’s book away to all graduates.14 While one might view Pink’s right-brain provocations as wishful thinking or dated in the age of AI, one could also consider the opposite: creativity could be one of the most vital tools in one’s tool chest. This is because the human brain can do so many things computers cannot—imagine, reason, invent, negotiate, assess, discern, and more. ¶ In 2010, about five years after Pink published his book, a global survey (led by IBM) of 1,500 CEOs across all sectors revealed that, in their view, the most important leadership quality for business success was creativity.15 In another survey of CEOs conducted seven years later, 77% of respondents reported struggling to find the creativity and innovation skills they needed.16 Moving into the present day, one might again wonder how rapid advances in technology and automation will further affect and shape the landscape of practice. Unfortunately, I do not have a crystal ball—but we can certainly look around for answers. ¶ In 2024, I was invited to attend a lunchtime seminar with Veda C. Storey, the Tull Professor of Computer Information Systems at Georgia State University. In a fascinating talk, Storey presented a brief, mostly chronological overview of her efforts to connect research across two areas: 1) information systems and 2) design science research. In just over an hour, Storey deftly described the arc of her research, providing attendees with key milestones and scholarly perspectives. Towards the end of her talk, Storey mentioned a recent paper17 co-authored with Alan R. Hevner and Victoria Y. Yoon. The paper immediately caught my c-minded attention. The abstract of the paper suggested that “The field of decision sciences is undergoing significant disruption and reinvention because of rapid advances in artificial intelligence (AI) technologies and the design of complex human-artificial intelligence systems (HAIS).”18 In her talk, Storey noted a section19 of the paper that outlines Design Science Research challenges for Human-AI systems design, which was subsequently followed by a set of key design challenges identified by the authors.20 To my delight, the challenges were presented as a taxonomy of eight c-words: composition, complexity, creativity, confidence, controls, conscience, certification, and contribution. When Storey shared this c-word list, I nearly fell out of my chair. Many of the c-words in the authors’ taxonomy also appeared in my own creative course c-word short list. This I immediately found fascinating. ¶ Alas, before we jump into the actual c-words, I will lastly note that, throughout these notes, I admittedly forgo any in-depth critical analysis or commentary around emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence (AI). Instead, I intentionally focus on the matter at hand—human intelligence (HI). Furthermore, as we ponder these c-words and creativity itself, I encourage students to explore and discern the endlessly fascinating, big-tent notions of creativity presented, while attempting to mix and match them, along with others, using principles of “combinatory play.“21 Together, we will expand, celebrate, interrogate, and challenge various notions of creativity. Like a journey across an endlessly vast creative terrain,22 I thus present An Incomplete List of C-words for the Creative Course.


C-Words


  1. Care: One could easily argue that individuals who identify as creative generally want the things they make, contribute to, or engage with to be well considered or well made. If this assumption is at least partially true, we might furthermore assume that, generally, when it comes to such matters, creatives care. ¶ In creative work, maintaining a high level of care is not always easy, nor is it always straightforward. Just as in life, one’s career, or any particular practice, there are always competing forces, limitations, concerns, ideas, and demands—many of which are out of our control. These concerns may include, but are not limited to, time, budgets, health, energy, resources, non-alignment, and more. ¶ In this list-maker’s field of design, one might expect to find a rich body of literature concerning care, but as Rob Imrie and Kim Kullman suggest in their 2016 Chapter, “Designing with Care and Caring with Design,” it [care] remains fairly “understated and unexplored in design discourse and practice.”23 Imrie and Kullman’s Chapter provides readers with a care-oriented overview that explores how practices of caring and designing have converged and diverged over time. Imrie and Kullman’s Chapter was published in Care and Design: Bodies, Buildings, Cities, which primarily focuses on urban environments. As is typical in academic scholarship, this edited volume seems to have been derived from a narrowly focused academic gathering: in this case, the Royal Geographical Society conference in 2014.24 Despite this narrow disciplinary lens, the editors sought to “redress the relative lack of writings about design and care, and to explore how care and design may be conjoined in ways that enable places to function better.”25 The good news, as is even evidenced by the aforementioned volume itself (and also noted by its editors), is that there seems to be a relatively recent upsurge of interest in care. ¶ Just as the authors of Care and Design offer many methodological and pedagogical ideas, critiques, and perspectives, this list-maker likewise puts forth care as a big-tent c-word for creatives in this course. At the intersection of creativity and care, we posit the interdependence among action, artifacts, empathy, quality, craft, understanding, translation, and more. Thus, building upon the earlier supposition that care is not easy, we will explore its meaning and implications in creative work and beyond. ¶ As we ponder care, it should be noted that over time, high-performing creatives across disciplines learn to navigate and manage care-related concerns, and in fact, care seems to be a key tenet of nearly any productive practice. These high-performing creatives also understand both the independent and collaborative nature of creative work. But as we will see and explore within our c-words, even though creatives generally care, they oftentimes care about different things. This predictable tension is not necessarily a bad thing, so long as it is properly facilitated by stewards adept at the creative process. ¶ Creative stewardship differs slightly from other forms of leadership and management. Creative stewards are hybrid-brained leaders who attempt to center people, perspectives, and resources around a shared creative vision. They thereby exhibit a sensibility and sensitivity well suited to cultivating ideas, fostering consensus, and elevating performance. Creative stewards tend to be care-oriented. ¶ Care-oriented creative stewards are alignment-minded in that they welcome critiques, questioning, and varied perspectives that balance pragmatism and aspiration. As a broad humanistic trait, care and acts of care may also foster motivation. This list maker has noted that care-oriented creative leaders and participants often operate more like volunteers,26 even when they are paid. In fact, one great way to practice creative leadership is to volunteer for or work for a non-profit organization. ¶ Based on these learnings, notions of creativity and care may serve as a catalyst for sustained engagement in a variety of things: projects, tasks, problem-solving, curiosity, learning, and more. ¶ Like creativity, care is indeed a “big tent” humanistic term. Writers care for their readers, nurses care for patients, and artists care for the art. Care is connected to our sense of empathy and understanding, our notions of time, observation, and more. Care appears on this list because it naturally maps to a wide range of creative identities, industries, interests, and careers. Those who work in healthcare, education,27|28 childcare, elder care, culinary arts, engineering, design,29 actively and tacitly engage with care as a sensibility, mode, and aptitude. ¶ In education, there seems to be a symbiotic relationship between education and notions of care. Some scholarship even lists caring (alongside six other c-words) as desirable outcomes for positive youth development.30|31 ¶ As creatives, there very well may be times that you feel like the only care-oriented voice at the table—the only one willing to advocate for something you care about. Being the lone voice for creativity or care can be especially difficult when your care-oriented concerns are not easily quantified or when additional expenses are attached. For artists and designers, this presents a timeless dilemma—how does one advocate for the things one cares about? This is in part why, as a creative, you need to be clear, cogent, articulate, and compelling. Depending on your goals, doing the work is not enough. Several strategies are explored in the c-words that follow—so keep your footnotes. ¶ At the very least, as we begin our c-word journey, I hope you begin to formulate and reflect upon the many connections between creativity and care. Caring, care, and being careful lead quite naturally to our second “big tent” c-word—one that, in many ways, embodies notions of care. When something is made with intention, attention, or extra care—or when something is carefully performed, well-composed, or elegantly solved, an observer very well might observe or remark that such an effort is “well-crafted.”

  2. Craft: Unfortunately, in the mainstream, we all too often associate the term “craft” with hobbies and hobbyists. Despite this narrow use of the term, craft has been and remains a critically important concern for those who undertake a wide variety of creative work. It is no surprise, then, that ancient Greek philosophers viewed “craft” as a central philosophical pillar—one that served as a springboard for vigorous discourse into many facets of society and life. As Plato, Aristotle, and others sought to describe and explore craft, these ancient Greek philosophers used the word techne (or “tekhne,” [τέχνη] in Greek)—which today might translate to mean, among other things, “applied knowledge.”32 Fascinatingly, techne is the root of the modern English word “technology”—but its original meaning was much broader. While the long history of craft and its varied uses cannot be adequately summarized here, craft seems to have evolved from a way to describe goal-directed knowledge to the present day, where craft is used to describe or identify properties such as care, patience, intent, quality, and more. ¶ As is noted at the outset of this section, in the 21st century, in the mainstream, many narrowly associate craft with hobbies or “side projects”—things made with glue sticks, colored paper, and popsicle sticks—handicrafts, if you will. Along these lines, a Google image search for “craft” will yield countless images of yarn and items made of paper-mache. I am not against these forms of craft—but by including them on this list, I suggest we explore their broader meanings and potential. ¶ For those in this creative course, like the ancient philosophers before us, I urge you to explore craft as a mindset. Adding craft as a “mindset” will help shape and inform your creative and designerly practices. With all this said, and as I note in my Illustrative Introduction to a Curious Compendium of Incomplete Lists for Productive Practice, in her 2024 Tanner lectures, Rachel Barney quite appropriately describes craft as “a very big tent.”33|34 Thus, if you have not done so already, like many before you, I encourage you to embark on a journey to explore craft. ¶ As an extension of the c-word section on care, the term “craft” might be well served wby pondering that which is well-crafted. Things that are “well-crafted” often exhibit discernible evidence of attention, detail, patience, or care. Curiously, evidence of care may be “felt,” sensed, or understood, and, like one’s sense of care, perceptions of craft may vary based on one’s own taste, culture, beliefs, and aesthetics. But generally, humans can sense when extra time, empathy, effort, or consideration goes into the formulation, production, and making of a thing. ¶ But how can craft be “sensed”? Let’s use a small, seemingly inconsequential artifact as an example, such as a button or snap on a jacket. When we use a button, we, as its [the button] users, are the recipients of the designer’s consideration (or lack thereof) of its form and function. This helps shape how the button feels when we use it, and by considering how it “feels,” we in part begin to discern and evaluate its craft. How easily does the button snap? How easily does it unsnap? What does the physical snap look like and sound like when snapped and unsnapped, etc? Who then cannot claim to appreciate a perfectly proportioned button that snaps magically into place? And so, in a snap, craft can sense. If we extend this button example, we can observe and consider craft in many things. We can sense craft just as much in a musician’s ability to conclude a performance with a final note that feels “just right.” The craft in this latter example is likely the product of the musician’s many hours of practice, which then develops into muscle memory—a kind of intuition that informs split-second decisions about timing, volume, and pitch. This practice-to-craft-to-muscle-memory cycle applies equally to the detailed work of a surgeon and to the plumber who seals a pipe with perfect precision. ¶ Sometimes we sense something is well-crafted when we hear it, or experience it, when we touch it, or use it. Akin to what is described above, in a section of Richard Sennett’s 2008 book The Craftsman, the author stresses, “the positive, open role routine and practicing play in the work of crafting physical things.”35 But Sennett also moves beyond physical object as he explores practice and craft, noting that “so too do people need to practice their relations with one another….”36 Interestingly and in this writer’s view understandably, Sennett intentionally avoids the word “creativity”—suggesting that “the word carries too much Romantic baggage—the mystery of inspiration, the claims of genius.”37 Setting such creativity-oriented concerns aside, Sennett’s book reinforces craft as a crucial “big-tent” connection between making and thinking. ¶ Lastly, we might ask ourselves, “If craft and care can be ‘sensed,’ can a lack of craft be equally sensed?” Here, the answer may be nuanced. An expert professional baker will have very different expectations of bread from the average consumer. Despite this varied sense of craft in any given discipline, and even when the maker or provenance of a thing is unknown, tangible traces of the invisible creative hand are “baked into” a final product, artifact, or thing. Craft is thus a distinctive, subjective, and humanistic property that is evident in some of our oldest human-made artifacts.38 Artifacts and craft thus reflect, substantiate, and “embody” our longstanding innate penchant for tangible evidence of human care. ¶ There are some tensions that arise as one engages with notions of craft. These issues center around time, cost, material, and energy use, and another might even concern pride. For instance, in one’s seemingly noble pursuit of excellent craft, how does one develop pride in one’s work without conflating such a practice with pride in oneself? How does one then appreciate the work of others without sliding down the slippery slopes of appropriation or envy?39 Beyond this, one might posit how to craft cogent artifacts or maintain clarity of vision while also considering others’ perspectives. ¶ In popular culture and occasionally in marketing, the latter question is oftentimes [overly] positively celebrated when a product, brand, or creator is viewed as “uncompromising.” Thus, as students explore notions of craft, they will no doubt encounter these issues, trade-offs, and more. ¶ So welcome to the very big tent we call craft. As Ezra Shales states in the introduction to his 2017 book The Shape of Craft, “The most I can hope is that I whet your desire to touch craft and cultivate increased respect for the myriad anonymous craftspeople at work in the world.”40 As students posit craft, the term quite fluidly leads to adjacent concerns involving the careful ordering, synthesis, assembly, or arrangement of things. This general concern for ordering and arranging things leads us to our next two c-words: composition and curation. Let’s start with the former.

  3. Composition: Composition describes the formal arrangement or ordering of media, materials, spaces, content, objects, ideas, and more. Big-tent principles of composition span many disciplines, not limited to music, math, writing, film, art, computer science, design, and more. Thus, composition can apply to paintings, poems, architecture, sonatas, and sculptures alike. Of course, composition generally describes the act of composing [and sometimes recomposing] multivariate material(s). ¶ How something is shaped, ordered, arranged, or composed determines its structure, form, and sometimes, as a product of a particular structure and form, its significance, value, or meaning. In elementary school, I remember being handed a small black notebook with the word “Composition” on the cover. Within such composition books, students are generally instructed to explore the process, craft, and technique of writing. Over the past 50 years, the study of composition has been generally referred to as composition studies. Even in this relatively short time period, our thoughts around composition—how it is taught and what it encompasses have evolved significantly. For instance, in 1973, Peter Elbow published Writing Without Teachers, in which he suggested that we write not only to compose or record our thoughts, but also to cultivate our thinking. For some, this idea may seem obvious, but for others, this notion of writing, and likewise composing to cultivate, might serve as a fresh frame. In his book, Elbow states that, “Putting a thought into symbols means setting it down and letting the mind take a rest from it.”41 This, as we will see in the d-word section on “Drawing,” is quite similar to how folks in the visual arts approach sketching—which likewise allows us to rapidly bring ideas into the world. Elbow later states, “A principle value of language […] is that it permits you to distance yourself from your own perceptions, feelings and thoughts.”42 If we thus extend this logic just a bit further, we thereby posit human composition as a reflective “thinking” process. Furthermore, this reflective line of reasoning lends itself to many other forms of making and doing. ¶ As we further consider composition, in the 21st century, even what we might consider less “tangible” material arrangements could fall into compositional categories. Data, visuals, or code are also considered languages or materials and, thus, when arranged, they form compositions. As is fairly typical in creative classes such as this, students create compositions in part so that we can analyze, discuss, describe, evaluate, and better understand their formal qualities. ¶ When creatives talk of the formal, we’re not describing a middle-school dance. In conversations around composition, the formal refers to a resultant quality. The formal is thus a way to discuss and discern certain elements and principles that inform composition, or, said more plainly, the arrangement of things. ¶ In his 2003 book, Arranging Things: A Rhetoric of Object Placement, Leonard Koren suggests that arranging things “has two aspects: (1) the selection of the objects—things—and (2) the manner in which the objects are arranged.”43 Interestingly, Koren adds a footnote after “arranged,” noting that his book is primarily concerned with arranging and that “object selection should be the subject of another book.”44 Likewise, this short memo on composition is followed by a section on curation, which briefly explores notions of culling and selection. ¶ “Forms,” when viewed as a big tent term, can be understood as a way to ponder organizing principles that shape texts, objects, or even ideas. For instance, in her 2015 book Forms, Caroline Levine notes that, “Over many centuries, form has gestured to a series of conflicting, sometimes even paradoxical meanings,”45 but the author later shares that, “‘form’ always indicates an arrangement of elements—an ordering, patterning, or shaping.”46 Fascinatingly, although Levine hails from the world of literature, she uses affordances,47 a term from the fields of psychology and design, to think about form. ¶ As we will see, c-word forces, including curation, composition, content, and concept, are in various ways highly intertwined and interdependent. Together, such concerns generally contribute to the substance of a work. Composed material can be physical, digital, or even ephemeral—and, as noted earlier, these days material can include images, shapes, language, sounds, text, code, matter, data, ideas, and more. ¶ Depending on the medium, material can be manipulated and arranged with various elements and principles in mind. These elements and principles might include, but are not limited to, contrast, hierarchy, scale, duration, texture, volume, pattern, and more. ¶ In the interest of brevity, I might suggest that we ponder 10 decent “starter” structures as we explore creative composition. They are: 1) sequential (or “linear”) composition, 2) non-sequential (or non-linear) composition, 3) framed composition, 4) dynamic composition, 5) looped composition, 6) systematic composition, 7) material composition, 8) recontextualized composition, 9) derivative composition, and 10) spontaneous composition. Sequential composition, for instance, encompasses most time-based works. Most films, music, and writing produced today are linear—meaning that they have a generally definitive start, middle, and end. Framed composition can be used to describe works that are contained or constrained within a frame, plane,48 or space. This framing may also be conceptual, which means that the “ideas” can be composed or constrained within a “conceptual frame” or defined within an “idea space.” Along those lines, framing is a great way to constrain both form and ideas. Non-sequential and dynamic composition encapsulates work that may be unframed; such works may be interactive, instructional, generative,49 spontaneous, random, participatory, and more. This latter category can even encompass dynamic works that change and adapt over time. These dynamic works might also be defined or informed by live or systematic data inputs. Looped composition, by contrast, is defined by continuous or semi-continuous repetition or repeating structures. Systematic50 composition is defined or driven by a structure, system, matrix, or grid. Material composition refers to the specific “ingredients” that make up a substance and the proportions in which they are combined. Recontextualized composition is a broad category that includes reuse, remixing, and recontextualization. With well-known artistic figures such as Marcel Duchamp51 (1887–1968) in mind, this last category might include found or discovered objects as new or reconstituted compositions. This latter form of composition is in some ways connected to derivative52 composition, an example of which might be a sequel to a film. The last form of composition listed here is spontaneos composition—which can be observed in forms of improvisation, dialogue and even conversation. ¶ This list maker is most certainly not the first to posit composition as a multimodal and multidiscipary space. For instance, in 2026 Sarah Huber published Creating Formats Across Media and Disciplines: Assignments Beyond the Essay. This volume contains contributions by over a dozen educators who provide tools, lesson plans, resources, and narratives—each with clearly defined learning outcomes. The goal of the book seems to be centered around developing fluencies at the endlessly interestung intersection of media and meaning. Unsurprisingly, a whole section (Part 2: Lesson Plans: Compositional Principles)53 seems to grapple with many of the aforementioned compositional structures. The first two lessons (authored by Huber) within this composition-oriented section largely deal with framed composition. Then, the third lesson, provided by Alyssa Nez, deals with nonlinear storytelling.54 Nez points out that, “Everyone knows a linear story structure. It has a beginning, middle, and end. But not all stories fit this structure.”55 Then Nez shares that, “Since time immemorial, Indigenous Peoples have told stories in nonlinear structure.”56 Nez then provides scholarly and cultural examples that highlight cyclical and relational structures and how they differ from more typical linear57 models. The last lesson within this section is penned by Sara Veglahn. Veglahn’s contribution titled “Making Poems: Exploring Ekphrasis and Text/Image Poetics”58 seems to live at the intersection of composition, language, and meaning. To do so, Veglahn provides two prompts: one that provides students an opportunity to create meaning with found texts, and a second that explores the composition of descriptive texts. In this way, these two prompts are less about poetry, and more about understanding the varied compositional attributes of text. Ekphrasis, for those new to this term, has been used since classical antiquity as a highly descriptive or detailed storytelling technique.59 ¶ Of course, some projects necessarily fall into multiple compositional categories. No matter which type of composition you are dealing with, creating a composition usually requires making choices and selections. Creative choices can be informed by evidence, feedback, experience, taste, input, intuition, and more. ¶ Luckily, in creative fields, we use another c-word to describe this process of narrowing down choices, or even a series of choices or compositions. This process of selection and ordering, which is often closely linked to notions of composition, is frequently called curation.

  4. Curation: Whether we are aware of it or not, most of us curate. In fact, many of us perform acts of curation on a daily basis. Selecting tracks for a musical playlist, for example, is an act of curation. Choosing your clothing and wardrobe is also a form of curation. Assembling a food menu is a form of curation, as is selecting artists or works for an exhibition. For the latter selection process, museums, galleries, and other cultural institutions often employ full-time curators. ¶ To briefly ponder curation, one contemporary curator may be worth mentioning here. Since 2016, Hans Ulrich Obrist has been co-director of the Serpentine Galleries in London. Beyond a curator’s core role in selecting and arranging works for galleries and museums, in his 2014 book Ways of Curating, Obrist suggests or implies that curating also involves making connections. This distinctly human ability to envision and make complex humanistic connections is in part why curation has been elevated as a c-word topic of concern and exploration in this course. By framing curation as a connection-oriented process, Obrist helps us ponder the curator’s ability to “make junctions, to allow different elements to touch.”60 A bit more abstractly, Obrist describes curation as a kind of “map making that opens new routes through a city, a people or a world.”61 Much like a map, which oftentimes orients, this big-tent view of curation suggests that matters of arrangement also connect to matters of wayfinding and even understanding. ¶ Curation as a discipline and practice involves a rich mix of organizational, aesthetic, and historical knowledge. Curators such as Obrist are valued for their unique perspectives, which in turn are informed by a general sense of discernment or discretion. ¶ Lastly, in Ways of Curating, Obrist notably describes an influential 1986 meeting with the Italian conceptual artist Alighero Boetti. In that meeting, Boetti suggested to Obrist that “curating could be about making impossible things possible.”62 This imagination-infused, future-oriented notion of curation required Obrist to continue doing something he already seemed inclined to do early on in his career—talk to artists. In his book, Obrist chronicles these studio visits and conversations with artists. The reader thus comes to understand and appreciate how such conversations help shape and define Obrist’s curatorial process and, in turn, his understanding and interpretation of the artists’ works. Obrist thus shares a quality, or “trait,” that is common across many creative disciplines: an attempt toget to the source. This creative “trait”—one that seeks out sources, information, footnotes, material, and materials sometimes drives the creative’s innate motivation to learn. This innate motivation is explored in our very next c-word section: curiosity.

  5. Curiosity: At the beginning of each semester, one of my colleagues asks his business school students to raise their hands if they see themselves as creative. Unfortunately, he reports that many, if not most, students do not raise their hands. Thus, as we dive into notions of curiosity, now may be the perfect time to challenge one of the most significant misconceptions about creativity: that only certain people are creative. ¶ Out of curiosity, I also started conducting this informal poll around creativity in my courses as well. I then ask those who have not raised their hands whether they would be comfortable sharing why they view themselves as “not very creative.” Some state that they cannot draw or paint, or play a musical instrument. Some simply say, “I’m just not very artistic.” ¶ The reality is that all humans, to various degrees, are creative. Creativity is, in fact, one of the core attributes that make a human being human. Thus, when one says “I am not very creative,” I tend to think it is akin to saying “I am not very human.” So please stop all that non-creative nonsense—and stop it now! ¶ One goal for students in this course might be to explore various ways to harness and develop their creativity. Generally, if one wants to become more creative, a good place to start, or better yet, a good word to ponder, is curiosity. The reason for this focus on curiosity lies in its power to spark, drive, and sustain creativity. In fact, in this list-maker’s opinion, curiosity is like raw fuel for creativity. But beyond such hyperbolic statements, how do we know any of this is true? ¶ As children, we are naturally curious. In fact, curiosity shapes how children develop, explore, and understand the world as they learn and develop skills such as language. As a big-tent c-word, curiosity has been a longstanding area of scholarly interest in psychology, business, the arts, and beyond. ¶ While research around curiosity initially focused on links between curiosity and motivation,63 renewed 21st-century interest and research have begun to explore more expansive possibilities. In their 2016 paper “Deconstructing intellectual curiosity,” Christopher Powell et al. describe this renewed interest as the ‘third wave’ of curiosity research.64 Fascinatingly, Powell et al. note that curiosity can include one’s desire or interest in sensory experience [perceptual curiosity], knowledge [epistemic curiosity], intellectual engagement, and more.65 Within this “third wave” of research, concurrent links between creativity and curiosity are being further explored by scholars such as Lydia Paine Hagtvedt, whose [multiple authors] 2019 paper is wonderfully titled “Curiosity made the cat more creative: Specific curiosity as a driver of creativity.”66 ¶ Notably, at the outset of their paper, Hagtvedt et al. present two flavors of curiosity: “diversive curiosity [emphasis added], which reflects broad interest in exploring and learning, and specific curiosity [emphasis added], which entails a desire to solve a particular puzzle.”67 ¶ The kind of research undertaken by Hagtvedt et al. is timely, not the least because designers and creatives of all types are increasingly being challenged to engage in problem-solving on a vast range of scales and within a variety of domains. At the complex end of the problem-solving spectrum, we encounter problems often described as “wicked.”68 Wicked problems are ripe for creative solutions from curious, creative, and entrepreneurial minds who (as we discussed in the section on curation) can make new and vital connections. ¶ This list maker suggests that one of the most compelling aspects of Hagtvedt et al.’s paper is thus the authors’ notion of idea linking—a novel mechanism described as “that specific curiosity drives the within-individual cognitive exploration that supports creative idea generation.”69 Unlike 20th-century creativity-oriented terms such as “brainstorming”—the notion of idea linking seems to offer creatives a more cogent and scholarly process. Furthermore, Hagtvedt et al. argue that specific curiosity supports our ability to explore multiple or partially overlapping ideas— characterized by an individual’s ability to “develop ideas by linking them together in a sequential manner, using aspects of initial ideas as input into subsequent ideas.”70 ¶ With notions of curation, curiosity, and idea linking in mind, we might now ask what separates the highest-performing creatives from us mere mortals? While there are certainly many answers to this question, one crucial, if not obvious, answer is consistency.

  6. Consistency: Despite the hurly-burly of contemporary life, what does it mean to deliberately dedicate oneself to a particular practice? Beyond this, we might ask how one might reflect on that practice and the associated actions embedded within or associated with it. By undertaking this reflective posture, one may begin to see (or not see) difference, discernment, distinction, or improvement.71 ¶ While the word “commitment”72 was also a contender for c-word six, and while these two words are somewhat entangled, it was with special intention that I opted for consistency. My initial interest in consistency was first sparked by imagining the contents of an unwritten memo. In 1985, Italo Calvino, an Italian novelist, was invited to present a series of lectures at Harvard. Unfortunately, Calvino passed away just before his lectures were scheduled to be presented. In preparation for his lectures, Calvino composed a series of essays titled Six Memos for the Next Millennium.73 Within his memos, Calvino sought to explore six literary virtues. The six virtues were: lightness, quickness, exactitude, visibility, multiplicity, and consistency. While Calvino drafted and edited the first five memos, the sixth, on consistency, was never written—leaving us to ponder or imagine the memo’s contents and significance. ¶ One might suggest with some degree of confidence that Calvino himself was in many ways consistent. As a prolific, committed, and consistent writer, Calvino published novels, stories, letters, essays, and literary criticism. ¶ If one imagined Calvino delving into notions of consistency, one might imagine him exploring the vast linguistic, poetic, aesthetic,74 and conceptual spaces in, around, and between the term. One might likewise picture a literary or dialogic75 discourse at the intersection of consistency and discursivity,76 or, possibly even an attempt to reconcile the two—a focused discursivism, if you will. But then again, who really knows? ¶ For students in this creative course, some key consistency-oriented points to ponder might be centered around time, focus, systems, progression, and habits.77 ¶ Calvino himself exemplified a consistent spirit that likely informed his own sense of identity as a writer. In fact, in a letter that Calvino wrote to Luigi Santucci in 1959, Calvino shared the following: “We are people, there is no doubt, who exist solely insofar as we write, otherwise we don’t exist at all. Even if we did not have a single reader any more, we would have to write….”78 ¶ With this passage in mind, it might be fair to assume that Calvino wrote every day he possibly could. But we all know that being consistent is sometimes easier said than done. In any practice, this often means carving out precious time, enjoying good health, and having the space or funding needed to adequately support our work. Our consistency, well-being, and commitments are thus intertwined. Enacting consistency and its close cousin, focus, can have a compounding effect. Together, these properties can foster creative flow79—which, in turn, canincrease productivity, efficiency, and perhaps even levels of creativity itself. Flow is, in some ways, the antithesis of distraction, or worse still, what creatives often call “analysis paralysis.” ¶ Some creative and skilled work requires us to make split-second, intuitive, or muscle-memory-like decisions, while other types require hours of focus, evaluation, and deliberation. These multivariate creative decisions—how we might make them, evaluate them, and pursue them—might lead us into fields of inquiry that extend to and beyond epistemology, cognitive science, and more. But in a creative and designerly context, if we pull on this thread of decision-oriented and evaluative properties, we encounter a vast range of opportunities for making and knowing ripe for exploration. I can tell by your countenance that you are intrigued.

  7. Countenance: In a 2007 issue of Design Studies, Andy Dong asked, “what is the role of language in the performance of design?”80 Dong then notes that, in the design process, language has traditionally been viewed as secondary to visual representation. This of course produces a stange double-tension for creative and designerly practitioners. On one hand, the artist might rightly say that language, and thus knowledge, is embedded in the artifact itself. The scientist might scoff at such claims and might rightly say that knowledge should be encoded, not in form but in language that can be cataloged, reviewed and debated. At the intersection of these arguments, we encounter an even more complex question, especially for designers and design researchers whose work lives at this nexus: how are design options evaluated, by whom, or, put another way, how do designers decide? Complicating this already complex question is the emergence, and we can only assume continued rise of AI-oriented design tools. One aspect of this complication is that, as Jaijie Zhang stated in 2026, “As AI lowers the barrier to generating sophisticated outputs, it also lowers the barrier to appearing competent.”81 Said, another way through a design-oriented lens, a solution may “look” perfect at a glance, but may not have been substatially interrogated or evaluated. Zhang makes a similar argument when he states, “When outputs look correct, but are not deeply grounded, evaluation becomes more difficult.”82 Thus designers need to sharpen both our mindsets and vocabularies as we face a potential tidal wave of outputs that, without proper framing, may risk (as Zhang states), confidence outpacing competence.83 ¶ Elsewhere,84 this list maker has elevated design as a dynamic and integrative challenge space for interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary work. In their 2014 paper, “Integrating knowledge: Challenges raised by the ‘‘Inventory of Synthesis’’ Rico Defila and Antonietta Di Giulio examine how to systematically combine different pieces of knowledge, data, and theories from various disciplines or societal sectors without losing analytical rigor. Very much akin to how design if often posited as a discipline and [or space] to solve complex real-world problems, Defila and Di Giulio’s paper begins to chip away at some of the thorny “how” questions that arise. To approach this question and begin to resolve the “how” questions, Defila and Di Giulio introduce an analytical tool called the “Inventory of Synthesis,” which they describe as “an instrument developed to facilitate the epistemic analysis and description of the integrated results of inter- or trans-disciplinary research and to identify where methods of integration are needed.”85 Interestingly, in the paper the authors also note that they “endorse a double perspective, one from the point of view of inquiring into processes of integration and one from the point of view of designing and implementing them.”86 Despite these efforts to examine these integrative methods and their implementation, in this list maker’s view, a lexical gap exists around how one might desrcibe the process of evaluating and selecting such products. This question is especially relevant for projects developed in an integrative design space, which oftentimes merge, group, systhesize or combine ideas and viewpoints from plural epistemologies along with expert knowledge, user feedback, stakeholder feedback, and more. Defila and Di Giulio also note research87 by Max Krott that discerns the varied products and intent of such integrative collaborations. These include grouping, delegation, negotiation, and systematizing. ¶ On “Taste” ¶ It is not uncommon to hear arguments that link the technological replacement of design-oriented skills, with a greater concern for “taste.” Along these lines, this list maker recalls taking an undergraduate design course with William “Bill” J. Hannon Jr.88 in the late 1990s. As this list maker recalls Hannon had one hard and fast rule for students in his course: under Hannon’s watchful eye, no student, presenter, reviewer, or instructor was permitted to use the word “like” when presesnting or evaluating design work. In a somewhat abrupt way, if this rule was violated, Hannon would interrupt mid-presentation and ask the presenter or reviewer to stop, start over, or come back later. Hannon’s rule was not instituted to stifle expression, taste or opinion—but rather to assert or demand better evaluative language. To this day, this list maker occasionally leverages Hannon’s rule by suggesting that his students replace “like” with more substantive language. ¶ With this long concern in mind, we might return to the question that orients this section: how might we put for forth language and mindsets that might describe the evaluative methods used to decide upon design? As we parse this question further, another question from Dong proves salient to the theoretical exploration that follows here: “What are the linguistic resources [emphasis added] that produce design practice and the designed work?”89 Following this line of questions, in a section titled “Appraisal”—Wong broadly asserts that “any clause which functions to express meaning related to affect, judgment or appreciation is considered an appraisal.”90 It is with these interconnected issues of affect, judgment, appreciation, and appraisal in mind—and also Dong’s aforementioned emphasis on the role of language—that this list maker puts forth the ideas explored below. In an attempt to address this issue, this list maker proposes a repurposing of somewhat abandoned language from the field of educational evaluation. As such, this list-maker will attempt to link make linkages between designerly ways of thinking, knowing, and doing to “countenance evaluation.” Doing so attempts to map the ever complex task of evaluating education to the equally complex task of evaluating design. Such borrowed language might provide designers and co-designers with a lexical reference point for how desigers evaluate, synthesize, and decide (Fig. 9). ¶ Beyond the Bricolage ¶ In the The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research (6th ed.) readers will enounter a section titled, “The Qualitative Researcher-as-Bricoleur.”91 In this section, the editors note that, “The many methodological practices of qualitative research may be viewed as soft science, journalism, ethnography, ethnotheatre, ethnodrama, bricolage, quilt making, or montage.”92 Later, the editors state, “The interpretive bricoleur produces a bricolage—that is, a pieced-together set of representations that are fitted to the specifics of a complex situation.”93 Indeed, the term bricolage94 often suggests a gathering of material in the process of making or creating. In the practice-based experience of this designer-list-maker, bricolage begins to capture the varirty of inputs that commonly shape contemporary works in architecture and design. It is now common practice for architects and designers to interview or directly engage users, stakeholders, community members, owners, and more, as one part of a bricolage-like gathering of qualitative data, discourse, and perspectives. But, this capatures only part of the “gathering” that commonly informs architecture and design. As part of this input, intake, or exploratory phase in design, architects and designers simultaneously and somewhat dynamically gather and synthesize a range of qualitative, data-driven, and evidence-based research. Beyond this, architects, designers and co-designers constinuously weigh those concerns against innumerable factors, including context, access, ethics, aesthetics, funding, and more.95 It would seem that many contemporary architects, designers, makers and creatives are now operating in a space that is “beyond the bricolage.” With Dong’s aforementioned questioning of “the role of language in the performance of design”96 in mind, this list maker asserts that designers have not adequately articulated and developed mature language to substantiate our decision-making frames. While designers and design’s ways of knowing may be described as designerly,97 how then do we evaluate and substantiate the product(s) of such designerly thinking? Here we encounter one example of what this list-maker has termed the lax lexical legacy in design—in this case, a lack of language to substantiate and describe our beyond-the-bricolage, ever inclusive and integrative decision-making practices. Put another way, design has not, in this list maker’s view, developed compelling, cogent, domain-defining language to describe how we make, guide, and facilitate design decisions—and moreover the multivariate evaluative frames we employ. At a glance, there seems to be a focus on the parts (e.g., evidence-based design) rather than the whole. As a consequence, and not surprisingly, many outside of design still see our methods as fluffy. We need to and can do better if design is to stand on it’s own two feet. This is in part why, in my d-word section on dynamism,98 contenance is put forth as one of the “four legs” that might support design as a dynamic and integrative domain of knowledge. ¶ If you have already stumbled across the word countenance, it was likely used to describe a communicative facial expression—typically one that suggests approval, disapproval, mood, or some other non-verbal cue or reaction. To this list maker’s knowledge, rarely do designers, architects, and other creatives used this term as a process-oriented linguistic device in the service of making a thing or things, or, more crucially, to describe the process of evaluating a thing or things. The section that follows briefly explores this possibility. To do so, this list maker will borrow scholarly terms and perspectives from educational evaluation. As this list maker argues in this section, the leap between educational evaluation and designerly evaluation is one that is well worth examining. This proposition lies in the fact that education and design are both complex and at times difficult to measure. ¶ Countenance is a wonderfully big, big-tent word with somewhat fluid meaning. Since countenance describes expressions of approval, disapproval, or evaluative reactions in general, the term can describe a multivariate approach to evaluation itself. Thus, for this c-word list, I use countenance to describe evaluation more broadly as a design-oriented evaluative skillset or mindset. In this way, we might begin to posit countenance as a specific type of mixed-mixed-methods evaluative method specific to design. Doing so requires some brave leaps across disciplinary and epistemological boundaries. ¶ Before proceeding further, first, let’s imagine a live jazz ensemble performance before us. Now let’s consider big-tent notions of “countenance” in real time. One might observe the countenance of the jazz musicians as directed toward each other, but also, oddly enough, their reactions to or toward the work itself. When posited as such, notions of countenance shape both the work and the evaluation of the work in a somewhat circular or recursive fashion. ¶ This list maker is not the first to posit the peculiar possibility of employing the word countenance as an evaluative descriptor or method. Years ago, the educational researcher and evaluator Robert Stake made that linguistic leap. To briefly orient ourselves around this linguistic trajectory of countenance within education evaluation I will first point readers to a 2024 video essay by Michael Quinn Patton. Patton is the former President of the American Evaluation Association (AEA). In his 2024 video essay, Patton provides a critical reflection of Robert Robert Stake’s 2023 memoir, Measuring Education. In this video essay lecture—which Patton cleverly titled The Countenance of Bob Stake, Patton puts forward an appeal for viewers to reconsider one of Stake’s key scholarly contributions—what Stake once termed countenance evaluation. ¶ Over the course of the essay, Patton provides a critical review of Stake’s key scholarly contributions. In particular, he revisits Stake’s forumulation of “countenance evaluation,” which, in his essay Patton describes as an “evaluative soup.”99 Stake is Professor Emeritus of Education at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, and earned a PhD in Psychometrics from Princeton University in 1958.100 He is the author of Qualitative Research: Studying How Things Work (2010), The Art of Case Study Research (2010), and many influential publications concerning educational evaluation. ¶ Curiously, according to the Encyclopedia of Evaluation, Stake did not purposefully set out to create a countenance evaluation model, and “to this day, he would assert that it is not a model.”101 But perhaps to Stake’s dismay, the author of the aforementioned entry also contends that “a brief review of the evaluation literature since its publication illustrates its characterization as such.”102 ¶ The core premise of countenance evaluation as explored by Stake posited that a more holistic or complete (or “countenance”) evaluation of education might go beyond simply looking at test scores or final outcomes. Stake seemed intent on exploring the entire lifecycle of education—accounting for antecedents, transactions, and outcomes. In this way, an evaluator might garner a more accurate picture of intention versus outcome versus external benchmarks and references. Stake first introduced his “Countenance Model” of evaluation in his seminal 1967 paper,103 “The Countenance of Educational Evaluation” (published in the Teachers College Record). With Patton’s notion of countenance as an “evaluatory soup” in mind, Stake’s countenance-oriented ideas are resurfaced here, as they may fill an essential gap in the lexicon of design scholarship. In his Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains, and in the sections on Delta (knowledge) and Dynamism in particular, this list maker traces the still-unfolding maturation of design as a distinct domain of knowledge. In these sections, readers are introduced to some of the discourses shaping design’s disciplinary methods and bounds. Without repeating that discourse here, readers might briefly posit how a field, sometimes described as in-disciplinary, alterdiscplinary, or even antidisciplinary and more, might synthesize such a wide array of knowledge as inputs and outputs. ¶ In his paper, Stake stated that, with countenance evaluation, he aimed to “introduce a conceptualization of evaluation oriented to the complex and dynamic [emphasis added] nature of education.”104 Likewise, we might posit that we might introduce a cogent conceptualization of evaluation oriented to the complex and dynamic nature of design. ¶ Let us briefly use architecture and the architectural design process as an example. Scholars of design have described the complex and combinatory-evaluative process of architecture and design as “holistic.”105 Likewise, we might map such holistic ideas to those examined in education. ¶ To sharpen the aforementioned education-design evaluative link, readers might consider the following passage from Michael Lissack’s 2019 paper “Understanding Is a Design Problem.” In his paper, Lissack argues that for issues concerning selection, ones which involve agency and choice, designers have a substantial role to play—not as those who decide per se (the more traditional notion of the designer) but rather those who guide—a designer as one who guides and understands understanding. As the author notes, “I assert that the problems associated with the transmission, cognition, and understanding of meaning could be eased if there were a designer involved in the process: someone to set the stage so that the very actions one hopes to enable by a given exchange of meaning might have a better chance of occurrence.”106 While the links between education and understanding may seem tacit, Lissack’s aforementioned reference begins to reveal a messy intersectional “soup” not limited to desire, belief, value and truth. As Lissack later states in defining the intent of his paper, “This article describes one way out of this cognitive mess—the recognition that understanding is a design problem and is aided when we explicitly recognize the reflexive role of the designer, and of design as a practice carried out by a cognizer who is self-aware.”107 This self-awareness is but one reason we need design education—not just to train skilled production, but to train figures who might guide shared decision-making and understanding projects and processes. ¶ How Designers Decide ¶ Let’s take this evaluative and understanding-oriented role of design one step further. In a 2025 paper, Zelenko et al. described a performance-based assessment methodology for the design of housing layouts. In the paper, the authors note that the “assessment of any kind of building design is a complex task due to the differences in human perception of quality based on background, context, expectation and taste.”108 The authors later acknowledge the difficulties of “blurring of subjective and objective measurement methods.”109 This latter note reveals a gap in the design lexicon that is beyond mixed methods research. Again, this list maker asks readers to turn to educational assessment and perhaps also sociology for possible answers. For instance, since the late 1990s, figures such as Grant Wiggins and Jay McTighe have championed notions of Understanding by Design110 (UbD). In the second edition of Understanding by Design Wiggins and McTighe ask, “What is understanding and how does it differ from knowledge?”111 This blending of knowing and understanding also translates to design because some if not many design problems blend subjective and contextual taste(s) with qualifiable and quantifiable knowledge. Beyond this, architects and designers oftentimes encounter and navigate a whole host of other “concerns,” including cost, scale, use, ethics, and more. We might ask: how do designers, users, clients, and communities decide? To fill this gap, over the past few decades, architects and designers have, somewhat sporadically, placed various things at the “center” of design: this is evident in user-centered design, human-centered design, life-centered design, patient-centered design, and more. Paradoxically, in fact, “design” seems to be at the center of design.112 This view further supports countenance as a reference point for dynamic modes of evaluation, which in turn supports design-oriented decision-making and discovery-oriented work.113 ¶ Understanding how groups of people decide seems to be a concern that has escaped or been avoided by design academics and practitioners alike. This may be a gap that sociological research can help fill. For instance, in 2026 just as this section was being drafted Damon Centola published Goodthink: The New Science of Collective Intelligence, which in part addresses one of the biggest fears of many architects, planners, cretives and designers—what informally has been called groupthink—the idea that putting decisions are put before groups will result in watered down, weak or even polarized ideas or conclusions. Centola’s book begins to challenge the traditional, pessimistic groupthink view of groupthink with research that links the design of our networks, collaborations and interactions to the quality of our thinking—or said another way, well structured networks can create the conditions for better thinking. In a chapter titled, “Deciding How to Decide,” Centola suggests that, “In an egalitarian structure, centers of gravity emerge around those individuals who can pull the population away from group bias and toward more intelligent solutions.”114 Centola then suggests the possibility of a ripple effect by noting that, “once the problem is solved, the network seamlessly adapts by shifting the locus of power to find new leaders who are best suited to guide the collective through the next problems they face.”115 ¶ Curiously, while composing this c-word section, this list maker also stumbled upon the term “countenance” in a passage written by the legendary American architect Frank Lloyd Wright. Wright noted that, “Whether people are fully conscious of this or not, they actually derive countenance [emphasis added] and sustenance from the ‘atmosphere’ of the things they live in or with.”116 If countenance can be applied to describe something as design-oriented, complex, and “fuzzy” as atmosphere, what or where else might countenance be applied? ¶ In his boldly titled 1986 book A Kick in the Seat of the Pants, American author, speaker, and inventor Roger von Oech included a chapter titled “The Judge,” in which von Oech states, “We’re all familiar with the judge; indeed, it’s probably our most well-developed role. We use it to evaluate everything from what clothes to wear and what books to read….”117 Later, von Oech suggests, “The judge performs the evaluation function of the creative process.”118 With von Oech’s notion of “the judge” in mind, further exploration of creative countenance might provide creatives with more concrete language for describing and documenting our mixed-creative-evaluatory process. ¶ Notions of countenance evaluation resurface here as they may provide timely language for, and new frames around, building shared consensus through co-design or co-creation. Such a claim speculatively rests upon a plural and collegial attitude and affordance towards “what might count” within any shared evaluative process: especially ones that result in the introduction of artifacts, plans, policies, experiences and organizations. While this may seem like a general statement, it raises the bar for creative leadership—what future creative leaders need to know, and thus what would need to change. While the concepts and references cited above come from scholarly literature on educational evaluation, not design, there may also be opportunities to map this thinking onto initiatives aimed at designing social innovation and social change. While this assertion may at first seem to be akin to awkwardly bending a pipe into a shape and purpose it was never meant to be—such efforts likewise encounter the dilemma of who decides and what factors and decision-making frames inform those decisions. ¶ For architects, designers and creative leaders, fluencies around various modes of knowing, understanding and evaluating might be seen as future-oriented language-based skills—ones which are now on par with the visualization skills that were prioritized in the past. ¶ Another potentially salient aspect of countenance as an evaluatory frame is that it may provide a methodology for shared understanding and stakeholder engagement in change-oriented efforts. Not surprising this list-maker finds shared concerns across education and design. In a column on educational leadership and design, this list maker’s former colleague Carole Wedge, FAIA, once wrote, “Changing the patterns of discourse is a very important aspect of leading a process of organizational change. If different results are expected, they will not be achieved by going through the same old processes.”119 To support this shift, Wedge then identifies a list of six human factors: championship, ownership, satisfaction, accountability, responsibility, and fulfillment. Lastly, Wedge describes this creative-evaluatory process as not finite but circular, urging readers to consider, “defining feedback loops that allow for continuous adaptation, adjustment, and improvement.”120 ¶ What Wedge describes has overtones of countenance evaluation: a messy mix of engagement, evaluation, feedback loops, and consensus building also requires creatives to rethink our standard set of language. Countenance, a term as cited and proposed here, is rooted in years of evaluative scholarship in education and is worth considering in creative and designerly contexts. Yet, in this way, perhaps Stake was right that his countenance model was not quite right for education. However, countenance evaluation may be just right for something as rich and varied as design. As such, depending on the project, community, and context, countenance modes of evaluation and assessment might lead to more cogent critiques, fluid and equitable discourses, and evaluative mindsets that afford richer and more inclusive assessments of pedagogy, plans, projects, compositions, and ideas. But what exactly is an idea? Ideas encompass our human ability to think and imagine. Ideas drive one of our greatest superpowers: our ability to think conceptually.

  8. Concepts: For this list-maker, my first memorable encounter with the word “concept” occurred in one of my undergraduate graphic design courses. Professor Elizabeth Resnick (now Professor Emerita and an AIGA Medalist) taught the course. Resnick crisply defined a concept as “a well-developed thought or idea.”121 ¶ For this c-list entry on concepts, we might build upon Resnick’s definition to read, “a well-developed thought or idea made visible.” By “visible,” I do not necessarily mean “visual.” Instead, I am attempting to indicate various ways to bring ideas into the world and make them tangible. ¶ While there are many tried and true ways one can develop ideas and make them tangible, a well-explored, highly efficient methodology is to draw122|123 or even better yet sketch. A sketch, as defined here, need not be a drawing; a sketch could also be made of code, text, sound, or other digital or physical materials. In the world of art and design, there’s a term we use to describe very quick, small sketches meant to work out concepts and compositions. We call them thumbnail sketches. Thumbnail sketches help creatives quickly and efficiently work through and reflect on ideas. ¶ Sketches can also be dimensional (like a model) or interactive and/or functional (like a prototype). For those who work with sound or in performance, a sketch can be a quick recording, an impromptu rehearsal, or an improvisational session. ¶ There are no less than three reasons why this list maker suggests that sketching is not only useful to fellow creatives but essential: 1) Sketching allows one to fluidly and efficiently work through concepts, compositions, solutions, and motifs. 2) Sketching makes one’s thinking visible [or tangible], and thus creates a “breadcrumb” record of one’s progress, process, and thinking; 3) Sketching allows ideas to be more concretely communicated and shared such that they can be discussed, critiqued, evaluated, or compared. ¶ Much like our earlier exploration of writing, sketching is also an active form of thinking. Again, like writing, sketching encourages creatives to bring ideas out of their craniums and into the world, where they can be “read” or even tested and evaluated. ¶ There are many benefits associated with making ideas visible. Beyond sketching, some have described this active conceptual process as “visible thinking.” Project Zero at Harvard defines Visible Thinking as “a flexible and systematic research-based conceptual framework, which aims to integrate the development of students’ thinking with content learning across subject matters.”124 ¶ Regardless of your focus or discipline, from plumbers to pianists to pulmonologists, there is tremendous value in one’s ability to sketch, think conceptually, and make one’s thinking visible. It is equally important to consider the challenges of bringing concepts and ideas to life. Theodore Levitt’s 1963 Harvard Business Review article, titled “Creativity Alone is Not Enough,”125 in part seems to do just this. Levitt cautioned that those who focus purely on concepts or creativity alone may “tend to confuse the getting of ideas with their implementation—that is, confuse creativity in the abstract with practical innovation.”126 ¶ Somewhat akin to Levitt, in 2026 Jon Kolko explored a creativity-oriented concern that this list-maker had also observed: that the value and measure of creativity all too often is weighted towards novelty. Kolko posits that scholarship from psychology tends to “define creativity singularly through the narrow lens of novelty—that creativity is only concerned with newness, and creativity can (and should) be measured by the quantity of new ideas that are developed.”127 Whether readers agree or not, Kolko views these forms of measuring creativity as reductive. Along these lines, contemporary creative educators seem consistently suspicious of the overtly clever. Along these lines, much like many of the c-words selected for this list (and this list-maker’s p-word list), Kolko seems to elevate process, reflection, context, and more. Without digression, a sharp focus on newness alone unduly narrows the scope of what creatives and designers do—the things they make, and the problems they solve. ¶ In this creative course, we might acknowledge Kolko and Levitt’s perspectives but also afford ourselves a degree of possibility and optimism. In response to Levitt’s article, we might at least agree that the world has changed quite drastically since 1963. The tools we use to research and create have undergone especially profound change. Unlike 1963, today anyone with a laptop and an internet connection can broadcast ideas to millions of viewers with little overhead or cost. Furthermore, we might speculate that notions of a creator economy may continue to gain momentum and shift power dynamics in unknowable ways. Beyond this, as we explored in the curiosity section, we might remind ourselves that our unique human capacity for generating ideas will never go out of style. In fact, in the 21st century, one might say that creativity, conceptual thinking, and taste are steadfastly becoming a kind of currency.

  9. Currency: With every new advancement in technology, automation, and efficiency, new questions, challenges, and opportunities arise that reframe the value of human work, time, skill, contribution, value, and more. In this c-word list, we use the term currency in part to describe this process of examining these ever-emerging questions. This non-monetary use of currency also serves to frame creative capacity and creative capital. Notions of creative currency and creative capital can apply to individuals, organizations, cities, regions, and more. In a section of Richard Florida’s aforementioned book—titled “From Social Capital to Creative Capital”128—Florida chronicled shifting notions of social capital as explored by scholars such as Robert Putnam. For Putnam, social capital refers to the networks, norms, and social trust that facilitate coordination and cooperation for mutual benefit. Unsurprisingly, creative works, initiatives, and institutions are generally social and thus tend to bring a wide variety of people together. From music festivals to film productions, from startups to salons, people seem to gather around aesthetics and ideas. We might posit these creative gatherings as potluck dinners—organized around themes, problems, projects, media, interests, and more. What you bring to the “table” is your creative currency. ¶ In popular culture, being current might infer that one is somehow “in the know,” or that one is adept at the latest technology, or even up on the latest “trends.” This is not necessarily what is being described here. In this case, currency also maps to contribution. Over time, creative currency may lead to other c-words such as credibility (sometimes called “cred”). ¶ In creative work and perhaps life in general, it might be tempting to compare oneself to others. While this is a natural human tendency, it is also a slippery slope and should be actively tended to with attention and care. With that in mind, one’s creative contributions can be documented in what is often referred to as a “body of work” or, even better, a portfolio. The word portfolio is used in finance, investing, real estate, and other fields, but in the creative world, a portfolio is similarly used to describe the qualities and quantities of one’s contributions. Akin to investing, these are your creative assets or holdings. In creative and increasingly scholarly and academic contexts, a portfolio can quantify and qualify a collection of creative work—sometimes presented as case studies that can include associated information, contextual research, and, when appropriate, process, evidence, and outcomes.129 Somewhat by tradition in academia, such collections of contributions are called a Curriculum Vitae (or “CV”). A CV is a detailed, multi-page document outlining a full history of academic and professional accomplishments. But for those whose work is creative, a resume or CV may fall short because it lacks visuality and context. The portfolio not only contextualizes the work but also attempts to present it. ¶ Regardless of one’s interest, focus, or practice, one can consciously develop a body of work, and (portfolio or not) one can cultivate creative currency by engaging in studio habits of mind.130 Creative habits not only foster a sense of focus and reflection upon one’s own work but also an appreciation for the contributions of others. Outside of professional pursuits, engagement in the arts and sciences can also fuel interest, support, and appreciation. Half jokingly, I tell students in my introductory arts courses that some of them may become world-class art collectors.131 ¶ In the messiness of our potluck meal of creative production, success is sometimes out of one’s control. Notions of happiness and success are also highly personal, subjective, and relative. But for those looking for exposure and opportunities for collaboration, it does not hurt to make your work visible, or, said another way, to “show your work.”132 ¶ As noted above, portfolios not only “list” one’s experience and achievements, but they also attempt to “show” them. As has been the case for many years in fields such as architecture, fashion, and design, portfolios create a valuable record of past work. For those in academia, creative works can [and should] be viewed as “legitimate and valuable form[s] of research.”133 With these creative currency-oriented perspectives in mind, adding work to your portfolio is like making a deposit into a creative or design research134 savings account. ¶ Like a passbook, ledger, or passport, notions of creative currency allow us to “enter the bank” of creative culture while earning “interest” over time. And fortunately, you don’t need to go it alone. Most students in my courses seem to grasp these collaborative aspects of creative work quite intuitively. In fact, when they want to partner on something, they even use shorthand: “Hey, let’s collab!”

  10. Collaboration: Please join me in shattering a second common creativity-related myth: that highly creative people always work alone. While many types of creative work undoubtedly require considerable time spent on individual work, time spent with others is not only equally valuable but essential. From the salons of the 17th century to present-day creative “collabs” (Fig. 4) like bees spreading pollen, creatives dynamically produce and distribute ideas. ¶ From two-person projects to teams of ten thousand, collaboration is a big-tent creative multiplier that consistently fuels progress, innovation, and invention. Collaboration can encompass circles of interest, shared knowledge, shared work, and more. Sometimes, as teams grow larger, highly collaborative team members might “break off” or “branch out” and start new teams or pursue new ideas. This is common if not expected. ¶ One advantage of identifying as “creative” is that it signifies a willingness to collaborate. One can collaborate within a discipline or across or between fields. For those who venture into or collaborate across disciplines, these creative cross-pollinators are sometimes described as interdisciplinary, transdisciplinary, multidisciplinary, or multihyphenate (Fig. 6), and some even exhibit multiple intelligences.135 In 2023, Harvard Design Magazine (published by the Harvard Graduate School of Design) released a “Multihyphenate”-themed issue. In support of this theme, the guest editors invited “an international group of architects, curators, fashion designers, scholars, and artists to question the issue’s theme from different vantagepoints..”136 According to the editors, multihyphenation is “a compound term that points to alternative landscapes of creative production: ‘Collab’ culture; ‘brand X brand’ projects; and multiple, or even opaque styles of attribution or and ownership.”137 The term “multihyphenate” originated in the entertainment industry in the 1970s, but it has since expanded to encompass those whose creative work spans disciplines, genres, and fields. ¶ Unlike multidisciplinary or multihyphenate creatives, some alternatively develop “deep expertise” in one particular practice. Naturally, we describe those with “deep expertise” as having depth. ¶ But depth and breadth are not at all binary options. Instead, we might imagine present-day creatives as shape-shifting characters. In fact, since the 1980s, designers and other creative characters have oftentimes been described using the letter T138 (with the vertical stem representing depth of expertise and the horizontal stem representing breadth). The real magic happens when the capital T’s are placed side by side [TTT] because the top bars visually connect and can thus represent (you guessed it) creative collaboration. From Hollywood to tech to education,139 creatives and designers in particular seem to be natural T-shaped collaborators. ¶ Creative collaborators are oftentimes gathered, assembled, or facilitated by other highly organized connectors. These gatherers include directors, architects, principals, producers, project managers, curators, and more. These are the creative connectors, producers and conveners. Convenors are oftentimes the logistical or connective “glue”—the facilitators that guide creative experts, actors, and practitioners. Creative convenors may manage a creative project themselves, or sometimes they hire experts in management, finance, production, and business to join the creative team. ¶ Let’s now imagine traveling along a metaphorical timeline that represents human collaboration over the past few thousand years. As we traverse time, we encounter a vast array of creative, philosophical, scientific, technological, and intellectual ideas that morph and intersect over time. Like dynamic particles, these ideas emerge, diverge, and converge, and collide, and they seem to be doing so with increasing momentum. For the purposes of this c-list, let’s assume that this dynamic trajectory will only continue—and that new (or by today’s standards) even radical forms of collaboration will continue to emerge. One way to explore, posit, or describe this trajectory towards increased collaboration is to consider big tent notions of convergence.

  11. Convergence: The big tent term convergence can describe the merging of ideas, technologies, products, organizations, and more. Convergence is explored and elevated here as a possible 21st-century principle that may be worthy of further consideration and study. Convergence is principally included on this list for its problem-solving potential. Convergence provides a framework or strategy that dissolves disciplinary silos and actively brings together expertise at multiple levels and in ways beyond sporadic collaboration(s). Building upon notions of collaboration, convergence seeks to bring together experts from various disciplines who possess specific tools and mindsets. Convergence thus creates a dialogic framework for exploring problems, productions, and projects alike. As such, creative convergence creates a frame or space in which people, ideas, research, knowledge, and perspectives collide, intersect, or intermix. ¶ As posited here, there are varied flavors of convergence that attempt to blend various disciplines, roles, knowledge, expertise, and skill. ¶ One recent formulation of convergence can be found in Julio Mario Ottino and Bruce Mau’s 2022 book The Nexus,140 which describes and explores the convergence of art, technology, and science. Another example described a few years earlier (2010) might be David Edwards’ book Artscience,141 which again posited new forms of innovation at the intersection of the arts and sciences. ¶ Disciplinary integration, convergence, and integrative142 thinking have, for this list-maker, been a longstanding area of focused interest. Like streams, rivers, oceans, and other bodies of water, human knowledge flows along sometimes irregular and unpredictable trajectories. One might thus imagine convergence as the various points at which these ideas intersect. ¶ In another example (2011), a group of faculty from MIT authored a report detailing another flavor of convergence. The report was titled The Third Revolution: The Convergence of the Life Sciences, Physical Sciences, and Engineering. In a letter that preceded the report, the faculty stated, “The past decade has seen the evolution of new interdisciplinary research areas…”143 while further stating that, “These new fields share a comparable, underlying research model, convergence, [emphasis added] and there is a need to see them as a unity in order to ensure their continued progress. The successful application of this model will require not simply collaboration between disciplines, but true disciplinary integration.”144 ¶ One might speculate that 21st-century notions of convergence will present new opportunities in education and industry alike. Such factors may lead to or even demand new formulations of physical space, new models of staffing, new forms of compensation, experimental curricula, and more. Moreover, convergence-oriented work may require changes in mindsets and perhaps even new understandings of ownership and authorship.145 ¶ Creatives, architects, scientists, engineers, and designers, in particular, have long been interested in integrated and convergence-oriented structures. This is largely because film, architecture, and design projects alike often require a vast combination of perspectives, expertise, and disciplines. They also oftentimes entertain or pursue many possible answers or solutions to a given problem. ¶ As highlighted in the Introduction section of this c-word list, design researchers Jonathan Cagan and Craig M. Vogel once explored, articulated, and demonstrated the all-too-common gaps across disciplinary perspectives. In a section of their 2002 book Creating Breakthrough Products, the authors note that “Although the need for integration seems obvious, it is not an easy thing to do.”146 ¶ The authors memorably illustrate differences in disciplinary perspectives with a qualitative experiment. Cahen and Vogel present three different kitchen colanders (or “strainers”) before a cross-disciplinary team of designers, marketers, engineers, and suppliers. They then prompt the participants to posit the following question: “If you owned a company, which colander would you prefer to sell and why?”147 It’s not at all surprising to hear that the variation in colander selections among the participants was “significant.”148 Cagen and Vogel’s experiment clearly “demonstrates the inherent gap in perception between these different players [from different disciplines].”149 ¶ But Cagen and Vogel also mention a sole engineer—one who somehow bridged the perceptual gap. In reference to this figure, the authors share this revealing note: “In following that engineer’s performance in the company, we found him one of the best at negotiating solutions….”150 This latter detail is crucial. Building consensus-based or co-designed solutions requires figures who can effectively align varied perspectives and concerns. These designerly leaders151 may be key when seeking convergence-oriented approaches. As such, creatives can productively avoid getting stuck in the perceptual gap. Such figures are key within organizations that desire a designful152 or design-forward culture. ¶ Rightfully so, some might fear that convergence-oriented solutions may simply lead to “watered-down ideas” or “groupthink.” While this is always possible, such occurrences are often the byproduct of leaders who mishandle or mismanage the creative process. ¶ Beyond bridging perceptual gaps, convergence-oriented creatives may be particularly well suited for the development of comprehensive solutions. ¶ Comprehensive solutions are dissimilar to one-off projects or fixes and are particularly focused on addressing problems of high complexity. This, of course, is based on the premise that some complex problems require equally complex or “comprehensive” solutions. In seeking comprehensive solutions to a vast range of projects and problems, designerly minds combine “convergent” and “divergent” thinking.153 This designerly thinking also attempts to consider short and long-term concerns simultaneously. This is in part why students in this creative class are encouraged to develop, explore, and exercise a “comprehensive view.”

  12. Comprehensive: This list-maker traces his interest in all things “comprehensive” to his design history Professor Al Gowan. As Gowan often noted in his comprehensive-view-oriented lectures, he briefly studied with the well-known 20th-century futurist Buckminster “Bucky” Fuller.154 Years later, it was no surprise for this list-maker then to discover that Fuller titled the first chapter of his well-known 1969 book, Operating Manual for Spaceship Earth, “Comprehensive Propensities.” ¶ Within the chapter, Fuller makes an argument for a complement or alternative to “narrow, shortsighted specializations.”155 ¶ Not to dismiss Fuller’s skepticism of specializations outright, this list maker might suggest that a more nuanced argument might simultaneously recognize the tremendous value of specializations and expertise. Nuances aside, in this creative course, we will likewise attempt to grapple with this notion of “the comprehensive view.” Within his Operating Manual, Fuller states, “Of course, our failures are a consequence of many factors, but possibly one of the most important is that society operates on the theory that specialization is the key to success, not realizing that specialization precludes comprehensive thinking.”156 Furthermore, Fuller suggests that “specializations are not comprehended integratively.”157 ¶ In earlier sections of this list, we lightly touched upon the benefits, drawbacks, and challenges of singular creative visions. If we follow the logic of the “Hollywood model,” one might assume that a single director provides some semblance of creative stability or guidance, and the producer(s) then ensure the “thing” gets made. ¶ But now more than ever, designers and other creatives are also interested in exploring and interrogating participatory, engaged, co-designed, co-created, and collaborative models of making. Designers also need data-driven models, concepts, and plans using a countenance evaluation mindset. Technologies such as artificial intelligence are fueling these data-driven design models, making these capabilities faster and more accessible. Data, media, visuals, text, and ideas can now be shared rapidly and cheaply. Creatives, clients, communities, and stakeholders can likewise meet, communicate, and share information in real or near-real time, and often at no or low cost. Designers may be well suited to facilitate and lead these communal design processes. ¶ Now more than ever, designers are also afforded the opportunity to explore and enact “integrated solutions” that pull from “integrated models.” For instance, many contemporary architecture firms now employ “Integrated design methodologies” and “building information modeling,” which enable information to dynamically converge across the broader team (client, engineer, builder, finance, design, project management, and more). This integrated approach has reshaped the tools, processes, and timelines associated with building, design, and construction. Thus, the present-day architectural “model” (digital, not physical) can and does dynamically update to reflect changes in costs, form, materials, energy use, and more.158 Outside of architecture, as more comprehensive, information-rich creative technologies continue to emerge, it seems even more crucial to bring stakeholders face-to-face at the creative decision-making “table”—and [ideally] to do so early in the process. A great way to facilitate this process is to organize an intensive creative workshop, which architects call a charrette.

  13. Charrettes: Let’s start with what a charrette is not. A design charrette is not a quick brainstorming session or “design thinking” workshop where a group of participants slathers sticky-note ideas on a wall, eats a catered lunch, and calls it a productively “creative” day. ¶ Before I worked in the marketing department of an architecture firm, I had actually never heard of the term “charrette” (also called a “design charrette”). But like a live-action design-research theatre event, a charrette might be better experienced than described. One might describe a charrette as a highly dynamic, sometimes intense, ideally well-planned and well-informed workshop of sorts that aims to interrogate and explore ideas. Charrette can provide direction, solicit input, and sometimes help achieve alignment towards specific objectives, designs, or plans. ¶ The term charrette originates from the French word “cart.” Legend has it that, starting in the 1800s, the term referred to the final push by students studying art and architecture at the École des Beaux-Arts, typically made before a major deadline or review. ¶ A creative-design charrette can take place over the course of a few hours, a few days, or even over longer periods of time. When conducting a charrette, as much as possible, it is helpful to have all the decision-makers at the table: experts, stakeholders, users, clients, or community members, depending on the objective at hand. This way, any solutions discussed or developed can capture, or at least consider, a range of concerns, abilities, cultures, and perspectives. During charrettes, architects and planners often create or display sketches, prototypes, data, drawings, maps, and diagrams. Ideally, this is done in a space where such information can be viewed, compared, and contrasted “at a glance.” Oftentimes, reference material or readings are provided in advance of a charrette. Unlike “voting on ideas,” charrettes are immersive, dialogic, and sometimes even emergent. Ideally, charrette participants are surrounded by the problem: its contexts, precedents, and possible solutions. As more concrete ideas emerge and solutions are formulated or proposed, proposals can then be compared, contrasted, combined, and critiqued.

  14. Critique: Who in this class, please raise your hand, enjoys being criticized? Inevitably, when I present this question to students in my creative courses, I rarely see a hand raised. Understandably, for many, having one’s ideas debated or criticized can be an uncomfortable experience. Despite this discomfort, critique is an activity and skill that has long served as the touchstone for how creatives interrogate ideas, form, materials, solutions, and more. One key for beginners to reduce the discomfort of criticism is to remember that you are not your work. Said another way, if the work is being criticized, it’s the work, not you, that’s being criticized. ¶ I have long wondered if creative educators should replace the term critique (or “crit” for shorthand) altogether? My rationale for this lies in what I (and surely others) have termed my creative-course “no like” rule. In my classes, during critiques, I politely ask students to attempt to refrain from using phrases such as “I like” or “I don’t like.” Instead, I ask them, as best they can, to articulate feedback using constructive, non-subjective language. I accomplish this by asking them to try framing feedback using phrases such as, “This works well because of W, and this does not because X, Y, and Z.” ¶ In popular culture, there’s a false assumption that artistic and designerly works are purely driven by subjectivity, or largely concerned with style. ¶ Sometimes, as a contrast to this subjectivity, I’ve wondered if “critiques” might more productively be labeled “constructives.” With this critical-versus-constructive argument aside, for those new to my courses, I often suggest that you try using “you may” statements. You may want to consider this, or you may want to check out this person’s work, that precedent, this book, or this research paper. You may want to try V, or W, X, or Y, or Z. ¶ In their 2025 book, Studio Properties, Derek Jones et al. provide a multi-page section on “Critique and the Crit.”159 The authors note that “Critique refers to both the act of giving formative and summative feedback and the word crit refers to specific activity types used to explicitly engage in critique.”160 Formative feedback is typically provided during or throughout the creative process. In some schools of art, architecture, and design, this is sometimes called a “desk crit” or “studio crit.” Summative feedback is typically higher-stakes and usually delivered towards the end of the project or performance, or once it is close to completion. ¶ Being a constructive critic is far more challenging than being a critic who resorts to subjective or disconnected statements. Generally, it is this capacity for constructive thinking that fuels many creative leaders. These constructive critics at once strive to be clear, articulate, honest, reasoned, and informed. These constructive critics oftentimes come prepared and do any necessary legwork or research in advance. ¶ With these evaluative communicative concerns in mind, for the presenter of creative work, it is also essential to consider power dynamics. During a critique, or even a presentation to clients, creatives need to consider who in the “room” and who actually “holds the keys.” Those who “hold the keys” are often those with money, power, or decision-making authority within a hierarchical organization. ¶ Scott Berkun and Bryan Zug do an excellent job illustrating this essential point. In their 2024 book, Why Design is So Hard. Berkun and Zug state, “On the first day of design school, and in the first page of every design book, there should be a clarifying lesson about human nature. Decision making in the real world [emphasis added] is a social process, not a solitary one.”161 Then, Berkun and Zug deftly walk readers through the pragmatic realities of relationship building, persuasion, influence, and more, sharply illustrating their point by noting that sometimes those “with low design talent but power” can sometimes “do terrible things,” and also the opposite, “whereas someone with great design talent but low power likely has no impact at all.”162 ¶ To make Berkun and Zug’s point another way, we might imagine building upon the aforementioned notion of T-shaped people and instead use the letter H. This imaginary H-shaped person163 (Fig. 1) can also leap and rotate 90 degrees. The resultant typographic form (depending on the typeface) is more of an “I” (Fig. 2). The “I” could thus represent Berkun and Zug’s notions of influence and “impact,” but might also unlock the potential for other “I’s”: intelligence or even innovation.164 When two of these I’s are placed side by side, they form a Roman numeral II (Fig. 3), which might stand for “shared influence.” ¶ How one navigates or reacts to negative feedback is also a practiced skill. This practiced skill combines composure, timing, contemplation, rhetoric, countenance, and more.165 Instead of reacting to negative feedback by starting with the phrase, ‘I disagree,’ a mentor of mine once suggested that one alternative is to first consider responding with the phrase, ‘I’ve never considered that before’ or even the more famous ‘yes and….’ Even if you disagree or plan to offer a constructive rebuttal, you thereby maintain productive collegiality and flow. This list maker, like many before him, has admittedly learned this skill the hard way. ¶ While critiques can be stressful, and of course, while creatives are passionate about their work, one should be careful not to let that passion undermine creative relationships. If there is one takeaway from this section, it may be this: avoid subjective statements, feedback, or arguments. Instead, try to surround your feedback and suggestions—and creative discourse in general—with ideas, precedents, evidence, scholarship, data, examples, samples, stories, studies, narrative, prototypes, demos, reference points, process, or contexts—anything other than I do or do not ‘like it.’ As such, context is one of the fundamental properties that informs and differentiates some creative works from purely scientific ones. So, next, let’s do some contextual research.

  15. Context: In 1996, Bill Gates penned an essay titled Content is King. As legend has it, in his essay, Gates suggested that content was where “the real money” would be made on the internet.166 While frequently attributed to Gates, the phrase “content is king” was used much earlier. In 1974, J.W. Click and Russel N. Baird appear to have used the phrase in the context of magazine editing and production.167 ¶ In the 21st century, we might make an equally bold assertion—which is that when it comes to designerly, creative, and project-based work, context not content may be “king.” As Stephen Nachmanovich stated in his 2019 book The Art of Is, “Every expression is tied to person, place and time. Context is everything.”168 Without digressing into scholarly or philosophical debates over positivism versus relativism or the long and rich history that has shaped these discourses,169 it may be said that, in many spheres, “the role and significance of context-dependence“170 still faces many uphill battles. ¶ Thus, let’s start with some basic context-oriented arguments. One might assert with some confidence that human beings are emotional, and thus our decisions are not always based on rational logic. Viewed broadly, human decision-making is often driven by a “fuzzy mix” of logic, emotion, and other complex factors. For example, the choice of a vehicle may be driven not only by factors such as safety and performance but also by the car’s color. ¶ While context has always been a factor in designing and design, most 21st-century designers and architects have increased aperature on contextual approaches and concerns. In a 2026 article for Time, Debbie Millman asserts that, “Good design relies on understanding context: how a building sits on its street, how a chair accommodates a body, how type works on the page and for the reader.”171 Despite our understanding of the importance of context in design, Millman then points out “how often these considerations seem to disappear, as if the object itself matters more than the environment or community it belongs to.”172 ¶ Alas, Millman’s context-minded cultural critique leads us to assert that despite our advances around all things contextual, we still have a long way to go. Alas, I am not alone in elevating this trajectory and these concerns. In his 2025 book, Design Empathy and Contextual Awareness, Wayne K. Li states, “Contextual awareness is one of the design behaviors that can be elusive for young designers.”173 Being “contextually aware”174 should not be an elusive afterthought. In creative work, examining context can be seen as a form of research. In fact, while studying at the Dynamic Media Institute, this list-maker was first introduced to notions of “contextual research.” ¶ Contextual research provides creatives with a vehicle for collecting, exploring, and examining historical, cultural, scientific, and even metaphorical references as one develops a project or composition or as one examines a problem. ¶ As a big tent c-word, context can serve as a frame to explore aesthetics, ethics, systems, evidence, costs, materials, and more.175 In what might sound like a description of reading glasses, context can serve as a metaphorical lens or frame. These lenses and frames can help shape, define, or situate a work. Contextual research can be leveraged and considered when conceptualizing products, communication, places, initiatives, experiences, and more. ¶ Exploring context often involves asking broad “w” questions—the who, what, where, when, how, and why—which can help shape form, meaning, access, solutions, tone, and more. ¶ How one communicates context can also shape the meaning and understanding of a work. Designers, artists, musicians, and architects often strive for a work to “stand on its own two feet.” By this, I mean that they hope viewers will “get it” without it having to be explained. In this way, some artists and creatives intentionally opt not to explain, include, or share inspirations, precedents, or contexts. One common rationale for this line of reasoning is that the creative hopes that the viewer, reader, listener, or user will bring their own interpretation and contextual understanding(s) to the work. In contrast to this “pure” view, we know that in a museum setting, even the title or date of a work placed next to it can drastically shift its meaning. Thus, the “museum label” oftentimes provides crucial contextual clues. ¶ In 2024, the New York-based industrial designer Todd Bracher published Design in Context. In a section titled “The Context for Innovation,” Bracher states that the “traditional approach to design, focusing on the object or the ‘what,’ often misses the mark in fostering true innovation.”176 Instead of focusing on the “what,” Bracher suggests focusing on the “why” or “the context within which design takes shape.”177 Building on Bracher’s suggestions, we might see context as a way for creatives to triangulate a range of topics or to interrogate our instincts. Context can also help us parse problems through historical or particular perspectives. ¶ Further building upon the aforementioned notion of contextual research178—such practices can create pathways for understanding considering human,179environmental, and more-than-human concerns. In some ways, all these concerns could be viewed as context at the micro- to macro-scale. ¶ Lastly, nearly any architect will attest that understanding contextual factors such as the “site” of a building or structure is crucial. Likewise, many designers now directly engage communities as they develop or co-develop solutions. These voices can meaningfully inform and shape the final design. ¶ In summary, contextual research affords creators the opportunity to examine and apply a whole host of issues, precedents, technologies, and concerns. Such information can be collected or documented in case studies, reports, white papers, films, or video essays. Distilling the context of a work can also help creators break down or explore complications and complexities. Complexities are oftentimes interdependent, dynamic, adaptive, or even “emergent.” Fortunately, artists and other creatives are trained to be comfortable in these emergent spaces. This is in part why I’m suggesting that students in this course also explore and posit complexity.

  16. Complexity: In 2006, John Maeda published a timely and (in this list maker’s view) quite delightful 100-page book titled The Laws of Simplicity.180 After reading Maeda’s book, I was so captivated that I asked the President of the architecture firm I worked for at the time if she would consider purchasing copies for all the firm’s employees (to my surprise, she said yes). I subsequently asked if we could invite Maeda in as a lunchtime guest speaker (which we did). The architecture firm I worked for at the time had its headquarters in Boston’s seaport, and around this time Meada was just “over the river” [the Charles] serving as a Professor in MIT’s Media Lab. ¶ Maeda’s book on simplicity was organized around ten “laws” and three “keys,” which, in the mid-2000s, as the worlds of design and tech seemed to be colliding in new and fascinating ways, The Laws of Simplicity seemed to embody this particular time in technology and design. For instance, in 2001, Apple launched the iPod, which was designed by the minimalist Dieter Rams-inspired British industrial designer Jony Ive. Years later, in 2012, Ive was even knighted for his pioneering work.181 Compared to other music players available at the time, the iPod seemed like a time-warping leap into the future of aesthetics, technology, and usability. Under the watchful eye of Apple’s founder, Steve Jobs, Ive and his team devised an elegant touch-wheel interface for the digital music player, and it shipped with far more music storage capacity than its competitors. This tight integration, or “marriage,” of form, technology, and function (aka “simplicity”) was also evident in Maeda’s research lab at MIT. Maeda’s lab, founded in 1996, was titled the Aesthetics and Computing Group. Meada’s lab seemed to be pushing beyond 20th-century “form and content” or “form and function” vocabularies of design in light of three d’s—digitization, data, and dynamism. ¶ Then, in 2007, Apple launched the iPhone, another monumental leap which, like the iPod, radically leveraged a tightly integrated combination of aesthetics, technology, and usability. Aside from its physical design, the iPhone, like a digital multipurpose tool, effectively cannibalized dozens of standalone gadgets, from in-car GPS units to compasses, calculators to MP3 players, and over time, anything that could be reimagined as an “app.” As of this writing, Apple has sold over three billion iPhones.182 ¶ Given this wildly successful record of success around simplicity in the 21st century, why would this list-maker call for students to also posit complexity? Going further, have you ever met anyone who craves more complexity in their lives? We know the answer is likely no. ¶ In the 21st century, many humans now live in an age of abundance—but, in some ways, connected to this is the fact that we also live in a time of unprecedented complexity. As a “big tent” term, there are innumerable ways one could approach, define, or explore complexity. We could easily branch into systems thinking, political theory, aesthetics, physics, theology, and more. So, when it comes to complexity and creativity, where might one start and why? ¶ One answer, or at least a place to start, may be found in Dennis Frenchman et al.’s 2025 book Designing the X. Frenchman et al. claim that, “traditional analytic approaches to problem-solving fall short when faced with unmeasurable and multifaceted challenges.”183 The authors then launch into a section aptly titled “Flow With Complexity,”184 which explores ways for designers and other creatives to better understand complexity or even embrace or attempt to understand its flow. ¶ Frenchman et al. are most certainly not the first to posit the intersection of complexity and design. In 2010, Katerina Alexiou et al. published Embracing Complexity in Design,185 a 232-page interdisciplinary anthology featuring wide-ranging scholarly perspectives on everything from art to architecture to management, and more. One section titled “Embracing design in complexity” (authored by the architect and educator Jeffrey Johnson) effectively flips the complexity-design script by advocating design methods and mindsets for those interested in complex systems science. In his section, Johnson notes that “few scientists today know anything about design as a process for understanding, creating, and managing complex systems.”186 But interestingly, Johnson suggests that this dynamic could change within a decade. How this might change remains unclear, but this list maker senses that the study of subjects such as design, aesthetics, and complexity may become valuable literacies beyond traditional designers and the design field, and, in turn, may bring a broader pool of interest to systems-level thinking. ¶ The following year (in 2011), Donald Norman,187 a pioneer in the field of user experience design (UX) and interaction design (IxD), published Living with Complexity. While Norman’s book was chock-full of both practical design considerations and memorable examples, for this list-maker, a short note on the last page was the most poignant. To tame the complexity of technology, Norman suggested a partnership “between the designers and those of us who use it.”188 The sentiment of this last statement reflects increasingly common notions of designing with versus designing for. ¶ Paradoxically, notions of complexity and the discourse it unearths have led some critiques of the “design thinking” process itself. For example, in 2024, Anne-Laure Fayard and Sarah Fathallah authored an article titled “Design Thinking Misses the Mark ” in the Stanford Social Innovation Review.189 In their paper, Fayard and Fathallah note that “The social sector is inherently complex [emphasis added] because it consists of a multitude of actors across different contexts, timelines, and political realities. Any approach that purports to easily solve for such complexity is more likely than not to be reductive and therefore ineffective.”190 ¶ Fayard and Fathallah’s perspective lends credence to our interest and exploration at the intersection of creativity, context, and complexity. In this list-maker’s somewhat limited literature review on complexity, it was suggested that I explore Edgar Morin’s complexity-oriented writings. Morin191 is a French philosopher and sociologist who is widely regarded as the “Father of Complexity.” Fortunately, I obtained an English translation of Edgar Morin’s 2008 book On Complexity. The first chapter of Morin’s book is titled “Blind Intelligence,” in which Morin first notes that “We have acquired extraordinary knowledge about the physical, biological, psychological, and sociological world.”192 But as we posit problem solving and creative work, Morin’s next suggestion is less obvious but perhaps more fruitful. Morin writes that “The deep cause of error is not error of fact (false perception), or error of logic (incoherence), but rather the way we organize [emphasis added] our knowledge into a system of ideas….”193 ¶ Moreover, as we ponder Morin’s point, and think more broadly about how knowledge, artifacts and ideas are interwoven, it may add additional substance to our notion of the “H-shaped person.” Firstly, our shift from a T-shaped person to an H-shaped one (Fig. 1) metaphorically “lowers the bar” for creative collaboration, which, in turn, invites more people to the problem-solving table. Then, unlike the T-shaped person, the H-shaped one was more explicitly engaged in theory and practice. To illustrate this idea, we effectively “split” traditional notions of “expertise” (the stem of the core common T-shaped person) right down the middle. This results in two verticals (the left and right verticals of the H). Then the top crossbar of the T (which has frequently stood for breath or collaboration) gets lowered to the midpoint of the two stems. This makes an H shape. With this formulation in mind, we encounter an H-shaped “creative” character. ¶ Furthermore, as we posit an H-shaped creative character, one of the split vertical stems—let’s say the one on the left represents the creative character’s competencies (and/or “skills”). The other could represent literacies, sensitivities (or even “knowledge”).194 But there’s something even more magical that happens when these H’s are combined. When the H’s are stacked vertically, we get a shape that looks exactly like a ladder (Fig. 5), which is the perfect metaphor for “teams” or “reading new heights.” In contrast to horizontally-linked T-shaped individuals, H-shaped individuals could “stack” to create ladders that combine skills, knowledge, and expertise. For those interested in marketing, these ladders, placed side by side, could, as Al Ries and Jack Trout once described, represent various notions of positioning195 (Fig. 8). ¶ But let’s back up and ask what we mean when we use the term “literacies”? Historically, and even today, the term “literacy” is associated with one’s ability to read and write, but since the 1940s, conceptions of literacy have broadened significantly. For better or worse, it would seem that “literacy” can now signify understanding, skill, aptitude, knowledge, and ability across a range of media and fields.196 Issues around literacy have become even more pressing with the introduction of new technologies such as AI. Some scholars even argue that “literacy in the time of AI requires a new way to speak about itself, a revised “grammar” of sorts.”197 This is, of course, in response to technologies that can “write text as conventionally understood, but also to ‘read’ images by matching textual labels and to ‘write’ images from textual prompts.”198 Thus it is all the more pressing that we as humans, as part of our general education and understandings, emphasize literacy in reading and writing texts and images alike. Unfortunately, this comes at a time when some educators fear that literacy is in decline. ¶ In art, design, and media education, we have long attempted to teach “visual literacy.” Visual literacy as a general literacy is no longer the singular purview of artists, critics, art historians, and designers—nor should it be. Anyone with an Instagram account, for instance, is immersed in visual culture—so we are well served to study it. In support of this view, in the third edition of Visual Culture (first published in 2019), Richard Howells and Joaquim Negreiros state, “If we live in a visual world, learning to be visually literate is not a luxury but a necessity.”199 As we ponder expanding conceptions of such literacies, we simultaneously need to expand our conception of what a “text” is. We’ve already touched upon the notion of context, but now we must parse texts as well. Texts and contexts are at once distinct and interconnected ideas. To explore this idea further, I propose that we revisit a somewhat old-fashioned word: a codex.

  17. Codex: In Howells and Negreiros’ aforementioned book, the first section explores various facets of visual theory. Wisely, to make this more concrete, Howells and Negreiros use John Constable’s well-known 1821 painting The Hay Wain200 as a reference point. The painting then helps frame a conversation around texts and contexts. In summary, the authors aim to instill in the reader a basic understanding of how we “read” images. Then, as we explored in the previous section, we might better understand the context and thus become more visually literate. ¶ With no slight to Constable or his painting, the work is, in many ways, “what-you-see-is-what-you-get.”201 By that, we might agree that the imagery in The Hay Wain is highly accessible and understandable — thus it is relatively easy for a general audience to analyze, parse, and “read.” ¶ At first, this notion of “reading visuals” as texts may sound strange to some students in this class. This is likely why Howells and Negreiros chose The Hay Wain, as “reading” the work requires very little context—thereby lowering the barrier for students to plainly discuss and analyze what they “see” in the work. As we further posit the term “context,” we recognize that understanding some works requires “prior knowledge of the subject”202 to fully grasp their meaning or significance. In much simpler terms, some might describe this as “knowing the codes.”203 ¶ To help us visualize interlinked notions of texts, contexts, and codes, let’s imagine a series of footnotes within footnotes. In footnote A, there may be a reference to footnote B, and within footnote B, there may be a reference to footnotes C and D, and so on. As our footnotes within footnotes expand, the varied references and contexts branch out like a tree. While the word codex was the historical term for a text or book, we’ll also use it here to posit footnote-like notions of interlinked ideas. ¶ Curiously, the word codex comes from the Latin word caudex, which also translates to mean the “trunk of a tree” or a “block of wood.”204 So just as the word model can be used to describe something physical or conceptual, the word “codex”, as posited here, could be either physical (a book) or conceptual (interwoven ideas) as well. We might thus imagine that every creative project might be supported by a codex of interconnected ideas that informs it. ¶ To understand codex as it is posited here, let’s return to the word context once more. Within the word context, not surprisingly, we find the word “text”—and interestingly, the origins of the word “text” also suggested connections to our physical world. In fact, “text” originates from the Latin word texere, which means “to weave.”205[ Going one step further, this text-oriented etymology also brings us closer to the contemporary wonderful word “texture”. ¶ Etymology aside, the whole point here is for students in this creative course to start to see and posit texts, contexts, and textures as interconnected through language. ¶ Now that we have a grasp of how “texts” are woven and interwoven, we can more easily posit the productive weaving of texts (or ideas). Much like “weaving,” creative work is often a process of inventing and combining concepts and material(s). ¶ As we posit the productive gathering of concepts and material(s), those who have already taken my course know I am generally not a fan of “brainstorming.” In fact, for most projects, I’d advise students to largely avoid it. The reason I suggest we avoid brainstorming is that it often lacks rigorous framing or context, which, if you’ve been following along, we might agree are essential components of creative work. ¶ Instead of “brainstorming,” we might be better served by an activity more akin to the aforementioned charrette. Half-jokingly, I often ask students to start a project by visiting an archive or library, or by collecting “footnotes.” The term “footnotes” is used broadly in this creative course. Ideas, images, research, and more can be “footnoted” as part of your contextual research. ¶ By avoiding activities such as brainstorming, we can save time and simultaneously debunk some widely held myths around creative work. Mostly, this helps us avoid the “light bulb” trap—the idea that creativity or innovation occurs in a flip of a switch, sudden, random, “aha!” way. ¶ Along these lines, in his 1997 paper, the design scholar and educator Nigel Cross stated that, “In creative design […] a creative leap does not necessarily require a radical shift in viewpoint.”206 Notably, Cross also stated, “This is what characterizes creative design as exploration rather than a search.”207 To conclude this section, this list-maker suggests that one great way to explore and collect footnotes is to read. ¶ If you want to be a meaningful creative explorer and contributor, I also suggest getting into the habit of reading. Reading is like exercise for the brain. Reading can spark new ways of thinking, doing, understanding, or seeing. Reading (just as we noted for writing) is like fuel for creative thought; as it is often said, it is a portal to another place or another person’s mind.208 So pick up a book (physical or digital) and read. ¶ The Library ¶ Lastly, as we ponder codex, I must also advocate for the role of the library and the librarian. Librarians are like master codexian catalysts in all the ways we’ve posited here. The library has been, and will continue to be, a special, if not sacred, space and place.209 But there is sad news for the library lover and text toter. Reading seems to be in decline.210 In response, some, including this list-maker, are issuing a calculated call to consider (or reconsider) the codex. In her excellent 2018 book titled Reader Come Home, Maryanne Wolf gently reminds us that the “acquisition of literacy is one of the most important epigenetic achievements of Homo sapiens.”211 With some echoes of Aristotle’s notion of the “good society,” Wolf then makes a compelling case for reading as a source of contemplation, entertainment, the exploration of ideas, and more. ¶ Very much like reading, another timeless way to explore ideas is through dialogue and conversation. Unfortunately, like reading, traditional conversation may also be on the decline. But what if, akin to reading and writing, conversation itself became a highly desired and learnable 21st-century literacy? This may be wishful thinking, but, at the very least, let’s have a conversation about conversation.

  18. Conversation: Donald Schön (1930–1997)212 once described designing as a reflective “conversation with the materials of the situation.”213 In this way we might describe aspects of designing as rhetorical.. For over 2,000 years, rhetoric was viewed as an essential pillar of Western education. From Ancient Greece, as early as the 5th century BCE, through the late 19th century, rhetoric wasn’t just a subject—it was the subject. Today, in popular culture (perhaps for good reasons), the term “rhetoric” oftentimes carries negative connotations. When describing a viewpoint that lacks backing, research, or substance, it is common to hear someone say, “Well, that’s just rhetoric!” ¶ But as we explore the big-tent c-word conversation, we might begin to see conversation as a practice. As a practice, conversation is at once subtly connected to but also distinct from rhetoric. Along these lines, it is no surprise that many view or describe conversation as an art.214 ¶ Our ability to engage in conversation is one of our most valuable human capacities. As was noted earlier, conversation’s argument-oriented cousin, rhetoric, was once viewed as an essential subject—one meant to train and prepare students for engagement in scholarly, public, civic, or professional life. Alongside grammar and logic, rhetoric formed what was often called the trivium.215 Interestingly, the Latin word trivium translates to “the place where three roads meet.”216 ¶ This notion of an intersection or meeting place is key, as we posit conversation as an elevated 21st-century creative concern. For creatives in this course, conversation might be viewed as a dynamic “space” where thoughts, narratives, voices, and ideas can be exchanged. While we sometimes take conversation for granted and some see it as a waste of time, conversation is a superpower of human intelligence. ¶ If conversation is an “art,” then like any art, it’s one that may take practice. Some conversation is like really good jazz. While I am not an expert in jazz or even in music, I’m sure we can agree that jazz often exhibits exchange, rhythm, and progression, which are generally the hallmarks of a good conversation as well. ¶ Conversation as a space, medium, or format (as compared to a lecture, for instance) might be viewed as digressive, discursive, or inefficient—and that may be a good thing. Despite these drawbacks, some advocate for a renewed focus. One such scholar is Sherry Turkle.217 In 2015 Turkle published Reclaiming Conversation: The Power of Talk in a Digital Age. Turkle is an American sociologist and is currently the Abby Rockefeller Mauzé Professor of the Social Studies of Science and Technology at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, where her research explores psychoanalysis and human-technology interaction. Within a section titled “A Love Letter to Collaboration,” Turkle makes note of a biography composed by the Nobel Prize-winning economist Daniel Kahneman, written to pay tribute to his late colleague Amos Tversky.218 In describing Kahneman’s letter, and thus his close professional relationship with Tversky, she notes, “Here we see conversation [emphasis added] as not only an intellectual engine but the means by which colleagues were able to cross boundaries that are usually only dissolved by love.”219 Then, in a poetic line that follows, Turkle states, “Conversation led to intellectual communion.”220 ¶ Another conversation and creativity-minded scholar is Michael Arnold Mages. In 2024, Mages published Conversational Design: Improving Participation and Decision-Making in Public Organizations, which offers readers, especially designers, leaders and planners, a more applied approach to conversation. Mages’ perspectives are especially salient for those interested in collaborative, co-designed, community-engaged practices. As Mages details in his book, a “design”—be it an environment, a product, an experience, or otherwise can be “shaped” by conversation. But as anyone who has attended a community meeting can attest, managing these conversations can be tricky. Thus, to strengthen our conversational abilities, one must engage in it as a practice. Thankfully, there are learnable techniques that make this process more effective. Mages’ book, for instance, offers techniques and case studies for conversation leaders and participants alike. In the introduction, Mages states, “When designers design a thing, beyond designing form, function, and meaning, they create a set of potentials for conversations to be had with, through, or facilitated by that thing.”221 Mages then states, “conversations are fundamental to human experience.”222 I hope you agree. ¶ In summary, conversation is a powerful and dynamic exchange facilitated through language. But while conversation can be productive, it is also somewhat unpredictable. In this way, conversations might be described as more like clouds rather than clocks. As broad metaphors, clocks and clouds are thus the next two c-words explored in this incomplete list.

  19. Clocks: In 1965, Karl Popper delivered the Arthur Holly Compton Memorial Lecture at Washington University. Popper, an Austrian–British philosopher, academic, and social commentator, is regarded as one of the 20th-century’s most influential philosophers of science.223 Popper’s lecture was titled Of Clouds and Clocks: An Approach to the Problem of Rationality and the Freedom of Man. It was subsequently published as a standalone essay in his 1972 book Objective Knowledge.224 In his lecture and essay, Popper employs clouds and clocks as symbolic labels to describe a spectrum of possibilities between determinism and indeterminism. On the left, Popper describes clouds as “highly irregular, disorderly, and more or less unpredictable.”225 On the right side, Popper describes a precision clock which is “intended to represent physical systems which are regular, orderly, and highly predictable in their behavior.”226 Popper later describes his clocks and clouds as “two prototypes or paradigms…in which we can arrange many kinds of things, and many kinds of systems, between them.”227 ¶ Students in this creative course might ask why we would spend time exploring and discussing Popper-inspired rational and orderly notions of clocks? Alas, shouldn’t we be spending the bulk of our time with our heads in the creative clouds? This is an excellent question, and it’s one for which Popper’s handy clock-clock metaphor might help us briefly explore. But first, (with apologies to Popper), we will need to extend Popper’s deterministic use of clocks to encompass an even wider set of principles and considerations. ¶ For the purposes of this conversation, we will use “clocks” as a big-tent catch for that which is rational, orderly, predictable, or even data-driven. On the side of clocks, we’ll also “glob on” things that are generally structured, evidence-based, or even metric-based, or that which is driven by efficiency, performance, or cost. ¶ So now, let’s go back to the question of “why clocks?” By exploring and gathering clocks, cloud-minded creatives can sometimes apply their cloud-based superpowers more intuitively, enabling them to thoughtfully synthesize, imagine, and “connect the dots.” With this clock-based evidence in mind, creatives can sometimes navigate patterns, challenges, and constraints more tacitly and precisely. ¶ Step into the design studio and you may observe designers and design teams dialogically weighing and exploring clock-and-cloud-based factors—the emotional versus the rational, the costs versus the benefits, the tried and true versus the unknowns. Contrary to popular myths, many high-performing creatives seem to “toggle” between clock-based concerns and cloud-based ones. This weighing of clock and cloud-based concerns oftentimes creates healthy tension. Fortunately, as we’ve explored in previous sections, artists, scientists, engineers, and other creatives have developed tools, methods, and techniques to manage, facilitate, and resolve these tensions. ¶ This notion of clocks can also serve as a springboard for us to further consider notions of form and aesthetics. Across the arts and in related fields, the term aesthetics generally refers to the quality of or perception of form. For instance, in my own field of two-dimensional design, there is a well-established “clock-like” aesthetic or approach that we informally call “the grid.” Grid systems (or “the grid”) were first championed by 20th-century designers such as Josef Müller-Brockmann.228 Grid systems inform everything from web pages to printed books to building facades. For designers, the grid provides just enough rules and structure to keep things cogent. Grids are often “invisible” to the viewer but provide orderly, modular, and systematic options for the designer. It’s likely no surprise that these clock-like aesthetics and approaches were further popularized following the cloudy chaos of World War II. The grid, along with modernist principles such as “form follows function,”229 seemed to dominate 19th- and early- to mid-20th-century aesthetics. These design aesthetics became essential components of the aesthetic movement that came to be known as modernism.230 ¶ In the world of business, these clock-oriented, logic-leaning, Aristotelian set of principles seem to support Theodore Levitt’s paper “Creativity is Not Enough.”231 But in business, as is the case in many other fields, we might likewise assume that clocks alone are not enough. Let’s consider this lofty position by looking right at the clouds.

  20. Clouds: In what Popper called a “commonsense view of things,” he noted that “some natural phenomena…are hard to predict.”232 As we make our way across Popper’s spectrum from left to right, we begin to encounter phenomena that are unorderly, random, sporadic, hard to predict, or simply new. Just as we did with Popper’s clocks, we will likewise expand Popper’s use of clouds to serve as our big tent c-word that broadly encapsulates that which is chaotic or unpredictable. This broad formulation of clouds might generally include the subjective, the random, the emotional, and the relational. ¶ Within this cluster of clouds, we might also encounter identity, taste, style, movements, intuition, conflict, trust, understanding, culture, expression, imagination, and more. In a nod to our c-word section on complexity, we may likewise encounter probability over certainty and intuition over facts. ¶ Here in the clouds, we might ponder notions of beauty, use, and value. Using one classic example, we might ask if the Mona Lisa is “useful”? Does Leonardo da Vinci’s work possess value, and if so, why? Is the Mona Lisa beautiful? How are such notions of beauty determined and by whom? What do you [individually] find beautiful, useful, and worthwhile?233 ¶ As I have noted elsewhere, designers often engage in a mix of clock and cloud-based thinking—designers may “make things to know things” and/or “know things to make things.”234 From prototyping to improvisation, creatives sometimes start in the “messiness” of the clouds. ¶ To make this cloud-based scenario more concrete, let’s consider an audible artifact embedded in a Miles Davis track from 1958. At the outset of Davis’ rendition of “If I Were a Bell,”235 listeners are greeted by a short voiceover clip featuring Davis. In his signature raspy voice, very likely captured in the recording studio, we hear Miles state, “I’ll play it and tell you what it is later.”236 By making this statement, Davis provides listeners with an intellectual clue. In this course, as we grasp tat that clue, we begin to grapple with the (like Davis) finding comfort and confidence in the clouds. This is easier said than done. As a seasoned jazz musician, Davis is, in some ways, stating the obvious—that in jazz, the result is not known until they play. By making this statement, Davis, as a creative leader, also helps foster the group’s openness to discovery.237 But also, for the audience or listener, the line adds intrigue, curiosity, and suspense. ¶ Just as we explored clocks as a big-tent mode of thought, big-tent notions of clouds provide a parallel partner to clocks, one that equally offers a path to “newness.”238 This notion of newness, oftentimes associated with technology, innovation, or change, is explored in a 2007 paper by Debabrata Chattopadhyay and B.N. Srivastava.239 In their paper, the authors describe newness as a concept “applicable in a wide variety of phenomena – strategic, administrative, technical and technological innovations, organisational learning, organisation development and change.”240 But they also note that “Unfortunately, there is inadequate exposition of the very concept of newness in the literature.”241 Despite these views, we might agree that newness usually involves or indicates substantial changes or shifts. In creative work, we oftentimes evaluate notions of newness versus novelty. Like newsness, notions of novelty can indicate the new, but also the unusual. ¶ On another newness-oriented note, in 1953, Alex F. Osborn likewise explored newness-oriented themes when he published Applied Imagination: Principles and Procedures of Creative Problem-Solving.242 Looking back on Osborn’s work many years later, it would seem he hoped to make cloud-oriented thinking accessible. In the Forward to his book, Osborn makes several references to J.P. Guilford, who in 1950 became President of the American Psychological Association. Years before Sir Ken Robinson and other creative education advocates, Osborn noted Guilford’s attempts to bring attention to “education’s appalling neglect of creativity.”243 Furthering Guilford’s argument, Osborn likewise stated, “By and large we have failed to recognize the fact that everybody possesses creative imagination, at least potentially.”244 Osborn also stated, “We have failed to find wide-scale ways to develop this gift of our people.”245 In this latter statement, in part, we encounter at least one raison dêtre for considering (or re-considering) cloud-based thought. ¶ One cloud-oriented concept worthy of creative consideration or even celebration is culture. It is often said that writing about culture is a bit like trying to photograph the wind—but this cloudiness should not prevent us from briefly pondering its potential.

  21. Culture: As one of our big-tent c-words, culture encompasses everything from artifacts and language to behaviors and beliefs, courtesies to cuisine, and more. Unfortunately, looking at culture in the present might also be a bit like being a fish in a tank; it can be hard to see things in the moment, and it’s hard to know you’re in a moment when you’re in the moment. ¶ In 1959, C. P. Snow246 (1905–1980) delivered the Rede Lecture247 at the University of Cambridge. The first part of his lecture was titled “The Two Cultures,” and was later published in book form as The Two Cultures and the Scientific Revolution. “Cultures,” in this case, referred to two intellectual “camps”—the humanities and the sciences. In summary, Snow argued that a deep divide existed between these two cultures. Moreover, Snow viewed this divide as a major barrier to solving complex problems. Just over four years after delivering his lecture, and in response to some of the feedback and criticism he had received, in 1963 Snow published The Two Cultures and A Second Look. The reason for mentioning Snow’s revised text here is twofold. ¶ The first for mentioning Snow here directly concerns his use of the term culture(s). It would seem Snow received a mixed response to his use of the term. As Snow notes, “From the beginning, the phrase ‘the two cultures’ evoked some protests.”248 Interestingly, it was not just cultures that were the target of these objections but also his choice of the number two. To defend his use of culture, Snow pointed readers to two relevant meanings in an attempt to substantiate his position: 1) “intellectual development, development of the mind”249 and 2) “a group of persons living in the same environment, linked by common habits, common assumptions, a common way of life.”250 In the present day, culture might likewise mean many different things, and thus, Snow’s clarifications, as they did then, still now serve to narrow our present meaning and focus. ¶ The second reason for citing The Two Cultures and A Second Look here concerns the aforementioned criticisms Snow received over his choice of two. Here we must give Snow some credit, as on this latter point he seems to have yielded—and in fact it was likely one of the core reasons he revisited the original lecture. In addition to science and the humanities, Snow seems to have yielded to a third group of “intellectual persons in a variety of fields.” While Snow’s description of the fields is a bit dated, it included architecture and “the social arts.”251 As is described further along in this literature review, in the 21st century, the architecture and associated “social arts” increasingly fall under the umbrella of design. ¶ In our limited time, this brief lecture on culture will focus on three highly intertwined “sub-tents” of this big-tent term: artifacts, media, and memory. To start, let’s look at a recent (2026) article written by Nils Gilman. Published in Noema, Gilman’s article grapples with emerging technologies such as AI and posits what he describes as “the judgment economy.”252 While we should always take any broad prescriptions or predictions around technology or the economy with a grain of salt—we might also posit Gilman’s “judgment economy” provocation and use it as a springboard for timely discourses around Snow’s previously mentioned definitions of culture(s). Akin to what we’ve explored in our c-word sections on currency, complexity, and craft, Gilman suggests that “value will accrue to those who can exercise sound judgment under stress and conditions of uncertainty.”253 Going further, Gilman states, “The currency [emphasis added] is trust, influence and the reliability of a decision [emphasis added].”254 ¶ As creators, we understand that the decisions we make can be shaped and informed by a whole countenance-evaluation-minded set of clock and cloud-oriented factors. When we consider Gilman’s arguments around a judgment-based economy—those with a mix of c-word skills may be uniquely positioned to participate and lead. In support of this, Gilman also seems to advocate for a renewed exposure to history, culture, and the liberal arts. ¶ With Gilman’s framing in mind, and for the purposes of this course, I might suggest that we briefly look back to ancient Roman mythology as we seek to understand culture-oriented ideas. To do so, we might posit Janus, the two-faced Roman deity. In ancient mythology, Janus was known as the Roman god of beginnings, transitions, gates, and endings.255 Janus was typically depicted with two faces, one looking toward the past and one toward the future. Thus, as we posit culture, Janus serves to remind us of our unique human ability not only to look towards the past, but perhaps even more powerfully, to imagine the future. This ability to simultaneously ponder the past and prefigure the future is one of our core creative and designerly superpowers. ¶ In his 2019 book The Janus Face of Ideas, the American philosopher and academic Burton Porter grapples with our cultural, philosophical, and intellectual histories in a nuanced tug-of-war style. While some might find Porter’s occasional lack of a clear stance on various issues frustrating, as we consider notions of culture, the “Janus Face” might likewise help us see both (or many) sides of a story. In describing Janus as a symbolic reference point for the book, Porter notes that, “Janus is two-faced, not from hypocrisy or insincerity but because of reflection. He looks at both sides of the question.”256 ¶ But what does all of this have to do with culture? In his book, Porter, while not explicitly pointing to culture, seems to be advocating for contemplation. Porter states, “This is not a book for specialists but for those interested in ideas, [emphasis added] in the life of the mind.”257 If students in this course agree, I might reason that if one is interested in ideas, one is a priori interested in culture, and if one is interested in culture, one is likely interested in ideas. Artifacts, when viewed in this context, are just different formulations of cultural ideas. ¶ In the 21st century, we are surrounded by, if not inundated with, media, messages, culture, and ideas. Thus, there is tremendous value in exploring and understanding the life of ideas. Beyond art and design, notions of culture can inform everything from media, politics, entertainment, technology, marketing, branding,258|259 and more. ¶ While one could point to countless examples of culture as a creative catalyst, a recent book co-authored by a pair of designerly and musical minds seems timely and fitting. In 2021, Panos A. Panay and R. Michael Hendrix’s 2021 authored Two Beats Ahead: What Musical Minds Teach Us About Innovation. The book provides an apt reference point because it attempts to directly correlate a culturally informed “musical mind” to one concerned with newness, culture and innovation. In their book, and somewhat akin to this list, Panay and Hendrix provide a musically informed mix of creative course skills and traits. These include but are not limited to listening, remixing, reinvention, and improvisation. To do so, the authors provide “an ongoing dialogue” that attempts to share and instill a “musical mindset.”260 ¶ Paney and Hendrix note in their Prelude—that “this isn’t a how-to manual.”261 Likewise, An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course sacrifices the technical or prescriptive for broad-brush creative properties and mindsets. In this way, creatives in this course may likewise ponder a “framework of seeing and responding to a dynamic world.”262

  22. Change: This list-maker has noted a somewhat strange occurrence over the past twenty-five or so years. Architects, designers, and other creative types are increasingly viewed as or turned to as stewards of change. Thus, in this creative course, change may be another relevant big-tent c-word worthy of brief exploration and consideration. Change has various meanings and applications that have evolved over many millennia. But if contemporary creatives are increasingly asked to explore and lead change, we might briefly ask how and why? ¶ In 2014, Maria Giudice and Christopher Ireland published Rise of the DEO: Leadership by Design. “DEO” in this case stands for “Design Executive Officer.” Early in the book, Giudice and Ireland address the most obvious question. Why are designers well-suited to lead change? As the authors themselves acknowledge, “Proposing design-inspired leadership as the answer may sound delusional to some, like a zealous art teacher attacking poverty with a new color palette.”263 But the authors then assert that “design leaders usually possess characteristics, behaviors, and mindsets that enable them to excel in unpredictable, fast-moving, and value-charged conditions.”264 In other words, contemporary designers are adept at managing and, when appropriate, facilitating change. The first chapter is, in fact, titled “Change Agent.” The authors follow through with countless statistics, methods, and examples. ¶ As it turns out, some of the most oft-cited scholarly definitions of design are, in fact, inextricably connected to notions of change. Perhaps the most frequently cited of these change-oriented definitions comes from Herbert Simon (1916–2001), a Nobel laureate and polymath. In his 1969 book, The Sciences of the Artificial, Simon famously stated, “Everyone designs who devises courses of action aimed at changing existing situations into preferred ones.”265 With Simon’s definition in mind, the notion of a designer, and those who design, becomes both extremely expansive and subjective. This, in part, lies in Simon’s subjective use of preferred. Oddly enough, the expansiveness of design is a less subjective truth than any notion of what is preferred. As we will see in An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains, we explore this expansive quality of design in the 21st century and, more importantly, reveal how design has become a way of thinking, doing, and knowing. We will grapple with design as a competency and literacy for all, and a professional “leveled-up” version of design for architects and other design professionals. ¶ Some designers and scholars seemed to have foreseen some of the shifts approaching the design profession. This is evidenced by a whole host of recent activity, scholarship, and practice at the intersection of leadership, facilitation, collaboration, design, and change. For instance, in 2004, designer Bruce Mau launched a traveling exhibition and book titled Massive Change. Seeing that most humans are now surrounded by the artificial, or that which is designed, Mau noted that “Design is evolving from its position of relative insignificance within business (and the larger envelope of nature), to become the biggest project of all.”266 A few years later, Tim Brown of the design consultancy IDEO published Change by Design, which, in part, interrogated myth-like notions of creative “innovation” by providing concrete design-based strategies, processes, and approaches as more productive alternatives. As Brown stated in his book, “Individuals, teams, and organizations that have mastered the mental matrix of design thinking share a basic attitude of experimentation.”267 Lastly, and more recently (in 2025), Sara Gry Striegler and Julie Hjort published Navigating Societal Change Through Design. Much like our brief journey across clock and cloud-based mindsets, Gry and Hjort demonstrate an openness to grappling with the multifaceted tension(s) that surface at the intersection of design and change. The authors seem to embrace this dialogic position. In one example, they state, “Another mindset tension we personally try to balance throughout the book is the tension between a speculative and a rational mindset.”268 ¶ As our many footnotes suggest, creativity and design are not only ways of making but also pathways for discovery, newness, exploration, and change. One additional, if not obvious, area that seems to reside at the intersection of creativity and change is education. One recent book that explores this intersection directly is José Antonio Bowen’s 2021 book, Teaching Change. For students in this course, Bowen’s argument may seem obvious: as the world changes, we cannot continue to teach and learn in the same exact way(s). But this, of course, overly simplifies the issue. Bowen does not prescribe specific changes to education as much as he advocates for those charged with teaching and learning to explore notions of change itself. In support of this, Bowen states, “As students, technology, and the economy have changed, the ability to adapt, change, and self-direct future learning has only become more important.”269 Much like our earlier c-word explorations of context versus content, part of what Bowen is attempting to explore is how we might, over time, consider educational approaches that shift away from “content” (what to think) towards “process” how to think. ¶ From design to education and more, big-tent notions of change can productively foster creative and analytical perspectives alike. The pre-Socratic Greek philosopher Heraclitus of Ephesus270 (c. 535 – 475 BCE) believed that the universe was in a state of constant motion and change, while Parmenides of Elea271 (c. 515 – 450 BCE) believed the opposite, that change is impossible. Plato, Aristotle, and many philosophers who followed, in part, attempted to bridge the gap between the “everything changes” and “nothing changes” debate. Likewise, whatever your views on change may be, I encourage you, as part of this creative course, to simultaneously explore both the traditions you uphold and the changes you embrace. Like the ancient philosophers before you, this exploration will most certainly inform and shape your creative practice.

With utmost gratitude to the many voices cited and referenced. First published 18 Apr 2026. Last updated 1 Oct 2026. Please send edits, corrections, and suggestions to this address.


Footnotes

  1. Florida, Richard. The Rise of the Creative Class. Basic Books, 2002, p. ix. ↩︎
  2. Ibid. ↩︎
  3. Ibid. ↩︎
  4. Han, Shoen. “Wait, Go Back,” Wired, November–December 2024, p. 16. ↩︎
  5. Han, Shoen. “About,” Shoen Han, accessed 2024, https://sheonhan.net/about/. ↩︎
  6. In 1987, for instance, David Bohm and F. David Peat published Science, Order, and Creativity: A Dramatic New Look at the Creative Roots of Science and Life. Bohm and Peat believed that science has become fragmentary and that dialogue and creativity could unlock new ways of seeing the world. As the authors stated, “It is important to extend creativity beyond the spheres in which it is traditionally supposed to lie” (p. 266). See: Bohm, David and F. David Peat. Science, Order, and Creativity. Bantam Books, 1987. ↩︎
  7. Robinson, Ken, and Lou Aronica. Creative Schools. Viking, 2015, pp. 128-157. ↩︎
  8. Thornhill-Miller et al. “Creativity, Critical Thinking, Communication, and Collaboration: Assessment, Certification, and Promotion of 21st Century Skills for the Future of Work and Education.” Journal of Intelligence, 11(3), 54 (2023). ↩︎
  9. See: Bishop, Wendy and David Starkey. Keywords in Creative Writing. Utah State University Press, 2006, p. vii. ↩︎
  10. “Capabilities for life framework.” The RSA, https://www.thersa.org/design-for-life/capabilities-for-life/capabilities-for-life-framework/. ↩︎
  11. Loc. cit., p. 1. ↩︎
  12. See: Cagan, Jonathan, and Craig M. Vogel. Creating Breakthrough Products. Prentice Hall, 2002, p. 144. ↩︎
  13. See also the c-word section on Convergence. ↩︎
  14. Shea, Danny. “Oprah Gives Stanford Grads Books, Calls Class To Service,” Huffpost, last modified Dec 6, 2017, https://www.huffpost.com/entry/oprah-gives-stanford-grad_n_107282. ↩︎
  15. See: Martin, Colette, and Kristi Hedges. “Creativity Is The New Black,” Forbes, last modified Aug 9, 2011, https://www.forbes.com/sites/work-in-progress/2010/07/16/creativity-is-the-new-black/. ↩︎
  16. “20th CEO Survey,” PWC, accessed August 6, 2024, https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/ceo-survey/2017/deep-dives/ceo-survey-global-talent.pdf. ↩︎
  17. Storey, Veda C. et al. “The design of human-artificial intelligence systems in decision sciences: A look back and directions forward,” Decision Support Systems 182 (July 2024), https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dss.2024.114230. ↩︎
  18. Ibid., p. 1. ↩︎
  19. Ibid., pp. 5–6. ↩︎
  20. This “taxonomy of eight C’s” was originally published in 2023. They include composition, complexity, creativity, confidence, controls, conscience, certification, and contribution.” See: Alan Hevner and Veda Storey, “Research Challenges for the Design of Human-Artificial Intelligence Systems (HAIS),” ACM Transactions on Management Information Systems 14, no. 1 (2023), https://doi.org/10.1145/3549547. ↩︎
  21. The phrase “combinatory play” is attributed to Albert Einstein and appears in his book Ideas and Opinions, first published in 1954. See: Einstein, Albert. Ideas and Opinions. Crown Publishing, [1954] 1995), 24. ↩︎
  22. “Terrain” seems like a fitting word choice here, but “properties” could also be used. In regard to the latter term, Derek Jones et al., incorporate and thus elevate “properties” in the title of their 2025 open-access volume. See: Studio Properties: A field guide to design education. See: Jones, Derek et al. Studio Properties. Bloomsbury, 2025. ↩︎
  23. Imrie, Rob, and Kim Kullman. “Designing with Care and Caring with Design.” in Care and Design: Bodies, Buildings, Cities, edited by Charlotte Bates, Rob Imrie, and Kim Kullman, John Wiley & Sons, 2016, pp. 1–17. Wiley Online Library, https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119053484.ch1
    . ↩︎
  24. See: “Front Matter.” in Care and Design: Bodies, Buildings, Cities, edited by Charlotte Bates, Rob Imrie, and Kim Kullman, John Wiley & Sons, 2016, p. xiii. Wiley Online Library, https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119053484.ch1. ↩︎
  25. Ibid. ↩︎
  26. As but one example of this, Seth Johnson, who, at the time of this c-word list, serves as Design Director at IBM’s Chief Data Office, traces his corporate design leadership back to his time as an AIGA chapter volunteer and treats his design team members at IBM more like volunteers. In 2026, Johnson recounted these perspectives and experiences on the AIGA Design Podcast. See: “Seth Johnson on Earning the Right to Change Things.” AIGA Design Podcast, June 2, 2026, Available at: https://www.aiga.org/aiga-design-podcast. , ↩︎
  27. Care in education might be the opposite of what Paolo Freire famously described as the “banking model” of education—an approach that treats students as containers or receptacles of knowledge. Freire criticized the banking model of education for how it (among other reasons) stifles creativity. See: Freire, Paulo. Pedagogy of the Oppressed. 1968. ↩︎
  28. Along these lines, a more recent figure who emerged as an advocate for creativity in education was Ken Robinson. Robinson’s 2006 Ted Talk on creativity and education has been viewed over 78 million times. [Sir] Robinson was knighted in 2003 by Queen Elizabeth II for his services to the arts. ↩︎
  29. See, for instance, Luis Rico-Gutierrez’s (Dean of Design at Iowa State) 2023 lecture on design and care. Available at: Rico-Gutierrez, Luis. “I+E Day Culture of Care Presentation.” YouTube, uploaded by Iowa State College of Design, 7 Mar 2023, https://youtu.be/P5wyuS9CKf4. ↩︎
  30. The first five Cs: Competence, Connection, Character, Confidence, and Caring (or compassion) seem to have been first published in 2000. See: Lerner, Richard M., et. al. “Toward a Science for and of the People: Promoting Civil Society Through the Application of Developmental Science.” Child Development, vol. 71, no. 1, 2000, pp. 11-20, https://www.jstor.org/stable/1132212. ↩︎
  31. The sixth C, “Contribution,” appears to have been added by 2005. “Lerner and colleagues have contended that such exemplary positive youth development (PYD) results in the emergence in an adolescent’s life of a sixth C, contribution to self, family, community, and ultimately, civil society” (p. 96). From: King, Pamela E., et. al. “Thriving in Adolescence: The Voices of Youth-Serving Practitioners, Parents, and Early and Late Adolescents.” Journal of Early Adolescence, vol. 25, no. 1, 2005, pp. 94-112, https://doi.org/10.1177/02724316042724. ↩︎
  32. See: James, Ian. “Tekhne.” Oxford Research Encyclopedias, 25 February 2019, https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190201098.013.121. ↩︎
  33. Barney, Rachel. “Tanner Lectures on Human Values with Rachel Barney: Lecture I – The End of Craft.” YouTube, uploaded by UC Berkeley Events, 4 May 2024, https://youtu.be/chDcuJmqBjc. ↩︎
  34. Research is also considered a craft. As a poorly performing undergraduate design student, one of my professors suggested that I pick up a copy of Wayne C. Booth et al.’s The Craft of Research. Now in its fifth edition, this book has helped scores of students of all ages discern the art of choosing research topics, building sound arguments, and more. The book has sold over a million copies. ↩︎
  35. Sennett, Richard. The Craftsman. Yale University Press, 2008, p. 289. ↩︎
  36. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  37. Ibid., p. 290. ↩︎
  38. This lineage of craft and design is briefly explored in my 2025 motion graphics film Towards a Dynamic Discipline of Design, which uses the hand-axe as an ancient reference point. See: Vlahos, Dan, and Steven Cotroneo. “Towards a Dynamic Discipline of Design” in Edited Conference Proceedings of the 2025 Motion Design Education Summit, June 19-21, 2025: edited by Jessica Barness et al., MODE Society, 2025, pp. 169-186. ↩︎
  39. Students who wish to delve deeper into such questions may consider Matthew Niermann’s 2021 book The Humble Creative. See: Niermann, Matthew. The Humble Creative. Wipf & Stock, 2021. ↩︎
  40. Shales, Ezra. The Shape of Craft. Reaktion Books, 2017, p. 30. ↩︎
  41. Elbow, Peter. Writing Without Teachers. 2nd ed. Oxford University Press, [1973] 1998, p. 55.
    ↩︎
  42. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  43. Koren, Leonard. Arranging Things. Stone Bridge Press, 2003, p. 13. ↩︎
  44. Ibid., 109. ↩︎
  45. Levine, Caroline. Forms. Princeton University Press, 2015, p. 2. ↩︎
  46. Ibid., p. 3. ↩︎
  47. See: “Affordance.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 30 Mar 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affordance. ↩︎
  48. In the visual arts, this is often referred to as the “picture plane.” See: “Picture plane.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 19 Feb 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Picture_plane. ↩︎
  49. In 2025, Patrik Hübner published The Generative Mind, a timely and cogent exploration of all things generative. In the foreword, written by the pioneering generative artist Frieder Nake, Nake states, “What made generative aesthetics unique was its shift of focus from the finished product to the process of creation itself” (p. ii). Beyond generative thinking and making, Hübner explores notions of adaptability, meaning, collaboration, systems thinking, and more. See: Hübner, Patrik, The Generative Mind: A New Approach to Creative Thinking, Niggli, 2025. ↩︎
  50. For more on systematic structure, grids, and composition in visual design, see Shaping Visual Structures by Carla Viviana Cordova. See: Cordova, Carla Viviana. Shaping Visual Structures: The Art of Composition, Movement and Space in Graphic Design. BIS, 2025, p. 59–71. ↩︎
  51. “Marcel Duchamp.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 3 Aug 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marcel_Duchamp. ↩︎
  52. See for instance: deWaard, Andrew. Derivative Media. University of California Press, 2025. ↩︎
  53. Huber, Sarah, editor. Creative Formats Across Media and Disciplines: Assignments Beyond the Essay. Set Margins, 2026, pp. 60–95. ↩︎
  54. Nez, Alyssa A. “Indigenous Knowledge: Learning to Tell Stories from Native Americans and First Nations Peoples” Creative Formats Across Media and Disciplines: Assignments Beyond the Essay, edited by Editor Sarah Huber, Set Margins, 2026, pp. 78–87. ↩︎
  55. Ibid., 78. ↩︎
  56. Ibid. ↩︎
  57. In particular, Nez highlights and cites Gustav Freytag. ↩︎
  58. Veglahn, Sara. “Making Poems: Exploring Ekphrasis and Text/Image Poetics.” Creative Formats Across Media and Disciplines: Assignments Beyond the Essay, edited by Editor Sarah Huber, Set Margins, 2026, pp. 90–94. ↩︎
  59. See: “Ekphrasis.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 16 Aug 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ekphrasis. ↩︎
  60. Obrist, Hans Ulrich. Ways of Curating. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2014, p. 1. ↩︎
  61. Ibid., p. 1. ↩︎
  62. Ibid., p. 10. ↩︎
  63. “The psychological research on curiosity starts in the second half of the 20th century. A pervasive topic in the psychology literature has been the motivational nature of curiosity.” From: Subaşı, Ahmet. “A Dynamic Systems Theory of epistemic curiosity.” New Ideas in Psychology, vol. 54, 2019, p. 9, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.newideapsych.2018.12.003. ↩︎
  64. Powell, Christopher et al. “Deconstructing intellectual curiosity.” Personality and Individual Differences, vol. 95, 2016, pp. 147-151, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.paid.2016.02.037. ↩︎
  65. Ibid, p. 147. ↩︎
  66. Hagtvedt, Lydia Paine et al. “Curiosity made the cat more creative: Specific curiosity as a driver of
    creativity.” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, vol. 150, 2019, pp. 1-13, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.obhdp.2018.10.007. ↩︎
  67. Ibid., p. 1. ↩︎
  68. The term “wicked problem” was coined by the design and planning theorists Horst Rittel and Melvin Webber in 1973. They introduced the concept in their paper, “Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning,” to describe complex social and planning problems that cannot be solved in a traditional, linear way. See: Rittel, H.W.J., and M.M. Webber. “Dilemmas in a general theory of planning.” Policy Sci. vol. 4, 1973, 155–169. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01405730. ↩︎
  69. Loc. cit., p. 2. ↩︎
  70. Loc. cit., p. 3. ↩︎
  71. This reflexive perspective is often referred to as reflective practice and is most commonly associated with Donald Schön and his 1983 book, The Reflective Practitioner. Notions of reflective practice are also described or alluded to in the writings of German philosopher Immanuel Kant, the American philosopher John Dewey, and others. ↩︎
  72. In 2025, Lefteris Heretakis penned a brief memo on commitment as it relates to design and creative work. See: Heretakis, Lefteris. “The Discipline of Commitment in Design Education.” The New Art School, 2025, https://newartschool.education/2025/10/08/the-discipline-of-commitment-in-design-education/. ↩︎
  73. Calvino’s lecture notes were first published [in English] in 1988. See: “Six Memos for the Next Millennium,” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 1 Nov 2024, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Six_Memos_for_the_Next_Millennium. ↩︎
  74. In my introductory design classes, I explore aesthetic notions of consistency by assigning students a pattern-making exercise. The project asks students to compose three complementary patterns using two colors. The students are challenged to imagine their three compositions plotted along a spectrum, with consistency (or “unity” and/or “constants”) on one end and variety (and/or “variables”) on the other. When students bring in the completed assignment, I ask them to note their intended spectrum position on the back of their work, and then exchange their three solutions with another student. Students then visually “plot” where they think the other student’s solution falls across the spectrum. On a large wall, I place the word “consistency” on the far left and “variety” on the far right. This assignment was substantially inspired by the “Unity and Variety” section of the late Majorie Elliot Bevlin’s out-of-print book Design Through Discovery. See: Bevlin, Marjorie Elliot. Design Through Discovery. 6th ed., Harcourt Brace, 1993, pp. 123–139. ↩︎
  75. See “Dialogic” in An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains. ↩︎
  76. See “Discursivity” in An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains. ↩︎
  77. There are countless books on habits, productivity, and creativity. One of the most prominent might be Stephen R. Covey’s The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People. Upon Covey’s death in 2012, the book had sold more than 20 million copies. See: “The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 22 Oct 2024, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_7_Habits_of_Highly_Effective_People. ↩︎
  78. Calvino, Italo. Italo Calvino: Letters, 1941–1985. Princeton University Press, 2013, pp. 179-180. ↩︎
  79. The term flow, coined by Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi in the 1970s, was used to describe the phenomenon of losing one’s sense of time and experiencing increased focus during deep creative work. The term first appeared in Csikszentmihalyi’s 1975 book Beyond Boredom and Anxiety. It’s no surprise that Csikszentmihalyi is often called the “father of flow.” ↩︎
  80. Dong, Andy. “The enactment of design through language.” Design Studies, 28 (2007), p. 5. ↩︎
  81. Zhang, Jiajie. The Cognitive Revolution: How AI is Reorganizing Intelligence, Expertise, and Institutions. Open Intelligence Press, 2026, p. 41. ↩︎
  82. Ibid. ↩︎
  83. Ibid. ↩︎
  84. See: “Dynamism” in An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains. ↩︎
  85. Defila, Rico, and Antonietta Di Giulio. “Integrating knowledge: Challenges raised by the ‘Inventory of Synthesis.’” Futures, vol. 65, 2015, pp. 123–135. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.futures.2014.10.013 ↩︎
  86. Ibid. ↩︎
  87. Krott, M. (1996). Interdisziplinarita¨ t im Netz der Disziplinen. In P. Balsiger, R. Defila, & A. Di Giulio (Eds.), O¨ kologie und Interdisziplinarita¨t – eine Beziehung mit Zukunft? Wissenschaftsforschung zur Verbesserung der fachu¨bergreifenden Zusammenarbeit (pp. 87–97). Basel: Birkhäuser. ↩︎
  88. See: “Remembering William ‘Bill’ J. Hannon Jr.” Design Management Institute, http://www.dmi.org/?page=BillHannon. ↩︎
  89. Dong, p. 6. ↩︎
  90. Ibid., p. 15. ↩︎
  91. Denzin, Norman K., et al., editors. The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research. 6th ed., SAGE Publications, 2023. ↩︎
  92. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  93. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  94. “Bricolage.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 7 Sep 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bricolage.  ↩︎
  95. This list maker describes this integrative process as “design-centered design.” See: “Dynamism” in An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains. ↩︎
  96. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  97. Cross, 1982. ↩︎
  98. See: “Dynamism” in An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains. ↩︎
  99. Patton, M.Q. “Video Review of Measuring Education: Memoir.” Education Review, vol. 31, Sept. 2024, https://doi.org/10.14507/er.v31.3871. ↩︎
  100. “Robert E. Stake.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 1 Jul 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_E._Stake. ↩︎
  101. Mathison, Sandra. “Countenance Model of Evaluation.” Encyclopedia of Evaluation, SAGE Publications, 2004. ↩︎
  102. Ibid. ↩︎
  103. Stake, Robert. (1967) “The countenance of educational evaluation.” Teachers College Record, 68(7), pp. 523-530. ↩︎
  104. Ibid. ↩︎
  105. Zelenko, Darcy, et al. “Design Quality Housing Assessment Methodology: Supporting Heuristics with Evidence-Based Decision-Making.” CAAD Futures 2025 – Catalytic Interfaces: Conference Proceedings, edited by Kristof Crolla, et al., University of Hong Kong, 2025, pp. 538. ↩︎
  106. Lissack, Michael. “Understanding Is a Design Problem: Cognizing from a Designerly Thinking Perspective. Part 1.” She Ji: The Journal of Design, Economics, and Innovation, vol. 5, no. 3, 2019, p. 233. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sheji.2019.07.002. ↩︎
  107. Ibid. ↩︎
  108. Zelenko, p. 538. ↩︎
  109. Ibid. ↩︎
  110. “Understanding by Design.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 6 May 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Understanding_by_Design. ↩︎
  111. Wiggins, Grant, and Jay McTighe. Understanding by Design. 2nd ed., Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development, 2005, Back cover. ↩︎
  112. See: “Dynamism” in An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains, https://danvlahos.com/work/an-incomplete-list-of-d-words-for-designerly-domains/#dynamism. ↩︎
  113. See “Discovery” in An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains, https://danvlahos.com/work/an-incomplete-list-of-d-words-for-designerly-domains/#discovery ↩︎
  114. Centola, Damon. Goodthink: The New Science of Collective Intelligence. The MIT Press, 2026, p. 72. ↩︎
  115. Ibid. ↩︎
  116. Wright, Frank Lloyd. The Natural House. Horizon Press, 1954, p. 135. ↩︎
  117. Oech, Roger von. A Kick in the Seat of the Pants, Harper, 1986, p. 91. ↩︎
  118. Ibid., p. 110. ↩︎
  119. Wedge, Carole. “Leading Change: An Exploratory Process.” EDUCAUSE Review, vol. 41, no. 6, Nov.–Dec. 2006, pp. 10–11. https://er.educause.edu/articles/2006/12/leading-change-an-exploratory-process. ↩︎
  120. Ibid. ↩︎
  121. See: Resnick, Elizabeth. Design for Communication: Conceptual Graphic Design Basics. Wiley, 2004, p. 121. ↩︎
  122. I’ll note that every semester, I have my students watch Milton Glaser Draws & Lectures, a five-minute film from 2009. The film (directed by Chris Coy) is a single-take overhead shot of Glaser drawing Shakespeare while talking about drawing. The film starts with Glaser saying, “For me, drawing has always been the most fundamental way of engaging with the world.” See: Coy, Chris. “Milton Glaser Draws & Lectures.” Vimeo, uploaded by C Coy, 9 Oct 2009, https://vimeo.com/6986303. ↩︎
  123. See also “Drawing” in An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains. ↩︎
  124. See: “Visible Thinking.” Project Zero, Harvard Graduate School of Education: https://pz.harvard.edu/projects/visible-thinking. ↩︎
  125. Levitt, Theodore. “Creativity Is Not Enough,” Harvard Business Review, August (2022) [1963]. ↩︎
  126. Ibid., p. 3. ↩︎
  127. Kolko, Jon. “Novelty ≠ Creativity: The Problem of Psychological Measurement in Design Practice and Education.” Design Issues, vol. 42, no. 2, Spring 2026, p. 4, https://doi.org/10.1162/DESI.a.727. ↩︎
  128. Florida, Richard. The Rise of the Creative Class. Basic Books, 2002, pp. 267–282. ↩︎
  129. Unfortunately, the outcomes of, or critical response to, some creative works are not always evident immediately or even within short time periods. Also, outcomes, reactions, and critical perspectives can unexpectedly shift in a positive or negative direction over long periods of time. Thus, evaluations of some environments, creative works, and experiences may require flexibility and sustained effort. See also: c-word sections on clocks, complexity, and clouds. ↩︎
  130. See: Sheridan, Kimberly M. et al. Studio Thinking 3, Teachers College Press, 2022, p. 4. ↩︎
  131. This assumption is shared by Michael Craig-Martin in his 2015 book On Being an Artist. Craig-Martin notes that while many of the non-art major classmates he met in Josef Albers’ rigorous color course at Yale may not have become artists, he “always assumed that their direct experience with art-making led them years later to become the best of America’s new committed and sophisticated collectors of contemporary art.” See: Craig-Martin, Michael. On Being an Artist. Art/Books, 2015, p. 37. ↩︎
  132. See: Kleon, Austin. Show Your Work!: 10 Ways to Share Your Creativity and Get Discovered, Workman Publishing, 2014. ↩︎
  133. Serig, Dan. “Research Review.” Teaching Artist Journal, 10(2), 2012, p. 121, https://doi.org/10.1080/15411796.2012.658320. ↩︎
  134. In his highly influential 1993 paper, “Research in Art and Design,” Sir Christopher Frayling provided a framework to understand how research interacts with the creative process in academic and professional contexts, categorizing such research into three distinct types. See: Frayling, Christopher. “Research in Art and Design.” Royal College of Art Research Papers. 1(1), (1993/4), pp. 1-5. ↩︎
  135. Multiple Intelligence (MI) theory was pioneered by the American cognitive psychologist and author Howard Gardner. Gardner’s MI theory was first presented in his 1983 book Frames of Mind: The Theory of Multiple Intelligences. His ideas were further developed, extended, and refined in subsequent publications over many years: See Gordon, Lynn Melby. “Howard Gardner.” Britannica, 09 Oct. 2024, https://www.britannica.com/biography/Howard-Gardner. ↩︎
  136. “Multihyphenate,” Harvard Design Magazine, accessed December 19, 2024, https://www.harvarddesignmagazine.org/issues/multihyphenate/. ↩︎
  137. Canty, Sean, Zeina Koreitem, and John May, “Editors’ Letter: Multihyphenation,” Harvard Design Magazine 51, (F/W 2023): p. 15. ↩︎
  138. See: “T-shaped skills,” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 2 Jan 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T-shaped_skills. ↩︎
  139. One must credit Richard Saul Wurman, Harry Marks, and Frank Stanton for having the vision to connect interlinked notions of technology, entertainment, and design. As early as 1984, they founded the now-familiar TED conference. See: “TED (conference).” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 2 Nov 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TED_(conference). ↩︎
  140. Ottino, Julio Mario, and Bruce Mau. The Nexus. MIT Press, 2022. ↩︎
  141. Edwards, David. Artscience. Harvard University Press, 2010. ↩︎
  142. Much of this integrative interest began after reading Roger Martin’s 2009 book The Opposable Mind. See: Martin, Roger. The Opposable Mind. Harvard Business School Publishing, 2009. ↩︎
  143. Phillip A. Sharp et al., The Third Revolution: The Convergence of the Life Sciences, Physical Sciences, and Engineering (Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 2011). ↩︎
  144. Ibid. ↩︎
  145. See, for instance, the emergence of the “Artist Corporation,” a new type of company designed for creative people. More at: https://www.artistcorporations.com. ↩︎
  146. Cagan, Jonathan, and Craig M. Vogel. Creating Breakthrough Products. Prentice Hall, 2002, p. 140. ↩︎
  147. Ibid., p. 142. ↩︎
  148. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  149. Ibid., p. 138. ↩︎
  150. Ibid., p. 143. ↩︎
  151. Here, I might propose extending Nigel Cross’ notion of “Designerly ways of knowing,” to something akin to “designerly ways of leading,” which may require figures with a mix of design, research, change management, transformation, vision alignment, communication strategy, and more. See: Cross, Nigel. “Designerly ways of knowing.” Design Studies, vol. 3, no. 4, Oct 1982, pp. 221-227. https://doi.org/10.1016/0142-694X(82)90040-0. ↩︎
  152. Students further interested in designful organizations and concerns might check out Marty Neumeier’s 2009 book The Designful Company. See: Neumeier, Marty. The Designful Company. New Riders, 2009. ↩︎
  153. See: “Divergence” in An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains. ↩︎
  154. This is also chronicled in Gowan’s 2012 book Shared Vision: The Second American Bauhaus. Gowan studied at Southern Illinois University Carbondale and was present when Fuller gave his first lecture as a research professor in 1959. See: Gowan, Al. Shared Vision: The Second American Bauhaus. Merrimack Media, 2012, p. x. ↩︎
  155. Fuller, Buckminster. Operating Manual for Spaceship Earth. Southern Illinois University Press, 1969, p. 10. ↩︎
  156. Ibid., p. 12. ↩︎
  157. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  158. See: “Building information modeling.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 27 Nov 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Building_information_modeling. ↩︎
  159. Jones, Derek, et al. Studio Properties. Bloomsbury, 2025, p. 79. OA: https://doi.org/10.5040/9781350407480. ↩︎
  160. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  161. Berkun, Scott, and Bryan Zug. Why Design is So Hard. Berkun Media, 2024, p. 20. ↩︎
  162. Ibid., p. 21. ↩︎
  163. Part of my H-oriented interest stems from my research into H. H. Richardson, one of the early designerly giants of American architecture. Richardson seems to have set a sort of standard for how one could live a life in design. In Living Architecture, James F. O’Gorman writes that by 1885, Richardson “owned a national reputation as the single most admired and emulated architect in America” (p. 21). O’Gorman also notes that Richardson, “produced buildings that are, ultimately, ahistorically superb” (p.189). See: O’Gorman, James. Living Architecture: A Biography of H. H. Richardson. Simon & Schuster Editions, 1997. ↩︎
  164. Coincidentally, this list maker designed the “Hi” icon for Harvard Innovation Labs, which could also represent “Human intelligence.” ↩︎
  165. In one of this list-maker’s creative courses, he has students watch video footage of well-known creatives receiving critical feedback, and then we discuss how they respond. One example is a video of Steve Jobs at the 1997 Worldwide Developers Conference. See: “Steve Jobs Insult Response.” YouTube, uploaded by Jonathan Field, 1 Dec 2016, https://youtu.be/oeqPrUmVz-o. ↩︎
  166. This essay appears to have been posted to Microsoft’s website as a memo from Gates on January 3, 1996. I was able to locate a screenshot, but I am currently unable to verify its authenticity. ↩︎
  167. The phrase “content is king” appears in a 1978 issue (p. 103) of The 1978 Photographer’s Market published by Writer’s Digest Books. The entry cites Click and Baird’s book Magazine Editing and Production as the original source. ↩︎
  168. Nachmanovich, Stephen. The Art of Is. New World Library, 2019, p. 101. ↩︎
  169. Just as I was drafting this list, Alicia Juarrero published a 174-page volume titled Why Context Matters. Drawing on historical and philosophical analysis, Juarrero explores these themes in detail. See: Juarrero, Alicia. Why Context Matters. Imprint Academic (Ips), 2025. ↩︎
  170. Context-dependence is referenced, examined, and discussed throughout Juarrero’s book. At the outset, the author notes that, “Context-dependence […] was dismissed from reality and epistemology because interdependence and interconnectedness had no purchase in philosophy or science” (p. 5). ↩︎
  171. Millman, Debbie. “Is the World Getting Uglier?” Time, 18 Aug. 2026, time.com/article/2026/08/18/is-the-world-getting-uglier/. ↩︎
  172. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  173. Li, Wayne K. Design Empathy and Contextual Awareness. Laurence King, 2025, p. 176. ↩︎
  174. Li defines being contextually aware as “having a sensitivity toward the connections between customer trends, the production landscape, culture, and technology” (p. 176). ↩︎
  175. With some of these issues in mind, this list-maker is intrigued by Central Saint Martins, University of the Arts London’s recent proposal to reorganize the College into three somewhat contextual “Schools of Thought”—a C School (Culture), an S School (Systems) and an M School (Material). See: Ramanathan, Rathna. “Foundations, Not Hierarchies: Re:designing Creative Education for Future Resilience.” C+S+M, CSM Papers, Issue 1, Autumn, 2025, https://www.arts.ac.uk/colleges/central-saint-martins/about-us/schools-of-thought. ↩︎
  176. Bracher, Todd. Design in Context. Compendium Editions, 2024, p. 45 ↩︎
  177. Ibid. ↩︎
  178. Here, I should note that I first encountered the term “contextual research” during my graduate studies at the Dynamic Media Institute (DMI) at Massachusetts College of Art and Design, where it is tightly interwoven with project- and problem-based methodologies. A somewhat narrower use of the term has gained some popularity in fields such as Human-Computer Interaction and User Experience Design. “Contextual research” seems to have been more fully developed in the mid-1990s by Karen Holtzblatt and Hugh Beyerand. See: Duda, Sabrina et al. “Contextual Research.” In: Kurosu, M. (eds) Human-Computer Interaction. Design and User Experience. HCII 2020. Lecture Notes in Computer Science, vol 12181. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-49059-1_3. ↩︎
  179. As part of their creative and design studies, students should become familiar with the term “ethnography” and its basic aims and methods within anthropology. See: AIGA and Cheskin, “An Ethnography Primer.” 2007, https://www.scribd.com/doc/46873341/Ethnography-Primer. ↩︎
  180. Maeda, John. The Laws of Simplicity. MIT Press, 2006. ↩︎
  181. “Apple design chief Jonathan Ive is knighted.” BBC, 2012 May 23, https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-18171093. ↩︎
  182. Silberling, Amanda. “Apple has now sold 3 billion iPhones.” TechCrunch, 2025 July 31, https://techcrunch.com/2025/07/31/apple-has-now-sold-three-billion-iphones/. ↩︎
  183. Frenchman, Dennis et al. Designing the X. SA+P Press, 2025, p. 86. ↩︎
  184. Ibid., 89–126. ↩︎
  185. Alexiou, Katerina et al. eds. Embracing Complexity in Design. Routledge, 2010. ↩︎
  186. Johnson, Jeffrey. “Embracing design in complexity.” in Alexiou, Katerina et al. eds. Embracing Complexity in Design. Routledge, 2010, p. 193. ↩︎
  187. “Don Norman.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 1 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don_Norman. ↩︎
  188. Norman, Donald. Living with Complexity. MIT Press, 2016, p. 265 ↩︎
  189. Fayard, Anne-Laure, and Sarah Fathallah. “Design Thinking Misses the Mark.” Stanford Social Innovation Review 22, no. 1 (2023): 28–35. https://doi.org/10.48558/G6HQ-RZ22. ↩︎
  190. Ibid., p. 30. ↩︎
  191. “Edgar Morin.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 3 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edgar_Morin. ↩︎
  192. Morin, Edgar. On Complexity. Hampton Press, 2008, p. 2. ↩︎
  193. Ibid. ↩︎
  194. In another reference from Roger Martin’s 2009 book The Opposable Mind, the author states, “Experience enables us to hone our sensitivities and skills.” Martin goes on to define sensitivity as “the capacity to make distinctions between conditions that are similar but not exactly the same, ” while describing skill as “the capacity to carry out an activity so as to consistently produce the desired result.” See: Martin, Roger. The Opposable Mind. Harvard Business School Publishing, 2009, p. 100. ↩︎
  195. In Positioning: The Battle for Your Mind, Al Reis and Jack Trout use ladders as a metaphor to describe product categories and brands in the audience’s mind. See: Reis, Al and Jack Trout. Positioning. McGraw-Hill, 2001. ↩︎
  196. The Wikipedia entry on “Literacy” lists 15 variants, from financial literacy to musical literacy. See: “Literacy.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 25 Nov 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literacy. ↩︎
  197. See: Kalantzis, M. and Cope, B. (2025), Literacy in the Time of Artificial Intelligence. Reading Research Quarterly, 60: e591. https://doi.org/10.1002/rrq.591. ↩︎
  198. Ibid. ↩︎
  199. Howells, Richard, and Joaquim Negreiros. Visual Culture. 3rd ed., Polity, 2019, p. 8. ↩︎
  200. See: “The Hay Wain.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 28 Sep 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hay_Wain. ↩︎
  201. Howells and Negreiros, p. 17. ↩︎
  202. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  203. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  204. See: “Codex.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 2 Sep 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Codex.
    ↩︎
  205. See: “The Weaving of Words.” Chetham’s Library, 19 Dec. 2025. https://library.chethams.com/blog/a-weaving-of-words/. ↩︎
  206. Cross, Nigel. “Creativity in Design: Analyzing and Modeling the Creative Leap.” Leonardo, vol. 30, no. 4, 1997, p. 311. ↩︎
  207. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  208. In Steve Jobs’ talk at the 1983 International Design Conference in Aspen, Jobs notes that with books and reading, he did not have “an intermediary in the way” and that books get “right to the destination without anything in the middle.” See: Jobs, Steve. “Steve Jobs talk at the 1983 International Design Conference in Aspen.” YouTube, uploaded by David Krasniy, 17 July 2024, https://youtu.be/yHB_5WmRbho. ↩︎
  209. My former colleague, Geoffrey T. Freeman, FAIA, penned the still-frequently-referenced landmark paper, “The Library as Place: Changes in Learning Patterns, Collections, Technology, and Use.” In his paper, Freeman noted that “Upon entering the library, the student becomes part of a larger community—a community that endows one with a greater sense of self and higher purpose. Students inform us that they want their library to ‘feel bigger than they are.’” (p. 6). See: Freeman, Geoffrey T. “The Library as Place,” in Library as Place: Rethinking Roles, Rethinking Space, Council on Library and Information Resources, 2005. ↩︎
  210. Bone, Jessica K., et. al. “The decline in reading for pleasure over 20 years of the American Time Use Survey.” iScience, vol. 28, no. 9, 2025, 10.1016/j.isci.2025.113288. ↩︎
  211. Wolf, Maryanne. Reader Come Home. Harper, 2018. ↩︎
  212. Donald Schön.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 2 Mar 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Schön. ↩︎
  213. Schön, Donald A. The reflective practitioner: how professionals think in action. Basic Books, 1983. ↩︎
  214. A quick search for books titled “The Art of Conversation” yields over a dozen titles. ↩︎
  215. See: “Trivium.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 10 Dec 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trivium. ↩︎
  216. “Trivium.” Oxford Reference, 12 Dec. 2025, https://www.oxfordreference.com. ↩︎
  217. “Sherry Turkle” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 1 Jul 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherry_Turkle. ↩︎
  218. Turkle, Sherry. Reclaiming Conversation. Penguin Press, 2015, pp. 244–247. ↩︎
  219. Ibid., p. 246. ↩︎
  220. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  221. Mages, Michael Arnold. Conversational Design. BIS Publishers, 2024: p. 2. ↩︎
  222. Ibid., p. 3. ↩︎
  223. See: “Karl Popper.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 1 Mar 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karl_Popper. ↩︎
  224. Popper, Karl L. Objective Knowledge: An Evolutionary Approach. Oxford, 1972. ↩︎
  225. Ibid., p. 207. ↩︎
  226. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  227. Ibid., p. 210. ↩︎
  228. Müller-Brockmann popularized the grid in this seminal book, Grid Systems in Graphic Design, first published in 1981. Müller-Brockmann’s book remains one of the most popular and influential design books in history. It is still used by designers today to achieve structure, modularity, responsiveness, and visual harmony. See: Müller-Brockmann, Josef. Grid Systems in Graphic Design: A Visual Communication Manual for Graphic Designers, Typographers and Three Dimensional Designers. Arthur Niggli, 1981. ↩︎
  229. While the phrase “form follows function” became a mid-20th-century battle cry of the Bauhaus and the International Style, a variant of the phrase was used as early as 1896 by the American architect Louis H. Sullivan. In an article titled “The Tall Office Building Artistically Considered,” Sullivan used the phrase “form ever follows function” to describe the “modern office building.” See: Sullivan, Louis H., “The Tall Office Building Artistically Considered.” Lippincott’s Magazine 57 (March 1896), pp. 403-409. ↩︎
  230. See: “Modernism.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 3 Mar 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modernism. ↩︎
  231. Levitt, Theodore. “Creativity Is Not Enough.” Harvard Business Review, vol. 41, no. 3, 1963, pp. 72–83. ↩︎
  232. Popper, p. 226. ↩︎
  233. For many years, I have used this as the basis for a short essay prompt that asks students to pick one thing they find useful, one thing they find beautiful, and one thing they believe is both useful and beautiful. If comfortable doing so, students are then asked to share what they picked in a group conversation. ↩︎
  234. See: Vlahos, Dan and Steven Cotroneo. “Towards a Dynamic Discipline of Design” in Edited Conference Proceedings of the 2025 Motion Design Education Summit, June 19-21, 2025: edited by Jessica Barness et al., MODE Society, 2025, pp. 169-186. ↩︎
  235. The Miles Davis Quintet, “If I Were A Bell,” released March 1958, track 1 on Relaxin’ with the Miles Davis Quintet, Prestige Records, vinyl LP. ↩︎
  236. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  237. See “Discovery” in An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains. ↩︎
  238. In the entry for “newness,” the Cambridge Dictionary provides three definitions that vary based on intent: the first definition places emphasis on “recent creation” or time, the second suggests “difference” versus similarity, and the third emphasizes “unfamiliarity.” See: Cambridge Dictionary, s.v. “Newness,” accessed November 17, 2024, https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/newness. ↩︎
  239. Chattopadhyay, Debabrata and B.N. Srivastava, “The concept of newness,” Int. J. Management Concepts and Philosophy 2, no. 3 (2007). ↩︎
  240. Ibid., 244. ↩︎
  241. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  242. Osborn, Alex F. Applied Imagination. Scribners, [1953] 1997). ↩︎
  243. Ibid., ix. ↩︎
  244. Ibid., 397. ↩︎
  245. Loc. cit. ↩︎
  246. “C. P. Snow.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 4 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C._P._Snow. ↩︎
  247. “Rede Lecture.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 24 April 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rede_Lecture. ↩︎
  248. Snow, C. P. The Two Cultures and A Second Look. Cambridge University Press, 1964, p. 61. ↩︎
  249. Ibid., 62. ↩︎
  250. Ibid., 64. ↩︎
  251. Ibid., 70. ↩︎
  252. Gilman, Nils. “How To Future-Proof Your Career In The Age Of AI,” Noema, April 9, 2026. https://www.noemamag.com/why-a-liberal-arts-education-will-soon-be-more-valuable-than-ever/. ↩︎
  253. Ibid. ↩︎
  254. Ibid. ↩︎
  255. See: “Janus.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 25 February 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Janus. ↩︎
  256. Porter, Burton. The Janus Face of Ideas. Academica Press, 2019: ix. ↩︎
  257. Ibid. ↩︎
  258. Just as this list was being drafted, Robin Landa released Branding as a Cultural Force: Purpose, Responsibility, & Resonance, which provides “a roadmap for identifying and refining branding strategies and creative solutions that create positive cultural impact.” (p. 3) See: Landa, Robin. Branding as a Cultural Force. Columbia Business School, 2026. ↩︎
  259. This list-maker also wishes to note Thomas Frank’s 1997 book The Conquest of Cool. Frank’s book offered a sharp critique of 1960s culture (or counter-culture) oriented marketing. Ultimately, the book asserts that the “cool” culture of the 1960s became the ultimate tool of consumerism, turning rebellion into a way to sell more products. See: Frank, Thomas. The Conquest of Cool. University of Chicago Press, 1997. ↩︎
  260. Paney, Panos A. and R. Michael Hendrix, Two Beats Ahead. PublicAffairs, 2021, p. 4. ↩︎
  261. Ibid. ↩︎
  262. Ibid. ↩︎
  263. Giudice, Maria, and Christopher Ireland. Rise of the DEO: Leadership by Design, New Riders, 2014, p. 16. ↩︎
  264. Ibid. ↩︎
  265. Simon, H. A. The Sciences of the Artificial (3rd ed.). MIT Press, 1996. p. 111. ↩︎
  266. Mau, Bruce, and The Institute with Boundaries. Massive Change. Phaidon, 2004. p. 16. ↩︎
  267. Brown, Tim. Change by Design (2nd ed.). Harper Business, 2019 [2009], p. 77. ↩︎
  268. Striegler, Sara Gry, and Julie Hjort, Navigating Societal Change Through Design. Policy Press, 2025, p. 60. ↩︎
  269. Bowen, José Antonio. Teaching Change. Johns Hopkins University Press, 2021. p. 46. ↩︎
  270. See: “Heraclitus.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 25 February 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heraclitus. ↩︎
  271. See: “Parmenides.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 2 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parmenides. ↩︎

An Illustrative Introduction to a Curious Compendium of Incomplete Lists for Productive Practice, 2026–Present.

An Illustrative Introduction to a Curious Compendium of Incomplete Lists for Productive Practice by Dan Vlahos - Cover

An Illustrative Introduction to a Curious Compendium of Incomplete Lists for Productive Practice offers readers a concise introduction to a three-part, word-list-themed, literature-review-style essay series that explores and extends late-20th- and early-21st-century calls to interrogate and elevate the importance and value of creativity, projects, and design. ¶ While each word list is preceded by a short introduction, this prelude frames a handful of ideas, insights, and inspirations that underpin the series as a whole. Together, the three lists provide taxonomy, or field guide among field guides1 for exploring human intelligence and productive practice2 (HIaPP) in the age of artificial intelligence (AI). As such, these letter-themed word lists provide an introductory set of “big tent” practices, terms, methods, and principles commonly explored and used by architects, artists, designers, curators, writers, musicians, and more.

Links to all three word lists are provided below:

  1. An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course
  2. An Incomplete List of D-Words for Designerly Domains
  3. An Incomplete List of P-Words for Project-Based Pursuits

Foreword by Julio Mario Ottino


There is something wonderfully appropriate about an “incomplete” list. A complete list closes a subject; an incomplete one opens it. It invites us to add, question, connect, wander, and discover what might be missing. I am particularly pleased to write a foreword to this project because I recognize its spirit.

One of its inspirations is Bruce Mau’s Incomplete Manifesto for Growth, and Bruce has been my collaborator and friend for many years. Mau’s manifesto was never really a set of instructions. It was an invitation to see differently, to experiment, to grow, and to take responsibility for the possibilities that emerge along the way.

Dan Vlahos takes that spirit in an intriguing direction. His c-, d-, and p-word lists are not intended to provide definitive answers about creativity, design, or projects. They function more like a field guide: devices for entering a large and sometimes unfamiliar territory. The alphabetical structure gives the reader a starting point, but the real value lies in the connections it encourages – between disciplines, practices, ideas, and ways of thinking.

That openness matters. At a time when knowledge is increasingly abundant and readily accessible, the challenge is not simply to know more. It is to develop the curiosity and discernment to make connections, cross boundaries, and ask what might be possible.

Think of these lists, then, not as inventories but as invitations. They are deliberately incomplete because the most interesting part of any intellectual journey is what happens beyond the map.

And that, I suspect, is exactly the point.

Julio Mario Ottino
McCormick School of Engineering and Applied Science and Kellogg School of Management
Northwestern University
Author of The Nexus: The New Convergence of Art, Technology, and Science
August 2026


An Introduction to the Introduction by Dan Vlahos


This Curious Compendium of Incomplete Lists for Productive Practice was partly inspired by a manifesto written by Bruce Mau3 in the late 1990s. Originally from Canada, Mau is a multidisciplinary designer, educator, and creative leader. Mau’s practice has served as a guiding light for this designer, and one can confidently assume the same for many of his generation. In 1998, while living in Toronto, Mau’s sister invited him to contribute an essay to a small magazine she had planned to produce. Mau seized the opportunity and penned a reflective manifesto as he pondered how he might “sustain a lifelong practice.”4 Mau intuitively titled this discursive treatise “An Incomplete Manifesto for Growth.” Looking back on it, Mau once stated:

I reflected on my own patterns of living and working, and asked myself: What is really valuable here? How might these patterns be helpful to others? Can we learn from the unusual studio culture that we have created? I realized that many of my contemporaries were taking responsibility for the information they produced but not for its impact. They were committed to the form but not the content. I understood that the task of designers is less to inform people than to move them. Our role is to inspire.5

Mau then presented his manifesto at a design conference in Amsterdam, which led Chee Pearlman to invite him to publish it in I.D. magazine.6 Over the next 20 years, Mau and his countless collaborators went on to design a wide range of projects not limited to books, brands, exhibitions, environments, and more. Long before the present-day notion of “collabs,”7 Mau and his team members, clients, and collaborators seemed to exemplify this creative-collaborative spirit. As chronicled in a namesake 2021 documentary film,8 Mau has helped shape brands, institutions, museums, regional plans, and more. ¶ In a 2012 guest lecture at the Harvard Graduate School of Design—Mau reflected upon this multifaceted body of work—giving such varied work the informal label “context projects.”9 By using context as a frame, Mau and countless designers who similarly elevate contextual factors10 in the process of design situate their work not only by the “what” of design (the artifact, experience, communication, etc) but also the multivariate factors that shape, inform, and surround the what. This effectively centers design—not as a standalone area of concern—but as an integrative point of departure, reference, focus, and return that can be shared and shaped among various stakeholders and disciplines. Not surprisingly, both collaboration and context are but two of the c-words you will find in my Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course. ¶ It is important to note that centering creativity, projects, and design is not the singular goal of these lists. For this list-maker, elevating, expanding, and increasing access to these ideas and their histories is a greater focus. But of course, any overview or history told from a single perspective is inherently incomplete. As Lesley Lokko wisely stated in her Introduction to the 2023 Venice Biennale, “The ‘story’ of architecture is therefore incomplete. Not wrong, but incomplete.”11

The Problems at Present and recentering design

This list maker first introduced his Compendium at the 2026 AIGA Design Educators Community (DEC) Conference in Ohio. In his talk, this author identified five interconnected design-oriented challenges that his lists seek to address: 1) the design-dependency dearth-discourse dilemma, 2) the steadfast siloization of studios and scholars, 3) the resistance to a rigorous reading renaissance, 4) the lax lexical legacy logjam, and 5) the pay-to-play publication problem. ¶ The first point [the “design-dependency dearth-discourse dilemma”] underscores and seeks to describe our present-day human-design relational condition, whereby in the 21st century all humans are literally surrounded by design, yet (outside of design and design education) most are unfamiliar with designerly methods, principles, processes, or impacts. Put another way, while our tools and skills are being radically democratized, the principles and discourses of design (as compared with our tools of production) seem to be suffering from unequal access and attention. From a critical and historical perspective, a slightly different iteration of the same design-oriented dilemma seems to apply. For instance, in a 2015 paper, Wayne A. Williams and Janice Rieger aptly refer to perspectives shared by Helen Charman as they make a similar claim, stating, “Helen Charman explored this when she wrote that, despite the extent to which our lives are infused with and shaped by design, it is not a subject accorded much critical attention, certainly not when compared to art criticism.”12 ¶ The second point [the “steadfast siloization of studios and scholars”] highlights a concern that, in academia, design, and beyond, there is now a vast disconnect across disciplines. For example, a typical undergraduate graphic design student might now encounter architectural vocabularies and even architectural plans as if they were a foreign language. Moreover, some fear that a lack of understanding or exposure to a variety of fields may limit a student’s problem-solving capacity and epistemological breadth. ¶ The third point [the “resistance to rigorous reading renaissance”] suggests that some, but not all, students now seem resistant to long-form, theoretical, or challenging readings: especially theory. This resistance, exemplified by the now-common TL;DR acronym,13 persists despite a more-than-ever pressing need for students to engage in critical reading and writing as essential modes of critical thought. Put another way, reading long-form text helps cultivate the habits of designerly discernment that are becoming most salient in design. ¶ The fourth challenge explored in this list is what this list-maker has termed the lax lexical legacy logjam. This challenge surfaces in at least two situations explored here: our [designers’] use of broad terms without specificity or clarity, and our lack of domain-specific language to further substantiate or demarcate our “space.” ¶ The fifth challenge, what this list-maker has described as “the pay-to-play publication problem,” might in some ways be viewed as a “triple-tax” on knowledge and scholarship. As a mid-career academic, this list-maker was initially puzzled by the common practice of journals that charge publication fees to authors and scholars who want their work published. Worse still, some of these journals and publishers then place articles and other scholarship behind paywalls. In the worst case, the scholar pays, the editor(s) pay (by sometimes serving as an editor for prestige, but for free), and readers pay too. ¶ On Design-Centered Design ¶ These five challenges are united by a single claim or “thread” that spans a range of “deep [or expert] design” to diffuse14 [non-expert] design: that design is an uncommon integrative-dynamic space that can effectively center and de-center ideas, expertise, projects, challenges, and more. Because nearly anything can be “centered,” such a claim may seem vast (as the incomplete titling of these lists indicates). But as some readers have witnessed and others will encounter anew here, over the past 50 years we have witnessed the emergence of countless hyphenated variants of x-centered or x-based design methods, from user-centered design to evidence-based design to human-centered design, to life-centered design, and more. Now, paradoxically, such ideas may reconverge in what we might, in non-paternalistic 21st-century terms, call “design-centered design.” Again, one might reactively counter that this logic could equally yield or facilitate the notion of everything-centered design—and thus “vanilla” design. This all-too-common reactive trap conflates design as a final destination, rather than its more salient use here: an intellectual “space.” ¶ On Design-Centered Design as Integrative Challenge Space ¶ Since so many outside of design have sought to lay claims on design, this list-maker’s notion of “design-centered design” will face fierce scrutiny, roadblocks, and challenges. As such, it will require renewed solidarity around design as an independent, inclusive, integrative, and shared “challenge space.” The stewards who meaningfully invest time and energy in the study, practice, and understanding of this independent-inclusive space of design will thus be best suited to lead others in design as a shared “challenge space.” Beyond this, we face the obvious difficulty of overcoming the steadfast siloization common across industry and academia. As Pope John Paul II noted in 1990, “Integration of knowledge is a process, one which will always remain incomplete; moreover, the explosion of knowledge in recent decades, together with the rigid compartmentalization of knowledge within individual academic disciplines, makes the task increasingly difficult.”15|16On Design-Centered Design as Integrative Challenge Space as Mechanism for Academic Innovation ¶ Throughout these lists there appears a constant dialogic connection between creative, project-based, and design-oriented discourses and how we might use and apply these principles not only to bolster and inform our projects, but also our learning. While these ideas have long been explored, researched, and enacted, they seem to be gaining greater recent attention because of shifts in access, value, and focus across education. For instance, in a recent article, Courtney Brown, the Lumina Foundation’s current vice president of impact and planning, stated that, “Employers are hiring for the things that AI can’t do. They’re putting a premium on judgment, critical thinking, communication, and adaptability. They value those skills you gain by getting degrees.”17 ¶ It is at this intersection of design and education that we encountered a whole host of issues that seem to live on two sides of the same coin: the p-word section on portfolios,18 in which readers learn about the role of the portfolio in 20th-century design, the c-word sections on conversation, collaboration, and curiosity, and the d-word sections exploring discovery, divergence, data, and more.

Read This

A second, somewhat more personal and abstract point of inspiration for these lists arrived in the mid-2000s. Around this time, I had just started working in the marketing department of a Boston-based architecture firm. Just as I started at the firm, the office was relocating to a two-floor self-designed open-plan space in Boston’s Seaport. Upon arriving at the office, as the architects and support staff unpacked, I, like everyone else in the firm, received a desk, a file cabinet, a computer, and a brand-new Aeron office chair (produced by Herman Miller). Attached to each Aeron chair was a small magenta booklet with crisp knockout serifed type on the front that read, “Read this while adjusting your Aeron chair.” (Fig. 1) ¶ By this time, the Aeron chair19 had become a (albeit somewhat corporate) symbol associated with those who worked in creative or “creative class”20 fields. Akin to opening a fortune cookie, this list maker somehow expected the manual to offer some kind of inspiration, insight, philosophy, or encouragement. In hindsight, this false expectation of an instruction manual seems quite odd. ¶ My best rationalization of this divergent mishap may lie in what I had come to perceive about the Herman Miller “brand.” In design history circles, Herman Miller has long been viewed as a pioneering, design-centric organization.21 I must confess that I was at least somewhat disappointed to encounter a typical, step-by-step chair-adjustment instruction manual. ¶ Many years later, I asked myself: what was it (beyond instructions) that I was expecting to find within that chair-adjustment booklet? I began to imagine a dialogic treatise for the creative occupant of these then futuristic-looking chairs. I then also recalled the independent, sometimes subversive zines22 I had encountered while in art school. As a graphic design student, I found the “non-design” quality of these zines refreshing and fascinating. In the spirit of these zines, I wondered whether the Aeron chair manual could give the chair a symbolic or contemplative quality, perhaps much like Rodin’s Thinker,23 the chair or act of sitting might symbolize introspection? ¶ Alas, my off-beat “instruction manual” ponderings ended quite quickly when a work order for a client proposal arrived on my desk. I share this odd memory here because, in part, the lists that follow may well be or represent the imagined contents of that never-produced zine-like chair manual.

Watch This

A more recent point of inspiration for these lists were the Tanner Lectures on Human Values. As a multi-university lecture series in the humanities, the Tanner Lectures were founded in 1978 by the American scholar and philanthropist Obert Clark Tanner.24 Fortunately, many of these lectures are available online and can be watched for free. The lecture that most directly inspired this series was delivered in 2024 by Rachel Barney, Professor of both Classics and Philosophy at the University of Toronto. Barney has been teaching at the university level for over 30 years. Her research has “ranged from the early sophists to the late Neoplatonic commentator Simplicius,” but primarily focuses on Plato.25 Barney’s Tanner Lectures, delivered over three consecutive days at UC Berkeley, were titled “The Authority of Craft.”26 ¶ Before hitting play on Barney’s lectures, I wondered how one might approach delivering anything cogent or substantive with a topic as broad and multifaceted as craft. But Barney’s approach to the lecture itself was quite masterful. At the outset of her talk, instead of diving headlong into scholarship, Barney began with a memorable story. The story takes place in New York City, where, as Barney recalls, her wealthy aunt stops to observe a skilled wallpaper hanger at work in a hotel lobby. The aunt then asks the worker if they can watch him paper the wall. In response to Barney’s aunt, the worker says, “Lady, does Joe DiMaggio mind if you watch?” This story immediately immerses the listener and, more importantly, frames the broad topic of craft in a memorable way. Then Barney proceeds to explore the broad humanistic qualities and tensions of craft through a multi-pronged mix of historical, divergent, and convergent approaches. In this way, like a hawk scoping its prey from high above, Barney triangulates the topic from multiple angles before diving in. At around the 17-minute mark, Barney states plainly that craft is an endlessly vast subject. As Barney states, craft is “a very big tent.”27

the stakes

In a 2026 article published by Fast Company, Grace Snelling poses the question: “Can ‘Applied Creativity’ be the next ‘Design Thinking?'”28 In the article, Snelling points to recent research that suggests that in the AI era, creativity may in fact be one of the most essential assets an executive can have.29 At first, this assertion may seem odd; after all, isn’t AI lowering the bar on creativity? While not explicitly addressed in the article, the opposite may actually be closer to the truth. In fact, as Snelling’s article unfolds, a glaring “gap” emerges: creativity is at once a highly desired skill, a literacy, and a competency, yet few embrace or understand it. Moreover, while executives say they value creativity, only a small percentage of highly innovative firms seem to successfully implement and understand creative principles, methods, or processes—and, as a result, creativity, a key pillar of value and innovation, often gets sidelined. ¶ As we ponder such gaps, we will explore various notions of practice across several disciplines but with a focus on three intersecting ideas: creativity, design, and projects. These three areas are explored at a level akin to general education literacies. One way to posit the “who” these lists are geared towards is to reflect on what the late Virgil Abloh30 (1980–2021) once described as “tourists” versus “purists.” In a 2017 guest lecture31 at Harvard’s Graduate School of Design, Abloh metaphorically cast the notion of design for everyday people, or real people, as “tourists”—those who are curious, creative but perhaps not formally educated in art, architecture, culture, or design. Abloh seems to contrast or complement tourists with “purists”—those who formally research, study, or understand cultural and aesthetic context, techniques, and works. With Abloh’s notion of tourists and purists in mind, this list-maker might contend that these lists might appeal to both groups, but as an undergraduate instructor, they are weighted towards the tourist. ¶ In response to the three concerns noted earlier, the stakes are likewise threefold: 1) these essential discourses could sadly remain the realm of purists, and thus educators will abandon a whole swath of the populace in regard to creative, design, and project-based literacies and competencies. 2) Our silos will remain siloed, or worse, they may deepen, and 3) the resistance to a rigorous reading renaissance might claim victory—over what alternatively could be a radical resurgence and renaissance towards rigorous reading. As the Hungarian-born painter, photographer, designer, educator, and art theorist György Kepes32 (1906–2001) noted back in 1944, “To function in his fullest scope man must restore the unity of his experience so that he can register sensory, emotional, and intellectual dimensions of the present in an indivisible whole.”33

The [working] Thesis

With Abloh’s notion of tourists and purists in mind, and also Barney’s framing device of the “very big tent” in view, these lists aim to parse common and, in some cases, less common perspectives for those interested in creativity, projects, and design. Beyond this exploratory mission, as the “Problem at Present” section above indicates, this list maker also particularly places continual emphasis on the potentially powerful role of, and challenges around, design as an increasingly important 21st-century “tent”—a tent elevated in the service (as it has been for some time) of developing better products and experiences—but also in thinking more broadly about how we [all disciplines] frame our thinking around challenges and creatively enact them through projects. These ideas are especially salient in the rapidly shifting spaces of education. While ideas around challenge-based learning,34 project-based learning,35 problem-based learning,36 and other flavors of active learning37 have steadily gained more pedagogical attention, they could use, or sometimes require, the insight and perspective of those who have practiced and lived these modalities for years: designers and the designerly. As such, this calls for a re-evaluation of design in particular, and moreover a cohort of those with knowledge of design (this list-maker included) to reveal methods and dynamics that have been “tacit” for far too long. It is thus time to demystify the complex nature of projects, design, and creative collaboration.

While Rachel Barney’s talk serves as a convenient reference point for this introduction, nearly any Tanner Lecture might lead one to contemplate “big-tent” humanistic ideas and issues.38 As we ponder the incompleteness of this journey, I am reminded of the title of a 2009 paper by design educator Geoffry Fried. Fried’s somewhat obscure paper, first delivered at the International Association of Societies of Design Research conference in 2009, was appropriately titled “Chasing Infinity: Defining the Purpose of Design.” With his use of “infinity” in the title of his paper, Fried likewise acknowledges the impossibly vast “big-tent” nature of his subject. With this in mind, I encourage readers to join this list maker in squaring off with this task. Along these lines, this list-maker recalls a conversation from 2023. In an exchange titled “New Education Pathways for Future Designers in a Changing World,” Valentina De Matteo et al. grappled with two intertwined issues: 1) “how designers can apply their peculiar ‘productive thinking’ to educational spheres or other forms of organizations”39 and 2) “how a non-hegemonic approach to design education could introduce new perspectives on future experiences.”40 The authors’ use of “productive thinking” as used in the first statement can, in this specific case, be attributed41 to Flaviano Celaschi et al. While it may seem somewhat daunting in the conversation and resultant paper, De Matteo et al. grapple with how such design-oriented productive thought might map to education and “to other forms of organizations, to produce impactful changes.” Then, citing a range of recent scholarship, the authors briefly parse the possibility of (or for) “collaborative, inclusive, transdisciplinary and collective learning system[s].”42 ¶ Outside of these isolated, like-minded conversations, the convergence of these two concerns has, in this list maker’s view, received insufficient attention. In the mainstream, scholars and practitioners who have championed such ideas have received far less attention than the “celebrity designers” who design fashionable products. This may, however, be changing. As but one example, in 2026 the well-known documentary filmmaker Gary Hustwit43 turned his attention away from the product-, culture-, and form-oriented focus of his prior films and instead placed his lens upon a legend of design-oriented productive thought and strategy—Patrick Whitney.44 Whitney served as the long-time Dean of the Institute of Design (ID) at the Illinois Institute of Technology (IIT)—serving from 1987 to 2016—where he expanded programs in design research, strategic design, and human-centered methodologies. Despite Whitney’s advancement of design as a field and his founding of the first design research-oriented PhD in the US, for this list-makers generation of designers and educators Whitney had for far too long remained a relatively unknown figure. Said another way, many designers could tell you who designed the ABC logo,45 but not as many could tell you who developed the first North American PhD program in design.

An Invitation

Thus, these lists serve as an invitation to join Abloh, Barney, Fried, Mau, Whitney, this list-maker, and a global community of designers, strategists, thinkers, and makers who have (and are) opening up human creativity, human potential, and productive thinking in the service of imagining positive, productive, and healthy futures. ¶ Here, this list-maker’s students often ask the obvious question: how or where do I start? To this, this list-maker says, “pick a tent” and explore it productively, then discover the tents within that tent.46 As Bruce Mau stated in the very first point of his manifesto, “You have to be willing to grow. Growth is different from something that happens to you. You produce it. You live it.”47 Said another way, you are what you eat.48

Amor vincit omnia.

With utmost gratitude to the many voices cited and referenced. First published 1 Apr 2026. Last updated 5 Nov 2026. Please send edits, corrections, and suggestions to this address.


Footnotes

  1. See also: Jones, Derek et al. Studio Properties: A field guide to design education. Bloomsbury, 2025. ↩︎
  2. See reference to “productive thinking” below. ↩︎
  3. See: “Bruce Mau.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 3 June 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruce_Mau. ↩︎
  4. “IMFG,” Bruce Mau Studio, https://brucemaustudio.com/projects/an-incomplete-manifesto-for-growth/. ↩︎
  5. Ibid. ↩︎
  6. Ibid. ↩︎
  7. One of Bruce Mau’s most remarkable and celebrated “collabs” was the 1997 book S,M,L,XL—a 1376-page volume that was the result of a multiple-year intense partnership between Mau and Rem Koolhaas (founder of the Dutch architectural firm Office for Metropolitan Architecture or “O.M.A”). See: Koolhaas, Rem, and Bruce Mau. S, M, L, XL. The Monacelli Press, 1997. ↩︎
  8. Mau. Directed by Benji Bergmann and Jono Bergmann, Greenwich Entertainment, 2021. ↩︎
  9. See: Mau, Bruce. “2012 Class Day Lecture,” YouTube. May 24, 2012, video, 33:00, https://youtu.be/K3Q5bjDOYoQ?list=PL309451B70B1DE1FF. ↩︎
  10. In design education, the most prominent of these contextual factors over the course of this list maker’s career has been human factors, sometimes called “human-centered design.” Over time, however, architects and designers seem to be becoming more adept at navigating the complexity of multivariate factors beyond human-centered concerns alone. ↩︎
  11. Lokko, Lesley. “Introduction.” La Biennale di Venezia, 2023, http://www.labiennale.org/en/architecture/2023/introduction-lesley-lokko. ↩︎
  12. Williams, Wayne A., and Janice Rieger. “A Design History of Design: Complexity, Criticality, and Cultural Competence.” RACAR : Revue d’art canadienne, vol. 40, no. 2, 2015, p. 16. https://doi.org/10.7202/1035392ar. ↩︎
  13. “TL;DR.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 28 April 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TL;DR. ↩︎
  14. “Diffuse design.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 7 Aug 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffuse_design. ↩︎
  15. John Paul II, Pope. Ex Corde Ecclesiae. Apostolic Constitution, 15 Aug. 1990. Vatican, www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/apost_constitutions/documents/hf_jp-ii_apc_15081990_ex-corde-ecclesiae.html. ↩︎
  16. This passage was cited at a 2014 colloquium celebrating the 10th Anniversary of the Center for Ethics and Culture at Notre Dame, led by the Scottish-American philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre (1929–2025). See: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mCwKdkW6-lw. ↩︎
  17. Palmer, Kathryn. “Employers Say AI Will Make College Degrees More Important.” Inside Higher Ed, 20 Oct. 2026,www.insidehighered.com/news/students/careers/2026/10/20/employers-say-ai-will-make-college-degrees-more-important
    ↩︎
  18. See: “Portfolios” in An Incomplete List of P-Words for Project-Based Pursuits. ↩︎
  19. The Aeron chair was designed by Don Chadwick and Bill Stumpf, who began working on it in the late 1970s, only to have early iterations canceled. The Aeron went on to become one of the best-selling individual office chairs in the world. ↩︎
  20. The notion of the “creative class” is largely attributed to Richard Florida, an American urban studies theorist and author. An overview of Florida and his work is included in the Introduction section of An Incomplete List of C-Words for the Creative Course. ↩︎
  21. As a graphic designer, I have always admired Stephen Frykholm’s well-known and nearly timeless picnic posters for Herman Miller. These lovely screen-printed picnic posters spanned twenty years and can be found in art museums around the world. The poster series serves as an example that even the smallest project, such as a company picnic, can be elevated through creativity, craft, humanism, and design. ↩︎
  22. “Zine” is shorthand for fanzine. Zines are often used to promote music, bands, and culture. Many zines use low-cost or rudimentary production techniques (photocopiers, typewriters, collage, pens, markers, glue, tape, etc.). ↩︎
  23. “The Thinker.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 29 Sep 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Thinker. ↩︎
  24. “Tanner Lectures on Human Values.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 2 August 2025, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tanner_Lectures_on_Human_Values. ↩︎
  25. “Rachel Barney.” University of Toronto, 17 Oct 2025, https://philosophy.utoronto.ca/directory/rachel-barney/. ↩︎
  26. “Rachel Barney | Tanner Lectures.” Berkeley Tanner Lectures, https://tannerlectures.berkeley.edu/rachel-barney/. ↩︎
  27. Barney, Rachel. “Tanner Lectures on Human Values with Rachel Barney: Lecture I – The End of Craft.” YouTube, uploaded by UC Berkeley Events, 4 May 2024, https://youtu.be/chDcuJmqBjc. ↩︎
  28. Snelling, Grace. “Can ‘Applied Creativity’ be the next ‘Design Thinking?’.” Fast Company, 18 June 2026, https://www.fastcompany.com/91560629/applied-creativity-accenture-song-report. ↩︎
  29. Ibid. ↩︎
  30. “Virgil Abloh.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 16 July 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virgil_Abloh. ↩︎
  31. Abloh, Virgil. “Core Studio Public Lecture: Virgil Abloh, “Insert Complicated Title Here.” YouTube, uploaded by Harvard GSD, 30 Oct 2017, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qie5VITX6eQ. ↩︎
  32. “György Kepes.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 27 July 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/György_Kepes. ↩︎
  33. Kepes, György. Language of Vision. Paul Theobald and Company, 1959 [1944], p. 13. ↩︎
  34. See: “Challenge-based learning.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 18 July 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Challenge-based_learning. ↩︎
  35. See: “Project-based learning.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 23 Sep 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project-based_learning. ↩︎
  36. See: “Problem-based learning.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 13 Apr 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Problem-based_learning. ↩︎
  37. Center for Research on Learning and Teaching. “Introduction to Active Learning.” University of Michigan, https://crlt.umich.edu/active_learning_introduction. ↩︎
  38. Another wonderful “big-tent” example among many is Rowan Williams’ 2014 Tanner lecture, “The Paradoxes of Empathy.” Williams is a Welsh Anglican bishop, theologian, and poet who served as the 104th Archbishop of Canterbury from 2002 to 2012. Part 1 of Williams’ lecture can be found here: https://youtu.be/fdeoU0aJLX8. Part 2 can be viewed here: https://youtu.be/mQF_y24rZjY. ↩︎
  39. De Matteo, Valentina, et al. “New Education Pathways for Future Designers in a Changing World.” diid disegno industriale industrial design, Digital Special Issue 1, 2023, p. 696. ↩︎
  40. Ibid. ↩︎
  41. Celaschi, Flaviano, et al. “Thinking as a designer Productive Thinking in contemporary Knowledge Innovation System.” diid disegno industriale industrial design, no. 70/20, 2020, pp. 26–33. ↩︎
  42. Ibid., 697. ↩︎
  43. “Gary Hustwit.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 8 March 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gary_Hustwit. ↩︎
  44. Schusterbauer, Emily. “Whitney, Patrick.” Newsmakers 2006 Cumulation, Encyclopedia.com, 2006. Encyclopedia.com,www.encyclopedia.com/books/culture-magazines/whitney-patrick. ↩︎
  45. Paul Rand. See: “Paul Rand.” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 14 Oct 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Rand. ↩︎
  46. Along these lines, akin to discovering Barney’s lecture on YouTube, many excellent lectures can now be accessed online. For instance, I also discovered a masterful series of lectures on the history of philosophy by the late Dr. Arthur Holmes, which Wheaton College appears to have made public in 2015. See, for instance: Holmes, Arthur. “A History of Philosophy | 01 The Beginning of Greek Philosophy.” YouTube, uploaded by wheatoncollege, 2 April 2015, https://youtu.be/Yat0ZKduW18. ↩︎
  47. “IMFG,” Bruce Mau Studio, https://brucemaustudio.com/projects/an-incomplete-manifesto-for-growth/. ↩︎
  48. See point #10 in Chris Pullman’s 2008 essay “What I’ve Learned.” Available at: https://designobserver.com/what-ive-learned/. ↩︎